Jill Barshay Profile
Jill Barshay

@jillbarshay

Followers
5K
Following
9K
Media
92
Statuses
4K

I write about education research and data for @hechingerreport. Sign up for my newsletter https://t.co/oroqzxJtXQ

New York
Joined March 2009
Don't wanna be here? Send us removal request.
@jillbarshay
Jill Barshay
18 hours
High schools too. In many NYC schools, 1/2 the kids get the full period to complete exams and in-class writing assignments (which there are more of in the age of AI), and 1/2 must turn them in after a half hour or so and twiddle their thumbs for the remainder of the time.
@marcportermagee
Marc Porter Magee 🎓
2 days
Today's MUST READ: One of the biggest problems in schools right now is no one is empowered to ever hold the line on a standard. The result? "We have a two-speed student population."
4
5
75
@jillbarshay
Jill Barshay
3 days
A lot has happened this year. If you'd like a recap of what's happened to education research and statistics, here's my attempt. This might be a good one to listen to on your commute today. (Audio play button below headline. 16 minutes long.)
Tweet card summary image
hechingerreport.org
Decades of carefully built infrastructure aimed at improving and tracking how American children learn vanished in an ideological attack
0
6
13
@jillbarshay
Jill Barshay
12 days
.@markseidenberg latest blog post suggests that schools might consider scrapping oral-only phonemic awareness exercises altogether and always show letters when they are teaching sounds. a bit like fusing phonemic awareness and phonics together. (5/5)
Tweet card summary image
seidenbergreading.net
This post summarizes my longstanding concerns about the practice of phonemic awareness instruction, a core element of the “science of reading” approach that is based on a deep misunderstanding of...
1
0
10
@jillbarshay
Jill Barshay
12 days
I've written about how U.S. literacy experts worry that teachers here are spending too much time on phonemic awareness and how these minutes would be better spent on phonics, vocab or knowledge building. (4/5)
Tweet card summary image
hechingerreport.org
A growing number of researchers are criticizing an overemphasis on auditory skills
1
0
8
@jillbarshay
Jill Barshay
12 days
UK scholars reviewed the same research about learning to read that US experts did but its 2006 "Rose Report" didn't list phonemic awareness as essential. It was more focused on graphemes, how letters or combos of letters correspond to sounds. E.g. "ph" is pronounced "f" (3/5)
1
0
3
@jillbarshay
Jill Barshay
12 days
He notes that in the UK, teachers don't teach phonemic awareness. "British children manage to learn to read without phonemic awareness instruction and they do so about as well our students. The British experiment suggests that PA instruction isn’t necessary..." (2/5)
1
0
3
@jillbarshay
Jill Barshay
12 days
A flashpoint in reading instruction is about "phonemic awareness": the sounds that make up words. For example, the word chess has 3: ch - eh - s. Teaching it is one of the pillars of the "science of reading" but a top scholar @markseidenberg is questioning its importance.đź§µ(1/5)
2
2
19
@PaulMorganPhD
Paul L. Morgan🥋📚
16 days
Write up by @jillbarshay of @hechingerreport on our new study, led by @Eric_hhy, examining the effects of teacher-student gender matching during elementary school on academic achievement, behavior, and executive functioning. What do we find? Not too much.
Tweet card summary image
hechingerreport.org
A teacher's gender doesn’t matter for young boys, national study shows
0
2
7
@Eric_hhy
Eric Hengyu Hu, PhD
16 days
It was a great conversation with @jillbarshay and thank you for reporting our latest findings! You can find our preprint here: https://t.co/JCAOQ8xpTO We tested whether teacher–student gender matching improves student outcomes from kindergraten to 5th grade (1/🧵)
Tweet card summary image
researchgate.net
PDF | We investigated whether U.S. elementary students’ academic achievement, social-behavioral and executive functioning improved when taught by... | Find, read and cite all the research you need on...
@PaulMorganPhD
Paul L. Morgan🥋📚
16 days
Write up by @jillbarshay of @hechingerreport on our new study, led by @Eric_hhy, examining the effects of teacher-student gender matching during elementary school on academic achievement, behavior, and executive functioning. What do we find? Not too much.
1
2
3
@jillbarshay
Jill Barshay
17 days
But I digress...on average, it turns out, neither boys nor girls benefit academically, socially or behaviorally from having a male teacher in elementary school. And that's what this morning's column is about. (3/3)
Tweet card summary image
hechingerreport.org
A teacher's gender doesn’t matter for young boys, national study shows
1
1
1
@jillbarshay
Jill Barshay
17 days
Mr. Sedlak was a memorably great teacher who taught me how to calculate percent change, something I still use every week. (This was during the New Math era and he also taught me to count and add in base 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8 and 9) (2/3)
1
0
2
@jillbarshay
Jill Barshay
17 days
If my memory serves me correctly, I had one male teacher during the entirety of my elementary school years: Mr. Sedlak for 6th grade math at Squadron Line Elementary School. (1/3) đź§µ
1
0
2
@jillbarshay
Jill Barshay
21 days
There are a lot of SEL programs out there. Not all work. Some do. Maybe a small minority of them do. Good to see more rigorous testing of them. Ultimately we should care if they translate into learning gains.
Tweet card summary image
hechingerreport.org
Reading and math gains from soft skill instruction
@Jordan_C_Adams
Jordan Adams
22 days
School-based Social and Emotional Learning (SEL) intervention found ***zero*** impact on children’s mental health. https://t.co/n74bX6spbf
1
2
10
@jillbarshay
Jill Barshay
21 days
This problem is one of the reasons that @ReadingShanahan recommends that the whole class should be reading the same grade-level text.
Tweet card summary image
hechingerreport.org
In a new book, researcher Timothy Shanahan argues that giving students easy texts is holding back US reading achievement
@EvidentlyR
EvidentlyReading
22 days
One of the greatest weaknesses of the workshop model of ELA is that the students are reading books the teacher has not read. Supporting in a class this a.m. and struggling to answer students' questions about the 20 different biographies they are reading.
1
1
9
@jillbarshay
Jill Barshay
21 days
"Fluency doesn’t come from perfect lesson completion. It comes from messy attempts to make yourself understood, from forgetting words and using gestures, from laughing at your own mistakes. "And no app leaderboard can track that." (2/2) https://t.co/Uw8jObVDJp
Tweet card summary image
medium.com
(Not just “level up”…)
0
0
6
@jillbarshay
Jill Barshay
21 days
I've learned about the evidence for spaced retrieval practice through @researchED_US @tombennett71 et al. But here's an argument by Krystyna Trushyna: even when online learning gets spaced retrieval practice right, it's insufficient. Learning requires much more. đź§µ (1/2)
1
2
17
@jillbarshay
Jill Barshay
22 days
No longer a newbie. My second insta video. This one on @ReadingShanahan new manifesto to get rid of the practice of giving kids different books to read based on their current reading abilities.
Tweet card summary image
instagram.com
2
2
10
@margaretmckeow2
margaret mckeown
23 days
Excellent overview of the history of research on PA and its uses and misuses.
@jillbarshay
Jill Barshay
24 days
Researchers are trying to figure out how much "phonemic awareness" kids need in elementary school. More evidence that a lot of oral-only lessons (without letters) aren't helpful. Please also read my piece from 2024.
0
2
12
@jillbarshay
Jill Barshay
22 days
I'm experimenting with video. @jillbproofpoints
Tweet card summary image
instagram.com
1
1
6
@jillbarshay
Jill Barshay
24 days
It might seem that the federal education stats agency could easily be transferred to another cabinet dept if ED is closed. But not so straightforward. Why a move could degrade the quality of higher ed data.
Tweet card summary image
hechingerreport.org
But new hires and fresh research grants hint at a quiet rebuilding effort
0
1
0