Reasons why 'transing' kids is a myth.
1. It's fucking impossible.
Kids don't do stuff they don't want to.
There's a reason parents repeat the same few instructions. Why we check toothbrushes. Why we end up howling: 'Just find your shoes!' at 8:32am every damn morning.
So basically, If you're a trans woman with a publicly-available photo, you're at risk of JK Rowling posting about & mocking you?
Just for being a trans woman?
That is so fucked up.
2. It's based on a myth about child abuse.
Paedophiles tell themselves & others that children can be reprogrammed to happily accept sex.
It's not true. Children can't consent to sex. 'Grooming' involves constant threats, violence & manipulation.
3. 'Transing' children would not benefit parents. At all.
Trans children are
discriminated against
vulnerable to verbal, physical & sexual assault
stalked
less likely to do well in school because bullying
often suicidal
They should be left alone, but aren't - so they suffer.
4. It's far easier to believe you can 'explain' difference than accept it.
Whenever a social group becomes more visible, the immediate question is: where did they come from?
The answer isn't 'it's a conspiracy' - it's 'they were here all along, try learning.'
Terrifying huh.
So what would 'grooming' a child into a trans identity involve?
The same. Manipulation, threats, gaslighting & violence.
The parent's life would be devoted to it.
Why the fuck would anyone do that? Parents have lives, jobs, hobbies. Most are constantly.knackered.
(Seriously, we don't have time. Swimming lessons, ballet, karate, play rehearsals, trampolining, sleepovers, music lessons...are we meant to hold up 'transing' instructions from the gallery while they do lengths?)
It's now 30 years since Suzy Eddie Izzard did a routine about going into a shop for crisps.
Shopkeeper, panicking at encountering a trans woman, finally asks: "What do you want?!"
Izzard says she wants some crisps.
Shopkeeper replies: "What, you eat crisps?!"
Thirty. Years.
@AlexKokcharov
Everyone sharing videos like this needs to stop, right now. Every share adds to the lifelong, unimaginable suffering of the victims. Report, make sure authorities know, delete.
And don't view them.
@BadWritingTakes
Imagine deliberately antagonising the Tennant fanbase between Good Omens 2 & the Doctor Who specials. And wanting to make an enemy of Michael Sheen. That'll go well.
@AnxietySugar_
*This* is what she's getting all this hate for? Asking for dialogue, understanding and inclusivity?
It's...lovely. Warms my plastic heart.
Just to add: know I replied to one amusingly tragic poster, but generally I don't play 'bot or troll?' I just block. Bye now, transphobes. Ring yer mums.
So fucked-up to know that if my son dies, an organised hate group will harass me for speaking about him & desperately seek some proof that hating trans people doesn't result in violence, suicides, and murder. It does. Fucking abject trolls. This was *never* about women's safety.
#TerfsWereRight
oh, to call trans-supportive parents 'paedos'?
throw hate at bereaved parents when they posted about their children?
mock suicidal people?
waste their lives complaining a minority existed?
Like you'll give that up now, losers.
@LloydRising
My (autistic) brother wasn't diagnosed with autism in the 70s because 'autistic people can't speak'.
Being a lesbian wasn't criminalised, because they were considered not to exist.
Left-hand index, where did all these people come from, blah.
Bye, Captain Disingenuous.
GC: your trans son wears skirts?
Me: ah look, I don't want...
GC: how is he male?!
Me: he's male whatever he wears. Woman isn't a costume...
GC: that's my fucking line!
Me: yeah, you all have the same script. One you don't actually...
GC: HANDMAIDEN!!
Me: *blocks* there it is
So sad for Brianna Ghey's family. I hope they can be left alone to grieve.
Trans children attended her vigils to honour her, but also because they were scared. They still are.
Rest in peace Brianna. None of those kids will ever forget.
@StockportCoven
Literally nothing wrong with trans children expressing their identity. They're happier.
Social transition is a personal choice which should be respected. It's sad that some trans children feel they can't tell their parents, but nothing to do with anyone else.
@wizardingnews
I suppose when people get rich, they spend it on what makes them happy.
Could be learning new stuff & helping marginalised people, like Daniel Radcliffe. Or the opposite.
Parent of trans child: yeah, bit of a surprise. New name suits him better. He's happier. Yeah, applying for college, got a boyfriend, doing a play, eats so much toast....
Person who spends all day online obsessing about trans kids: oh their tits penis genitals genitals genitals
@SuzyZannC
Being trans isn't a choice, or something you have to do each day to live well.
It's who someone is.
No children get surgery in the UK, social transition saves lives, and c!s children have been taking puberty blockers for decades.
@alicemydaughter
Thank you for this. How lucky Alice was to have you, she sounds wonderful.
My son came out at 13. I asked why he seemed so scared, didn't he realise we were always going to support him? His reply: some people in the world want me dead.
Didn't believe him then. I do now.
@mushycrouton
Be fair, she'll also be remembered for telling an entire country's independence movement that she didn't like their tone. And paying a million quid to stop them.
Oh my god. It's *going private* that's caught this cancer.
Claiming it's all about reporting symptoms early & eating properly is practically victim-blaming the rest of us.
I lost someone to cancer who had to wait four months for surgery. Stop this.
#r4today
@Emmettpedia
@ShinyUmbreon360
Son turns 18, goes to uni. I offer to take him out for a haircut when he comes home for Easter.
He can't find his shoes.
He takes so long the barbers close.
Aaargh aargh literally last week aargh
@SteveSchmidtSES
@mtgreenee
@GOPLeader
It's a very common right-wing tactic. So common in recent months that it's clear a playbook is being followed. Mask refusers/vax deniers comparing themselves to Ross Parks and Sophie Scholl etc. Always obscene.
@HelenWebberley
What is it with the tit police on here? Asexual women told off for showing cleavage, sexualisation of breastfeeding & creeps sharing photos of topless trans boys. My God people can do what they want with their own tits. Well played Costa.
@JournalistHelen
There's a reason so many people are making fun here. Trans kids are courageous. They have to be, because adults are spreading a malicious lie about their identity, pretending it's the same as imaginative play. Please don't make it worse for them. Cheers.
@HannahJLavine
Having reported people for threatening kids & seen none of them arrested, this seems suspect to me. It's either a lie or the lad was in serious danger.
And you're right, it's abuse apologism.
Oh and going to a post about a dead trans child & typing 'I'm sorry for your loss but...' followed by misgendering and/or telling the parent off, absolutely counts as hate.
Because who does that. Who says something they know will hurt a bereaved parent?
Terfs do that.
@MrHarryCole
@NatashaC
Endangering trans kids by telling abusive parents about them isn't feminism, it's cruelty. Solves nothing at all & validates the sexualised, violent bullying already suffered by trans kids. Just more cheap, performative cruelty.
@AidanCTweets
I fear this is right. It's very close to Nazi phrases like 'useless eaters'. Part of hard-right efforts to insist that trans people are driven solely by sex.
Miriam Cates linking being trans to porn (today) isn't a coincidence.
@guardian
That's not what happened at the Dylan concert.
She was booed because of her bravery in speaking up about abuse. She stopped the band, faced the crowd down, and sang Bob Marley's 'War' acapella right back at them. Then she walked off.
And she felt patronised by Kristofferson.
@Merlynn132
1. They don't.
2. See my point about the need for constant reinforcement
3. See my point about not being able to convince them they're happy to do it.
4. Bye.
@BBCNews
This is so sad. All love, support & solidarity to Alice's family ❤
Her family are in terrible pain. Anyone trolling (which includes misgendering) has a cold stone where a heart should be. Have a word with yourselves.
No one did a damn thing when I reported a cis male GP trying to make me tell him sexual details about why I needed the morning-after pill. Ditto the dentist who knelt on my tits when I was 16.
But 70-odd doctors daring to work while trans? Whole fucking campaign.
@ceciliaissmart
@NadineDorries
Dyslexia absolutely does affect speech. Especially if that person also has dyspraxia.
Doesn't explain consistently voting against help for disabled people, though.
@frankotron
@BethRigby
@WestNitaFBPE
It's a power thing, a form of harassment. Happens to women in queues & on public transport when you're forced into close proximity. They'll often turn & make sure you've noticed.
Banning trans women from the fucking scary, isolated, silent spaces that are most Ladies toilets won't make them any safer.
It's also unenforceable, ignores how trans men look & puts any unBarbielike cis women in danger of getting her head kicked in.
@BBCNews
Christ, why the hate. Famous couple have kid, with minimum fuss. Apart from how old this makes me feel, objectively good news. Congrats to them both.
@ChafyMcStretchy
I could barely read that for crying. Cannot imagine how you feel.
What an incredible boy he was.Selflessness is taught, it comes from being loved.
xx
So who's 'transing' gay kids? Either:
1. Parents who want them to suffer extreme hostility, bullying & violence in & out of school for being visibly different
2. Teachers who crave extra work
3. CAMHS (just kidding, there is no CAMHS) or
4. It's a batshit conspiracy theory.
@AidanCTweets
His vile comments about David Tennant are what might finally stick. DT has a huge fan base & is on TV a lot this autumn. Always worth reminding everyone that Linehan called him an "abusive groomer" for wearing a t-shirt supporting his own child.
@Telegraph
@RachelKellyNet
Tried to get help for a suicidal teenager this week (a relative). Told that CAMHS won't support unless he actively attempts suicide. Or else go to ED. This is policy. Imagine if I'd told him this - that he'd only get help if he hurt himself. Fund the damn service.
@JordanPfot
All part of the poisonous 'threatening suicide is violence' narrative. Denying pain, blaming victims. Except it's true, trans people are living with the effects of constant hypervigilance due to not feeling safe. They are traumatised. Thanks for highlighting this, Jordan.
@JimJumJam611
You can't get someone to accept a change to their basic self - something they didn't choose & which affects them physically - without constant reinforcement & coercion.
@bbcquestiontime
A thousand Met officers under investigation, potentially 2-3 in court per week for years. Widespread abuse of police ID to gain power over women. Where's the 20min debate on that?
@SteveSchmidtSES
@mtgreenee
@GOPLeader
Apologies for typo (!)
See also 'My body my choice' being appropriated for this faux outrage. Saw that one today.
Remember: an abuser being challenged or even mildly inconvenienced is always worse than actual abuse. Apparently.
Stuff I've been told by 'Gender Criticals' on here about kids socially transitioning in school:
gives them privileges
makes them popular
other kids are scared of them & are forced to do what they say
you made them do it for an easier life
there's no violence
"I shouldn't be scared to go to school"
Exclusive: 15 trans children have told VICE News they've stopped going to school because of the transphobia & violence they experience there.
They say the government's trans guidance will only make things worse...
Me: this report recommends no care for trans kids
Son: shocker
Me: I know how tough it's been for you, I'll do anything...
Son: take La Roux off repeat & give me your caramel Freddos?
Me: stop faking brave
Son: told you when I came out, they want trans kids to hurt. So...Freddos?
@BBCr4today
@MishalHusain
My son's deaf. Knew he couldn't hear when he was a toddler, but it's difficult to test a child that age.
He only got access to hearing aids & SEN support once officially diagnosed, after years of missed milestones.
Without diagnosis there is no support for any SEN child.
@GCAutistic
My brother's autistic. I would absolutely never patronise him by suggesting he didn't know his own mind, wasn't capable of knowing his own gender, or didn't have agency over his life.
You are spreading very harmful myths. People aren't conspiracy theories. Ableism is wrong.
@Glinner
@David_Tennant
This is how all parents who love their trans kids feel. We've had enough of your hatred putting them in danger. David Tennant's hardly gonna stop supporting his kid because you were rude to, uh, a fan account.
@TransKidsRule
My son gets this too, from those horrible older blokes who can sense vulnerability.
So many men pretend that it's okay for them to objectify & assault trans children.
Lots of them in the replies here. Why else would they be commenting about a trans child? Pervs.
@AndrewSolender
The worst thing that you can say to a survivor is that you do not believe them.
I am shocked to see the right-wing media viciously attacking those who survived the Capitol attack. But I'm also not surprised, after what happened to the Sandy Hook parents. Horrible.
@BBCNews
Her poor mum 😔
Sending love & support & solidarity.
Anyone who finds pleasure in causing others pain (which includes misgendering Brianna, why would you bother, you know it hurts her mum) is telling on themselves. Do better.
@catespice
True. And they can't see the change, they think they're still good people.
GCs often stop throwing hatred at me on here when they realise I'm not trans. They debate politely, wish me well. While simultaneously being incredibly spiteful to a trans person on a different thread.
@AmandaHarperCat
Trans people existing,being alive, wanting to stay that way. Asking for inclusive language, which is essential for any group facing deep prejudice.
Right wing parties forcing ten year old kids to give birth.
Not the same, sweet.
@OwenJones84
Thanks for this. Most cis women know this movement is coming for us too, and how we'll be expected to behave in exchange for 'protection.'
Those boring on about 'women being forced to get naked with men in communal areas' is telling me:
they've never used modern changing cubicles, for some weird fucking reason
they're transphobic
and/or they get their info on what women do in private from a very specific source.
@fesshole
Go to an emergency dentist for a quick fix. They'll sort the pain, it's quite anonymous & you'll be out in minutes. Then register with a dentist specialising in nervous (i.e. terrified) patients for the longer-term stuff. Be kinder to yourself, it's fine.
@GcMisogyny
One of my kid's teachers had a similar attitude & was eventually forced to apologise to him for repeated, pointed misgendering.
Appreciate not every school is as supportive as ours, but I hope this one is. Bullying kids for their identity is a shocking abuse of power.
@Amandycat
I'm so glad she has such a supportive family.
I think she made the right decision though. The outrageous, unbelievably damaging lie that trans women are paedophiles is being rapidly spread by media & social media. She was in grave danger here.
@MichaelRosenYes
After the intensive study and exhausting exams/tests my son just went through, all I can say to OFSTED is 'good luck with that'. He remains anxious, and shattered, six days after leaving school.
Every parent with a trans kid, who doesn't publicly reject them, gets called this.
Minimising actual CSA is evil. There's a reason so many genuinely worrying men are attracted to the 'gender critical' movement. Watch them swarm this post.
🚨 BREAKING 🚨
Gender critical cult leader Kellie-Jay Keen (aka Posie Parker) says Emma Bunton from the world famous female pop group the
@spicegirls
, might be a "child abuser"
@EmmaBunton
Trans-supportive parent, week one: *listens* okay. I love you, I'll always protect you. No, of course I'm not angry. Fairly sure no one hates you for being yourself, sweetheart, why would they?
Week two: *says something positive about trans kids on Twitter* oh my fucking god
@AriDrennen
Aw, Judy Bloom's fantastic. Not sure our teachers cared that girls passed Forever round like a secret (certain pages in particular) but we felt like we had to. Information is power, and she's empowered so many of us.
@Joshnigerrr
@BBCPolitics
Nah.
Love my trans son, so do legions of trans-supportive parents.
A minority of parents are abusive, but that's their problem. Trans kids will always find a supportive adult somewhere - because being trans is normal, ordinary, everyday.
No one, anywhere in the world, should have to live with the fear that their child may die. Corei was so obviously loved but he couldn't go on - and all those who targeted him are culpable. They won't even leave his mum alone to grieve 😞
Reasons to vote
#PartyOfWomen
today.
1. You want to use your vote as a protest, because you're privileged enough not to give a shit about about local services.
Do PoW have any actual policies? Do they fuck. But you badly need to punch down to feel alive. Here's your chance.
Thanks to everyone who's out defending trans kids today. It helps.
And trans kids - hold on, please. Talk to adults in your life who care about you. Don't listen to ignorant opinions, especially from She Who Must Speak To The Manager.
*shakes fist at clowns*
Kid's going out with his bloke tomorrow for Valentine's. Both 16. Flying Tiger, Meal Deal in the park, having a wander.
Chatted about it. Mainly 'have fun, don't ask lots of questions'. Taken the names of classmates who've threatened to stab him for being trans. Usual stuff.
Bigoted fuckwit behaviour impacts people even if it isn't technically a hate crime.
Like the waiter who got angry my then-8yo son hadn't reacted when spoken to. Explained he was deaf. Bloke knelt down, yelled 'food!' sarcastically in his ear, smirked at us & walked off.
@joss_prior
Done. What also gets me about GL is his use of the misogynistic 'hypnotised by dick' trope to explain allies. Because some women can't possibly know their minds, too busy focused on pleasing men so they can be granted sex. Fairly clear where he did his research on that.