Wharton. McKinsey. UBS. Securities industry since '94. Asia ex-pat in '80s-90s. Elected to Mill Valley City Council in '20. Blocked by Zero Hedge since 2010.
1. There’s no PPT
2. The Fed has been hated for 105 years
3. High probabilities do not imply certainty
4. It can always be different this time
5. Things go up over time
6. We’re not all going to agree
The only modern comparable to now is 1987
- $SPX fell 20% in one day, rose 15% the next 2 days, then returned to the low the following week
- Then rose 15% again and then retested the original low 6 weeks later
- It was up 25% a year later and back at prior highs 2 years later
The single most important chart to understand the stock market. Gains happen 78% of the time. It's 6x more likely to gain >+15% than lose <-15%. You are hard wired to avoid risk and that's why almost everyone underperforms
When I used to write a monthly macro update, this was the precise point I'd made. You set your sails based on macro and trim based investor psychology. That’s how this works
At ATH: ‘market is overbought’
Down 5%: ‘it will fall 10%’
Down 10%: ‘it will fall 20%’
Up 5%: ‘bear market rally’
Up 10%: ‘it will retest low’
Up 15%: ‘low is in, now overbought'
$Vix under 15; it normally stays elevated during a bear market. Number of times it has fallen under 15 during an ongoing bear market in the past 30+ years: zero. More evidence the low in $Spx was two months ago
Not sure where the "$Vix must be +40 for there to be a low" comes from. 6 prior corrections of 10-20% since 2009, 3 bottomed <40. The 1990 bear market bottomed with $Vix at 36.
Tomorrow the FOMC is expected to raise rates for the first time in the current cycle. You’d have to go back before even the geezers on FinTwit were born to find a case where equities peaked BEFORE the first hike. Shown here is just the last 40+ years
This is the “low retest” that accompanies most market corrections. The trend is bearish, but the balance of evidence suggests this ultimately resolves in favor of the bulls. New from The Fat Pitch
Breadth: $NYMO -127 at the close. Last 20 years, only 2 closed lower. $SPX continued to sell off after each. This kind of momentum isn’t how lows in $SPX usually form
Exactly a year ago $SPX plunged 35% in 4 weeks (fastest ever!) and then jumped 70% so, yes, there has never been more 52 week highs than now. It’s a math thingy
A market that bottomed 9 days ago while cases rise and macro data worsens is a market that has stopped panicking and accepted that news will be bad for a while $NDX
Breadth has been so bad that Summation (momentum) will drop -1000 tomorrow, just the 6th time in 20 years. Marked the low in 2019 and 2009, the initial low in 2002 and the start of July 2008 rally. It also meant nothing during the Oct 2008 panic $spx
The current equity trend is being termed unprecedented; it’s not. It's also being called unsustainable, but in most prior cases, equities have continued higher. New from The Fat Pitch
If you bought the S&P in 1997 and held it for the next 20 years - a period which included two recessions and stock market crashes of 50% and 60%, the largest of the past 80 years - your return would still have been 300%
The bearish trend in equities should not be taken lightly. But the set up for higher prices, at least before a significantly lower low, appears strong. This is not a certainty, but it is a high probability. New from The Fat Pitch
Sentiment: Substantial -$22b outflow from equity MF + ETFs this past week. When this happens outside of December, at least a near-term rally is not far off (arrows) $SPX
In the past 50 years, 10-2 yield curve inversion has occurred an average/median of 19 months before the next recession and 12 months before the final peak in $SPX
Historically, a 3% dip takes place on average every 1-3/4 months and a 5% dip every 3-1/2 months. We haven't had more than a 2% dip in over 3-1/2 months $SPX
At its closing low, $SPX fell 25.5% in 2022. Almost all of that (93%) happened by mid-June. Since then, more sideways than down (i.e., a possible base). 4100 then 4300 key upside
This valuation chart from Bloomberg is making the rounds, showing that world equities are overvalued because they exceed world GDP, like 2007, 2017 and the start of this year
$SPX up 3 months in a row by >15%. Since 1980, 9 other instances. None was a top, all mostly were the initiation of an uptrend, but a few 3-7% corrections in the interim (circles)
2020 so far
Fastest bear market
Highest % down days
Fastest bull market
Shortest bear market
Highest % up days
Best 5 month gain
Fastest correction
4 months left. Good luck
The whole ‘people are going to forever leave big cities and telecommute from cheap suburbs’ strikes me as 1) being advanced by pundits who already live in suburbs (projection) and 2) the latest example of recency bias
Global fund managers:
- Overweight cash
- Equity allocations almost a standard deviation below avg
- Bond allocations at a 7 yr high
- View $USD as most overvalued in 16 yrs
New from The Fat Pitch
If you assume the stock market is fairly random (with a long term bias higher) and that you use fundamental and technical analyses to get a slight edge, you’ll be on the right track (and a lot happier)
World merchandise trade is set to plummet by btw 13 and 32% in 2020 - either of these numbers would be shocking & the range btw them is an indicator of our uncertainty right now.
@wto
basically saying we have no idea but its definitely terrible!
$SPX is down about 9% YTD. Anything can happen but, historically, for it to end the year with a loss like this, the economy would have to be in a recession (red circles) or the US in a world war. Chart from
@SethCL
; annotations are mine
Every rally in the past yr has stopped when $NYHL (10-dma) has gotten back to neutral (bottom panel). It'll be a useful confirmation of a new uptrend when it backs/stays above 0
$SPY up >8% this month AND above its 10-mma.
only 8 prior instances in 30 yrs, of which 2 were stinkers (2000 was a mega stinker, 2015 was a mini). The other 6 went zoom
Interest rates since 3,000 B.C.
Reflecting on the long-term data helps to keep things in perspective, and remind us what an unusual environment we've been in the past few years.
#macro
$SPY $ES $TLT
$SPX down 4 wks in a row. Only 11 instances in 14 yrs. Tends to rally the next wk Two exceptions: 2008 bear market and in 2011 when the 4 wk drop was less than 3% vs nearly 9% now
1. Trade war rhetoric is driving equities
2. Speculators now view continued volatility as a guaranteed bet (it’s not)
3. The end of the long 200-d streak for $SPX usually leads to very good returns
New from The Fat Pitch
If it was obvious that lumber was going to fall 70% and bitcoin was going to jump 30% you probably wouldn’t be selling newsletter subscriptions on twitter
$SPX - still in the hot mess that started 2 mo ago. Wild guess: it’s a base. The 2640 area could probably withstand a 3rd hit. Next time to 2800 area (4th) likely ignites fomo
This is my view. It may be wrong. You may disagree with it. We are not all going to agree, and that’s ok. Your job is to read widely, do your own analyses, form your own opinion, make your own decisions and live with the results. That’s how this works
Versions of this chart are making the rounds. The idea is that we are 285 days from last year’s low and 285 days after the 2009 low, $SPX plunged 15%. So, should you worry? A little thread 1/x
Economists stink @ predicting recessions. So do fund managers, corporate insiders, retail investors, newsletter writers, Wall St analysts, twitter pundits, that dude from Yale, the Fed & lobsters. Expect to be wrong, try to be less so than most & you’re on the right track
Strongest gain since June 2020. Gurus say days like these are just bear market rallies but that isn’t true. More than a few at lows or during uptrends $SPX
A lot of time left but 3 good things today so far.
One, $SPY breaking the pattern of lower highs. Wild guess is 392 (WR1) magnet and (5th time is the charm) goes higher
Two, $NYMO positive for the first time since Feb 16. Now, +7
What to expect in an election year? Based on the averages:
1. Chop/flat through April
2. May swoon
3. June-August summer ramp
4. Flat Sept-Oct
5. Post election ramp into year-end
Rising possibility of a recession in 2020:
- Employment growth weakening, lowest in 7 yrs
- 3Q19 real GDP growth expected to fall under 2%
- Housing starts and permits growth is slowing
- Manufacturing weakness broadening
New from The Fat Pitch