No better time to learn from & support the tenants who live in public housing and are fighting for a model of PH that is deeply affordable to those most in need.. and !!! serves higher income households as well.
@FecStop13647
@SaveSection9
@RPPHNYC
@DefendGlendale
@NYGovCuomo
Can we honor them in less symbolic and more tangible ways perhaps? By canceling the (back) rent and raising the minimum wage and making healthcare and public utilities public, and, and, and.. otherwise redistributing economic and political power?
Still cringing abt end of
@VOCALNewYork
debate when
@AndrewYang
told a highly respected political leader, 'great job, you have a future as an MC, or an auctioneer'.
...
Appreciate that they unflinchingly responded, "i just want to live in a city without police and prisons."
What is being lost in the convo about public housing is that it is MAJOR form of decommodified housing. We cant talk about expanding CLTs to address the housing crisis, and talk about commodifying public housing at the same time.
To be clear the funding gap was created by disinvestment by city, state, & federal government officials at the behest of the private sector.. tenants are withholding their rent bc NYCHA, HUD & Congress & state officials are not fulfilling their duties as landlords & stewards.
Nearly half of
@NYCHA
's tenants are now behind in rent, creating a $$ gap that's endangering the authority's promised timeline of fixes under a 2019 agreement with the feds
Some candidates have no shame.
It is NOT ok to ask a community group to attend or speak at their community meeting the day before the election when we havent heard from you.. ever (not before you announced your campaign, not for the last 10 months.. nothing).
Tenants at Fulton 1st rallied against demo in 2019. It was the 1st plan on the table even tho buildings weren’t in disrepair. Now thanks to the ANTI-democratic strategy of the Chelsea Working Group, demo is back on the table. This sets a dangerous precedent! Time to show out!!
What is being lost in the convo about social housing is that really it continues the 50 year policy shift away from public housing, tying up all of our “affordable housing” w speculative finance markets, and w the business that is being built up around “affordable housing”.
The only "housing program" we are expanding for households earning less than $30,000 a year ($40,000...? $50,000??) is prisons.. and that's the real housing crisis "the left" needs to be contending with.
@NYCMayor
" Challenging???" You put lives at risk by instating the curfew and by siding w the NYPD over residents, and you should be held accountable for that.
In the absence of intervention by public officials, residents in the Rockaways took it upon themselves to survey neighbors at Ocean Bay Houses about their experiences with the RAD program. You can read their full report here:
Suggested re-wording: I want to live in The People's NYC, & i think
@Dianne4NYC
is the candidate that can help us get there, along w all of the continued commty organizing work that has built the foundation for a campaign like hers.
This thread - where neolib & afford hous industry enthusiasts are aligning w some DSA members - shows the dangers of where DSA is on hous policy right now.
DSA needs to come strong & hard in support of pub hous resids fighting to preserve section 9. PERIOD.
I am extremely disappointed in my chapter’s decision to promote these anti-public sector talking points and borderline incomprehensible characterizations of municipal bonds.
How much money are we about to drop on metal detectors and “safety & security infrastructure” when the real answer is to invest in people and their well being?
Just rcvd this IMO from a resident & organizer in Far Rockaway. The facade of the first RAD conv in NYC, Ocean Bay Houses, is ripping off the building. This dev converted 5+ years ago, a pilot used to justify the expansion of RAD.
@DRichardsQNS
promoted this as a success..
Just found out today NYCHA is changing leases to make it easier for them to evict folks. These kinds of "clean sweeps" usually accompany privatiz plans to dampen any tenant organizing or opposition. These policies are further activated by targeted hyper-policing (geo,rac,class).
As the city moves forward with another RAD conversion, I looked at WHO the units are being transferred to. This preliminary analysis shows that
@NYCMayor
&
@NYCHA
have passed off more than 16,000 units to some of the WORST landlords in the city.
The housing and climate crisis are the same crisis.. not separate.
Both have roots in the commodification of land and the history of colonization ongoing.. This is the real root crisis that we need to be addressing.
Our housing crisis has been interrupted by our climate crisis 🤬
This is the disaster of our capitalist system, and more of a reason to show up and fight back against rent hikes proposed by Adam’s RGB.
See you Monday 6/12!
We knocked-doors in
@JuliaCarmel__
district today and every single tenant we talked to - about 100 in a 1.5 hour time span - are against the Blueprint.
Where is the robust support she keeps talking about?
@Biaggi4NY
, you seem to want to jump in, maybe you know?!
For a “socialist” organization to remain “neutral” on the subject of the privatization of public housing in the face of its own elected putting forth the legis..
You have made it. You’re now an established white liberal organization.
From
@nycDSA
to NYCDLA.
@PEWilliams_
That’s the wrong question and it valorizes white institutions and white ways of knowing and being and structuring society in really problematic ways.
Actually, the first step was to not sell public housing down the river. That is a major reserve of public land and publicly-owned housing that a DSA elected official stepped up to sell off.
We do have to build more housing; it should be publicly owned, robustly funded, controlled by the people. How we get from here to there is not easy
By mitigating displacement/rent hikes and giving tenants rights to take power good cause and TOPA are HUGELY NECESSARY first steps
News the morning that NYCHA is starting the eviction process w tenants who have filed a collective HP Action and have been withholding their rent for repairs. It ain’t right but we’re ready.
How will you be supporting your constituents?:
@SenGianaris
@juliej_won
@RepMaloney
I’m beginning to think we should be withholding our taxes… for those of us who don’t pay upfront. We’re literally only paying for war and military intervention and private profit thru gov contracts at this point.
The battle for Willets Point is a revealing bit of NYC and more so NYCEDC history.
First, the city BEGAN the conversation with a mass eviction for the local community and economy that served mostly working-class Latinx workers.
Willets Point is on the agenda at Community Board 7 tonight -- and the architects are showing for the first time the renderings of the future
@NYCFC
stadium and the housing that goes along with it.
Before and after:
For Queens folks thinking about the Queens Boro Pres race, 2021 - its worth noting that
@JimmyVanBramer
is on the Committee on Public Housing, and was SILENT during the hearing on RAD last week. SILENT.
So to recap, HRW releases an extensive report detailing how bad RAD in NYC is & not one elected has acknwldgd it or shown any support for residents?
Where is the outrage? Action?
NYCHA is the sz of a small city, this a MAJOR crisis thts being ignored.
What does "social hous = hous for all" really mean?
Let's look at the 3 Vienna-inspired "social hous" programs mentioned in the article yesterday in Maryland, California and Seattle..
Spoiler: Each program is exclusive in the same ways “affordable housing” dev has been.
Appreciate
@Jawanza
asserting that closing jails is not utopic.
@NYCComptroller
your view isnt reasonable, its privlege and ignorance. Our incarceration system is an endangerment to our neighbors. If it endangered your life directly, you would feel differently, i am sure.
Tune in tonight for this tenant-led truth commission on RAD.
NYCHA is saying those opposing RAD are "spreaders of misinformation who want tenants to accept the status quo". Tonight let's set the record straight, RAD = contd neglect, contd disrespect, contd status quo..
If youre running a grassroots campaign, the strategy cannot be calling on neighbors who are already activated & the goal cannot be getting elected, only. The strategy and the goal has to be activating new neighbors - around the election & more so, othr comm and city issues.
This “affordable housing industrial complex” is being driven forward by the private sector thru nonprofits, like LISC, Enterprise, Furman Center, NYHC, which are really just political formations of priv sector actors that are pushing a specific policy agenda of mixed finance.
Grateful to be invited to co-write this piece with
@robbins_glyn
- to shed some light on the serious issues w the Trust and to make sure the tenant-led efforts are not being invisibilized by those that claim to speak for them.
#savesection9
I am truly inspried by the work and tenacity of the Flushing community. I wish it didnt have to be this way, but your efforts are undergirding my own now too. 💕
Ready to send a friendly letter to our
@NYCCouncil
members to demand they vote
#NoFlushingRezoning
. We got over 1,000 signatures (with zip codes to back em up).
Luxury housing, retail and hotels in an over congested, working class neighborhood equals displacement. VOTE NO.
The other GLARING issue is race and class. When has capitalism ever been the answer for working-class and/or communities of color? HINT: NEVER. Instead, race and (societally-produced) poverty has been used to justify and conceal capitalist interventions and abuse.
Tonight the longtime coordinations among residents & allies organizing around public housing was on full display.. for 6 independently-created presentations to be synced up & fluid w one reinforcing & building on the next.. w little-to-no coordination ahead of time.. let’s go!
CONGRESS. CONGRESS is the worst landlord. CONGRESS made it impossible for NYCHA to make repairs, and federal prosecutors worked hard to replace any discussion of disinvestment w mismanagement.
NYCHA is the worst landlord in NYC – the heating and hot water outages we saw at Fort Independence Houses and across the five boroughs are at once entirely unacceptable and entirely predictable given NYCHA’s history of mismanagement and chronic underfunding.
We need reform now.
So the problem w public housing is that it’s “income-segregated”??? This is how
@DemSocialists
@CSSNYorg
+ NPIC is justifying walking away from the fight for public housing towards resecuring the interests of a now-multiracial White Middle Class. A dangerous misstep I think..
@NYCMayor
What social purpose do police serve? Honestly? How about we try providing social support, community control, and autonomy instead of disciplinary action?
Where’s the money for public housing?
The pentagon now consumes more than half of the federal discretionary budget.
The avg taxpayer spends $1100 per year on weapons contracts compared to $270 for K-12 education, and $6 for renewable energy.
#notrad
#notpact
#savesection9
Well, actually, no.. There are still 168,000 public housing units funded thru Section 9. Public housing and social housing are not equivalent, but public housing is certainly one type of social housing. Or are we trying to erase public housing so we don’t have to fight for it?
🧵 Most of NYC's social housing (60k units!) comes from Mitchell-Lama co-ops. After decades of affordability, these residents are battling privatization to keep their homes.
#socialhousing101
The larger story here is that these contracts further wealth concentration and economic inequality, and thus, further political inequality, which ultimately maintains the system of housing scarcity that we call "housing policy" in this country.
At a rally at City Hall today public housing residents once again showed strong and consistent opposition to RAD and the Blueprint Trust
@CityLimitsNews
@JeanmarieEvelly
@NYCEDC
's master plan for developing over Sunnyside Yards is premised on false claims and flat out lies. This piece outlines 5. Whle there are more, this is enough to suggest
#NoSunnysideYards
and
#AbolishEDC
are the way to go.
I dont expect much from
@nytimes
but the pro-RAD piece by
@kimmelman
is lazy, under-researched, & inaccurate.. & these inaccuracies are worth highlighting and correcting -- in part bc they reveal
@gregruss51
's media strategy for delegitmzg the opposition.
This shows a concerning lack of understanding of local politics. The current TA pres who opposes the plans is excluded here. And the past TA president along w Urb Upbd have been publicly supportive of every bad dev deal proposed & directly benefited $$$..
@tiffany_caban
Today I stood with current and past leadership of the Astoria Houses Tenants Association, as well as leaders from beloved D22 CBOs
@Zone126Queens
and
@UrbanUpboundNY
, not to mention friends from
@32BJSEIU
and
@nycDSA
to talk about land use and housing.
🧵👇🏽
We are dealing with another
#RacistRezoning
here in Astoria. Another dev team is targeting another plot on Hallet's Point where the longest-standing residents live in Astoria Houses. The images attached here show roughly how the housing units will be allocated.
I’ve said this behind closed doors but I think it’s worth saying louder bc I know too many ppl who are good organizers & activists & getting no where in DSA. GET OUT. We have work to do, and DSA as an org has shown that it is not a site of struggle, but a way of coopting energy..
Everyone concerned abt the future of hous NYC (and the US) should be fighting against the furtherance of RAD & the Blueprint. Together that is the LARGEST urb redev plan in NYC (US?) that will ultmly worsen the challenges we’re ALL facing now, wether you live in pub hous or not.
This is does not erase the decades of displacement & uneven distribution of money, power, & well-being caused by this industry. They are not our saviors now; they are a part of the reason our communities are struggling so acutely now. This attempt at rebranding is disturbing.
Great piece on the real estate community's ongoing efforts to help small business, their employees and all people in need, led by Seth Weissman and Urban Standard
#REHasYourBack
It is not in our best interest to be conflating social housing with this new version of social housing.
CLTs & fights for community land are much more social than this BS. So is pub hous. We need to take seriously the diffs in these models, who they serve, how they're funded..
NYCHA is once again trying to coerce residents into privatization, this time thru an unfair voting procedure. Tenants are once again sounding the alarm - see for full list.
Ex. 10% participation is considered a valid vote..
Something else to consider is that public housing IS NOT income-segregated.
The program serves households w incomes that are less than $10,000 to over $100,000.. w most at the lower end.
This makes sense because these households need it most!
So the problem w public housing is that it’s “income-segregated”??? This is how
@DemSocialists
@CSSNYorg
+ NPIC is justifying walking away from the fight for public housing towards resecuring the interests of a now-multiracial White Middle Class. A dangerous misstep I think..
The other SHOCKING thing from
@nycDSA
today is that they used the “NYCHA isn’t a monolith” argument AGAINST residents opposing the legislation.. they used something that is supposed to recognize the diversity and humanity of tenants to undermine those same tenants.
Disgusting.
Rather than challenging the political winds which have normalized housing insecurity and homelessness for low income households, social housing promises to secure mostly white middle class futures in urban areas - I’d argue, paralleling suburbanization in some key ways.
One key thing the Blueprint Trust does is create an institutional barrier between the public subsidy AND tenants and repairs and maintenance. This ensures the hard line cash serves as debt repayment and creates more security for investors.
This is a trade off.
If you’re not going to trust tenants & allies speaking out, here is a technical review by Queens Legal Services that aligns w what tenants and Allie’s are saying:
I know I say this often, but I say it earnestly: I would strongly encourage anyone to read regulations, or any policy, before commenting on it publicly so you don't show the world that you have not, in fact, read the thing you are talking about
Tenant at Ocean Bay Houses on RAD/PACT: “stop w the lies.. there’s been high evictions, some seniors are on pantry lines now, folks who were getting transfers because of domestic violence are not in process any longer… stop with the lies.”
This affordable housing industrial complex RELIES on the housing production of housing scarcity as much as the development of “affordable housing”.
Working they these means will never address the housing crisis and in fact are critical to reproducing it.
A lot of the discourse around the changes NYCHA & Russ are making to public housing revolve around whether or not this is privatization. But maybe more clearly, it is the expansion of the real estate state into public housing in NYC, & a hostile take over by financial capitalism.
While we’re talking about the violence of white supremacy, lets not forget - not only the disinvestment in public housing, but also the absence of coverage of the broad and still-growing tenant-led movement for Section 9.. & the persistent abandonment by “the Left” in general..
New report on RAD in NYC from
@hrw
; title is telling: “The Tenant Never Wins"
Main findings include: Priv involv reduced rights protections & increased evictions in 2 devs
We need to end RAD as a failed program, and fully fund for Section 9 now.
@SecFudge
@alexaforcouncil
Jackson's ongoing water crisis is a foreboding example of what remedying federal disinvestment in public housing with speculative bond financing will mean for our public housing stock and residents down the road.
NYCHA is Jackson.
#FundNYCHANOW
#SaveSection9
New oped on RAD in progress - here's a tidbit:
If Fulton and Chelsea-Elliot Houses are converted to Section 8 through the RAD program, taxpayers could fork over as much as $4mil to the private management company - per month.
@cmenchaca
@Dianne4NYC
@JackieL69918724
Since The Blueprint was announced, residents have been organizing and rallying to oppose it, and mobilizing for public funding through Section 9.
This begs the question, who wants The Blueprint anyway?
Here's a look at 5 of the nonprof lending support -
Are ya'll ready to talk about the non profit economy? Or do we still want to make people dependent on charity instead of ensuring housing, food and transportation are healthy, affordable and accessible?
#america
#ThisIsAmerica
We all want nice things but if we pursue this vision of hous w/out preserving pub hous & addressing homelessness then we are not solving the housing crisis, but reinforcing it’s tectonics.. meaning another round of racialized dispossession while resecuring a white middle class.
a beautiful portrait of the kind of world social housing could create:
“I have a car. A Mercedes A-Class from the ’90s. I eat out. I drink one coffee out every day. I don’t have a lot of money. But I live rich.”
I say "other" issue - but these issues are deeply intertwined. Preserving public housing, and heralding it as the premier form of decommodified housing, and giving it the respect it deserves by investing in it is about racial and class justice. This is the future we need.
This is a DISTRACTION. From what?
These programs boast about being self-funded. No need for any government subs or funds. This is why these devs need to be exclusive.
But why don't we expect the US gov to fund housing?!
Unsurprisingly,
@NYCHA
's figures on evictions, which they receive from their private partner, are much lower than research conducted by independent researchers.
@AlickaASamuel41
Breaking tonight: Industry City developers pull application for rezoning, after slate of Congress members including
@RepJeffries
came out against it today.
@JanakiChadha
has the scoop:
We need to be building strong grassroots networks to hold them accountable. Why go on a 100 person call where you look at a PowerPoint when you can talk to your neighbors IRL face-to-face..?
Social housing, I think, is really just a redirection that will ultimately bolster the economic and political standing of finance capital and reinforce differences within the working class.
So this is an attempt to RE-SEGREGATE housing by creating a hous option that is EXCLUSIVE to middle-inc ppl. These devs will likely worsen gentrif and homelessness while securing a urban middle class.
"Social housing" is the new suburbanization.
Conversely, tenants & their right to safe afford housing become completely reliant on speculative debt, & funding for their needs comes after debts are repaid. What if the Trust can’t keep up w their debt payments? Tenants will once again be told there is no money.
This is important! Some of the social housing policy arguments justify targeting middle income households because allegedly we’re only building affordable housing for low-income people..
No, we’re not and it’s WHY public housing is so important!
New from me: a report shows the nation is rapidly losing apartments affordable to the poorest people, despite a boom in new multifamily apartment construction not seen in 50 years
All of this to say that the fight for our collective futures is at the federal level. The Blueprint IS a distraction and the residents leading the fight know this. Rather than undermining those efforts, their perspectives should be guiding the left’s approach in general.
This also flies in the face of a community meeting w tenants of Astoria Houses just a couple weeks ago where tenants overwhelmingly opposed the project.
I hear people say Twitter is toxic, but my experience of toxic Twitter is pretty limited to my interactions w members of DSA.. that doesn’t say everything about the org, but it does not bode well for its future..
@TribecaTrust
Historic preservation is not a useful lens or foundation for the housing movement. It is inherently racist - in a couple ways: what histories it preserves vs. erases, what it does to land values and who pays vs benefits - and it completely decenters the community.
This is what
@Nycha
Simon Kawitsky said at
@CRDCNYC
panel re: Fulton/Elliott Chelsea redev when asked about developer accountability bc history of demolition/privatization of public housing bring displacement: “NOTHING IN LIFE IS GUARANTEED…”
@RPPHNYC
@SaveSection9
@ka_hackett
Why isn’t there more outrage from elected officials about the displacement provoked by RAD at Ocean Bay Houses and elsewhere? Where is the call to investigate further? Could it be because some campaign donors are making out big?
NEW INVESTIGATION: As homelessness has spiked in New York City, the people who run nonprofit shelters have found ways to enrich themselves. They’ve collected large salaries, steered money to companies they control, and hired their relatives. 1/
When afford housing industry folks talk about “afford hous” what they are actually talking about is access to affordable mortgage credit.
They DONT mean access to afford hous for low-inc households & certainly not the robust hous provision needed to address the housing crisis.
@NYCHA
describes the resident vote for demo at Fulton Houses as “57% of nearly 1,000 residents”…
What a misleading way of talking abt a decision that would effect at least 4,500 residents..
More accurate: only 22% of residents participated in the vote; only 12% votes yes..