Tooze & Fertik (2014) assert that WWI reshaped the world economy countering the economists narrative that war interrupted globalization. WWI, they argued, 'activated to an unprecedented degree' the networks of 19th century globalization. My essay understands the present similarly
Absolutely sensational piece from
@MonaAli_NY_US
. The density of forensic knowledge about the global dollar system is astounding.
Among other treats, it has the clearest and most concise explanation of Bretton Woods I and its demise I've ever read.
As Keynes envisioned the Bretton Woods institutions, the idea was to equilibrate international imbalances. This also means addressing imbalances in the body's voting-shares. Both India and China punch way below their weight in voting rights with respect to their population & GDP.
Can’t wait to read
@PMehrling
’s book on the man who helped fashion the world dollar standard. Here is Kindleberger in 1970, just before Bretton Woods falls apart, advocating for G-10 representation at the Fed’s FOMC and for the BIS to regulate the offshore dollar market!
Krugman's wrong and it's because he understands the dollar as currency alone rather than as a global system of debt and debt-based finance (e.g. derivatives & sovereign debt). He doesn't want to get into the details but NY-LON are the core of the $ based global financial system.
Zoltan is mostly right but he is wrong about the future of the dollar. His analysis of geo-monetary dynamics is spot on. World money has core-periphery dynamics. Regime shifts are non-linear events. Keynes himself recognized that world events can't be measured using probability.
Good critique here. The Keynesian framework underpinning Pettis's argument is anachronistic; among else it is premised on savings driving investment i.e. there is no endogenous credit creation. Similarly, it relies on comparative advantage rather than industrial policy as the key
NEW from the
#NIEO
Collection: Professor
@MonaAli_NY_US
on the geo-economics of acute dollar dominance — and why so many governments present at the IMF Spring Meetings are now seeking alternative arrangements.
Kudos
@FT
. A new institutional framework for debt restructuring--one in which western bondholders, multilateral creditors such as the IMF and the World Bank, as well as China agree to evenly accepting sovereign debt write-offs--is the need of the hour.
Tbh, as I work on a book on the weaponization of the world economy, the pace at which transformative events are occurring registers viscerally in the body as: breath-taking, dizzying, but also, literally, nauseating.
Kind of stunning to see this not because a former student is a co-author (congrats Serra!) but is this the very first time that a NY Fed staff report explicitly mentions the economic imperialism of the $?!
Before we dive into Bank for International Settlements reports and else, my International Trade and Finance students begin the semester with this superb read on 'How To See The World Economy' by
@zeithistoriker
.
Scenes from the IMF Headquarters today: two excellent civil society org panels on taxation policy and SDRs featuring some stellar heterodox economists and policy makers alongside a representative from the IMF. When the dialogue got combative, it made for some fireworks and fun.
<historians' visualization>
@zeithistoriker
sketches out the boundaries between discourses of settler colonialism and financial imperialism at the Just Money conference.
While the Biden admin shells out $35 million to the US subsidiary of the leading British arms manufacturer, it has pledged just half the amount ($17.5 million) to the global climate-related Loss and Damage fund.
The first Chips Act grant is out the door.
US is giving BAE Systems $35 million to upgrade a fab that makes niche chips for defense.
For scale: In 2021-22, BAE distributed $3.3 billion to shareholders in buybacks & dividends. In June, it agreed to another $1.9b in buybacks.
Afghanistan is one of the poorest countries in the world, plagued with high unemployment, but aid inflows and capital controls have made the Afghani the third-best performing currency globally this year after the Colombian peso and the Sri Lankan rupee.
Economic geographers (Krugman and such) have rightly taught us to be obsessed with cross-border trade in autos. . . High-value added; capital-intensive; originally the bulk of which was north-north in orientation; but now China has changed that game.
<$1 trillion down> Unprecedented losses in the foreign exchange reserves of nations as the dollar has strengthened against other currencies. More than half of these losses are from valuation effects (exchange rate changes) alone. India has lost approximately $100 billion!
Thank you
@phenomenalworld
for providing a wonderful space for writing political economy. I've made some good friends through this platform and then to discover that my young cousin
@imadahmed
just wrote a piece on Zambia and the World Bank for PW, well, that's icing on the cake
Wow. An incredibly productive, wide-ranging, and nuanced conversation on Bidenomics and what it means for progressive policy. We need a follow up in six months
@DanielDenvir
if not sooner.
This new
@thedigradio
ep is a really important discussion and debate on Bidenomics—the new industrial policy, the energy transition, the New Cold War with China, and more. With
@DanielaGabor
,
@tedfertik
, and
@70sBachchan
.
<Why not default?> Hard to fathom after last year's climate-catastrophe and the energy-crisis in Pakistan (which explain why forex reserves are down to a month's supply) that the IMF is withholding a long-promised tranche unless austerity measures are imposed. IMF please explain?
The original Keynes-White plan (undermined in the final IMF Articles of Agreement) explicitly called for capital controls not only on countries experiencing capital flight but also on countries to where capital was flowing. Joan Robinson's critique of Article VI still resonates.
Requesting capital management measures to prevent rapid and significant capital outflows as a condition to access emergency liquidity is part of the IMF's treaty obligations. Not doing so is not merely bad policy, it is unlawful. And the IMF should be liable for it.
Fascinating that both Harry Dexter White, who essentially created postwar dollar hegemony, and Charlie Kindleberger, who tried to make it more benevolent, were deemed security threats accused of being communists or spies or both. Such are the dangers of studying money seriously.
Afghanistan's population is facing extreme hunger. The humanitarian crisis can be eased by the U.S. releasing the $9.4 billion in foreign exchange reserves it has frozen. This will resuscitate Afghanistan's central bank functioning. Some much needed plain-speaking by
@adam_tooze
The humanitarian catastrophe engulfing Afghanistan is staggering in its scale and urgency. Western sanctions are compounding the damage done by withdrawal. Chartbook
#78
<a must read> This is a beautiful piece of thinking and writing about age-old economic development questions that are back with even greater urgency today. Congrats
@humford
@davideoks
.
Blistering critique of what the new IMF loan program to Ukraine might entail from
@TheEconomist
. I stopped subscribing to the mag because of its often sexist and racist tone but I will say that I do miss its laconic sarcasm (see last line).
About that big IMF loan to Ukraine: “There needs to be economic support for Ukraine but its allies should have borne the risk, not the IMF, and done so with grants instead of letting Ukraine rack up debt.” says Mark Malloch-Brown
@malloch_brown
A piece I wrote on why the IMF needs a bigger balance sheet and why expanding its capital-base (quotas) and regular Special Drawing Rights issuance must be interlaced with fundamental governance reforms.
"A recent IMF report clarifies that 'systemic debt crises' are ones that threaten the solvency of large and private creditors. In this framework, distressed low-income sovereigns simply don’t matter much."
NEW:
@MonaAli_NY_US
on reforming the IMF.
In the lead-up to the G20 Summit on Sept. 7, the Biden Admin declares a commitment to reforming and modernizing the Bretton Woods institutions. Some further background on why reforming the IMF's balance sheet requires more ambitious & fundamental change.
Samuelson was so right about propositions but so wrong about comparative advantage as the exceptional 'true and non-trivial' case. For comparative advantage to hold forth required extremely stringent criteria from non-increasing returns to full employment to perfect competition.
Ours is a hybrid global dollar system where sovereigns are enmeshed in shadow finance (money markets). While the PBoC can 'dance to its own tune' the world economy dances to the tune of the world dollar. Think of the dollar as a money-military matrix backed by legal supremacy.
As the BRICS gold-backed trade currency is making the news, it is worth noting that the US and UK dominate
CB gold holdings. The pics from Eichengreen et al. 2023 below convey how war & sanctions have resulted in a unstable global monetary system, that embraces gold once again.
In 145 days, 21,000 women and children have been killed in Gaza. American bombs, artillery, personnel, and military aid have facilitated this bloodshed. Not sure how we will ever recover from this.
So, what's the ancient Greek or contemporary German compound term for a hegemon trying to solve a problem which itself has helped shape, and in so doing, it falls short or invariably worsens the problem?
Beginning my spring seminar 'Crisis Economics' with an analysis of this trenchant and hopeful article by Angela Harris and James Varellas (2020) "Law and Political Economy in a Time of Accelerating Crises". Here we go.
Turns out that Henry Morgenthau Jr., US Secretary of the Treasury under Franklin D. Roosevelt, who presided over Bretton Woods and was key to the New Deal, was also a farmer in New York's Hudson Valley. He insisted that it be listed as his profession on his passport & tax forms.
In a state of distraction because of US debt ceiling politics, browsing through recent
@FTAlphaville
columns, I ran into a nice surprise - a link to my latest
@phenomenalworld
essay. :) Thanks
@RobinWigg
!
Focusing on current account imbalances as the cause of and austerity as the response to speculative attacks on sov. bond markets is simply wrong. Powerful research by
@KarstenKohler2
. Implies that concepts of international crisis management (incl. IMF Articles) need to be updated
From 'fire and forget' Spike and Hellfire missiles (used in Iraq and Syria) to unguided M117 'dumb bombs' detonated over Korea & Vietnam and 2,000lb GBU-31 bombs (four times larger than those used in Mosul), Gaza's carpet bombardment exceeds that of Hamburg, Cologne, and Dresden.
Brilliant piece by
@jdostry
and
@JosephEStiglitz
on the need for capital outflow controls, a curiously MIA IMF in the face of the worsening of global economy, and the need for the IMF to uphold its original mission.
The IMF should move beyond tolerating some capital controls to imposing them when needed. As
@jdostry
&
@JosephEStiglitz
remind us, in Argentina the IMF let investors cash out and left the govt with "a $44 billion debt burden and little to show for it"
A brilliant analysis by
@pathtopraxis
on the recklessness of US nationalism. My main quibble: the recent history of neoliberalism capitalism should not make one fall for a zero sum game/declinist/falling rate of profit teleology - a logic that plagues both the left and Bidenomics
@70sBachchan
@pathtopraxis
@pathtopraxis
FWIW This is the best rebuttal of Industrial Policy boosterism I’ve read yet. I don’t agree with every single point and there’s of course the big, open question of left political strategy only touched on at the end, but this is an impressively comprehensive analysis
Reading Federal Reserve's General Counsel Howard Hackley's memo, which provided legal clarification permitting central bank swap-lines and potentially with the IMF. Thankful to Nathan for generously sharing this and the treasure trove of Fed history (below) with his subscribers.
It's finally here: I got seven secret Federal Reserve books through FOIA. In this piece I provide access to all of them and give a background description of their contents and why they are important.
I agree with Zoltan that we have entered Bretton Woods III (a term I've been using in my own slow book-in-progress). But this is not Zoltan's Bretton Woods III of 'commodity-backed currencies in the East' but, I wager, a weaponized global dollar system.
@adam_tooze
@policytensor
I love Roitman's repetition that crisis is a concept. As I teach in my class 'Crisis Economics,' crisis is both a rupture in the existing order but also revelatory of its inner workings. The work of crisis-as-concept then is to denaturalize systems via history and heterogeneity.
"The ends of perpetual crisis" - this smart essay by
@RoitmanJanet
has been cited as though it were a knockdown critique of the term polycrisis. I would see it as an extremely useful elucidation of what a self-reflexive usage entails. Recommended.
Just in time for the
@jainfamilyinst
panel tomorrow: Lance Taylor declares the global savings glut hypothesis dead, conducts the autopsy, and argues for an overdetermined perspective on current account imbalances.
@NathanTankus
@JWMason1
@adam_tooze
<Sovereign debt defaulters>
@AnnPettifor
pointedly notes that the Nixon Shock (1971) constituted the largest sovereign debt default in history. For obvious reasons it isn't generally described as such.
Love
@DanielDenvir
's use of the conjunction "and" to capture the complexity of this historical conjucture and Baconi is superb on politicising Hamas. And The Dig has truly been a superb podcast for political economy analysis this year.
Remarkable data. A $1 trillion current account deficit for the US in 2022 is without precedent. And unlike 2006-8, nobody I know is talking about the dollar crashing. Let's call that epistemic progress.
"Global current account balances—the overall size of headline current account deficits and surpluses—widened for a third consecutive year in 2022."
Indeed.
<White World Dollar Order> Writing a book on our world dollar order and this essay is part of a larger story. Thanks to
@fact_pattern
for his superlative editing.
@GeneralTheorist
on Keynes' plan for the postwar international currency union that was derailed by countervailing forces (The White Plan) and unfortunate circumstances (Keynes' premature death) is really worth a read: "Should [it] be called dolphin" . . .
Against the 'so what?' view here is a superb explanation of why studying the 'polycrisis' matters and why the effort requires urgent and interdisciplinary collaboration.
@70sBachchan
@kmac
@adam_tooze
Giving birth in Gaza today, where the healthcare system has been obliterated, means facing the risk of a caesarean section without anaesthesia and a hysterectomy to stanch bleeding post childbirth. Add that to the catalogue of terror.
Super-interesting piece on the alarming state-of-affairs in the UK. But I think that understanding the hemorrhaging in manufacturing is also key to the wage-productivity puzzle. Back in 1995, manufacturing amounted to 19% of UK GDP and by 2014, it had fallen to less than 10%.
$4 trillion per year for the global energy transition: What if the IMF Spring meetings centered around mobilizing this goal? From
@adam_tooze
's latest Chartbook Carbon Notes.
Stability at the core of the global dollar system will be countered by tremendous instability in the global South. That will propel its own terrifying dynamics of perpetual conflict and immiseration made worse by climate change. This is the world we are handing over to our kids
Superb thread by
@murtazahsyed
on the new IMF loan programme to Pakistan. Raises the question (for me): What if gross capital formation were to replace fiscal consolidation (adjustment) as IMF conditionality?
Last week, the
@IMFNews
released its latest report on Pakistan. It marked the start of our 24th waltz together. It pulled us back from the brink of default. We all heaved a sigh of relief. But the report reads like an SOS. A last call. You might want to sit down for this one ...
Is this 1971 when Nixon delinked the dollar from gold causing monetary havoc? Not if the Fed has institutionalized dollar-liquidity via swaps and standing repo facilities to money markets as it did last year. If anything, the dollar will become stronger and even more weaponized.
Nice piece
@ntinatzouvala
. Despite the famine in Afghanistan, none of the country's frozen foreign exchange reserves have been disbursed back to the Afghan people via the Afghan Fund set up last year.
A recurring & inefficient outcome where the IMF withholds a new loan disbursement (because of a 'failure' to meet IMF prog. targets) and the borrower uses its RMB swapline to pay back the IMF. May be fixed by IMF quotas & voting share reform that give China greater representation
Another great piece by a close observer of developing economies
@Jonthn_Wheatley
on the collateral damage of a strong dollar --> currencies dive across EMs
<Petrodollar and Pax Americana> The Ukraine crisis has intensified our weaponized world-order. A victory for military Keynesianism over a green new deal. Looking back at the Suez crisis of 1956, provides some disturbing parallels to the current one:
As Reuniões de Primavera do FMI são semana que vem, neste ano que marca o aniversário de 80 anos de Bretton Woods
A hegemonia mundial do dólar está no centro das atenções
@MonaAli_NY_US
conta os detalhes dessa discussão aqui:
Of course, the other side of growing trade imbalances are the financial ones. In contrast to the IMF's own recommendations (China reduce EXR intervention which will most likely further devalue the RMB and increase China's already vast $$ reserves), Setser's (as well as Pettis's)
A big devaluation by a country with rising reported reserves and the biggest surplus in manufactures the modern world has seen would almost certainly lead to the fracturing of the global economy that the IMF fears ...
1/2
Another great piece on the shifting tectonics of the world dollar order. For all the talk about red states realigning, it appears that China is sanctioning Russian oil sales in order to avoid secondary sanctions imposed by the U.S.
‘Romanticising Palestinians, expecting us to show our strength, resilience and patience throughout it all, imposes mythical terms on our experience and our everyday struggles. It obscures our humanity.’
New on the blog from
@MalakaShwaikh
:
How unequal country quotas at the IMF make climate-vulnerable countries underrepresented in decisions that disproportionately impact them. Essential analysis from
@LaraMerling
.
Agree with the sentiment albeit I'd put it a bit differently. The US debt ceiling is like Brexit: a completely unnecessary self-inflicted injury. What's the appropriate analogy from ancient Greek tragedy?
The debt ceiling = the British royal family.
Both bumble along irrelevantly, then suddenly it’s ubiquitous coverage while we follow every breathless detail.
Apologists defend archaic virtues but reasonable people long for dropping the whole silly, exorbitant charade
Before this war is over, Western political economy will be transformed — in a very bad way. Biden and the gang will be thrown out, to be replaced by militarized adaptationists and corporate welfare queens. 12/
Seems that questions about 'neutrality' are worth thinking about again: here is the Bank for International Settlement's neutrality declaration (December 1939).
This Foreign Affairs piece - by Summers, Zelikow and Zoellick - is superb.
I have fairly conservative views on seizing v freezing foreign exchange reserves but I found their arguments on this hard issue persuasive.
Clarifying the BoP perspective,
@Brad_Setser
. It's when China becomes the 'world's banker' i.e runs the biggest current account deficit and finances it by selling yuan-denominated debt which has the quality of being a global safe asset like the $. Agree we are very far from that.
So there won't really be petroyuan in my view until the US, the UK and India (the world's big borrowers, in net terms, based on their current account deficits) start issuing a lot of yuan denominated debt ...
We are a long ways away from that.
6/