Senior reporter
@chronicle
who covers people and politics.
Send me tips! emma.pettit
@chronicle
.com. DM for Signal. Snail mail to 1255 23rd St. NW, D.C., 20037
I’ve been able to connect with lots of academics on Twitter. If you’re leaving platform, I get it! But I still want to hear your story ideas, tips, and feedback.
You can always get in touch at emma.pettit @ chronicle dot com. Save it in your phone for a rainy day 😊
Outlook's search function is perfect for those days when you want to read just 30 percent of the emails between you and someone else, out-of-order, without any of your replies or attachments showing up
Holy cow! The Post publishes the letter it received from Harvard's hired defamation attorneys back in October, who threatened to sue for "immense" damages and basically told the news outlet to get lost.
I'm very interested in how colleges will respond to these 'divisive concept' bills becoming law.
If you are too, here's one example. The University of Florida just sent a presentation to faculty on the newly signed Stop Woke Act...
Very interesting development at the University of Georgia. More than 50 tenured professors have said they plan to mandate masks in their classrooms, in violation of the system's rules:
NEW: I’ve been asking Harvard about its investigation into alleged plagiarism by President Gay, and tonight, they provided some new information to
@chronicle
. I’ll thread it here. Bear with me...
🚨At least one Florida university is assembling a list of courses on critical race theory and DEI, at the behest of Ron DeSantis.
He sent a memo asking for info "regarding the expenditure of state resources" on such courses and programs.
Me pitching a reported version of the professor-friendship Twitter discourse but the headline is “Can an undergrad be your friend?” and the body is just “no ❤️”
You're telling me a U of Chicago philosophy professor divorced her philosophy professor husband to marry her graduate student and now they all live together and no one thought to email me
Good morning from Morgantown, WV! I’m on campus for a student protest of academic program cuts WVU's administration has proposed.
You’ve no doubt seen news about the cuts on your timeline. I’m going to thread some background reading and post a few updates here later today.
How these laws play out in practice will be something to watch.
If your college has sent around this kind of advice, please send it to me! Emma.pettit
@chronicle
.com
Now for the slides. There's a distillation of the law's "core message," which is that profs shouldn't preach their personal views as gospel, next to a picture of some sunflowers.
Had a very brief interaction w a Pulitzer Prize finalist today.
Her: "You know what's another word for finalist?"
Me: "um"
Her: "Loser."
I will treasure this forever.
First there’s a short intro by Kent Fuchs, the president. He says the presentation makes clear “you may continue to address important academic issues in your classes” and thanks profs for their “important role” as “objective" educators and teachers.
Despite everything else going on here, the claim from
@HamlineU
's prez that the adjunct instructor did not "lose" her job because she's on a short-term contract is just in bad faith, imo. Under that kind of thinking, no adjuncts would ever "lose" their jobs!
One of my favorite quirks of universities is the omnipresence of the mascot. If your mascot is a bear you better BELIEVE the meal plan will be called something like G.R.O.W.L. and the student union will be called The Den and the data management system is like HIBERNATE!
There are slides that summarize what's now banned under the law, and then assurance that these concepts can still be discussed, just without endorsement.
And then there's some slides that say what an instructor's role should be. Like encouraging vigorous and open discussions, "not imposing personal views about controversial topics," and "effectively managing classroom discussions that can become heated."
Hi
#highered
Twitter. I'm looking for professor bands. What's a professor band, you ask? Basically, any group of academics who choose to rock out or sing the blues or whatever in their free time.
Please DM me if you know of/are in a band.
#edchat
#AcademicTwitter
@chronicle
@FreeBeacon
Here's a screenshot of what Harvard sent me about its scope of what it calls its initial review, and its policies, which I quote from and reference above.
And with that, I've summarized all the new info I've gotten.
Still wrapping my head around it, so tell me your thoughts!
According to The Post, Clare Locke sent them a second letter denying that Gay was a plagiarist on November 7.
That's while the review by three external scholars into whether Gay had plagiarized was still going on, per Harvard's timeline.
And here's my story on today's walkout. I spoke to a WVU alum who drove 5 hours (!) to attend.
As I write, for the protesters, a fundamental question underlined their shouts and signs: What sort of education must a public flagship provide?
Good morning from Morgantown, WV! I’m on campus for a student protest of academic program cuts WVU's administration has proposed.
You’ve no doubt seen news about the cuts on your timeline. I’m going to thread some background reading and post a few updates here later today.
News: At today's New College of FL board meeting,
@realchrisrufo
moved to take steps to eliminate the school's gender studies program.
The director of the program is on the board and vigorously opposed the directive, which the full board approved.
@chronicle
story coming soon.
@chronicle
Nevertheless, the review *did* find what they call "instances" of Gay failing to "adhere" to that guide.
Here's more context for those instances and the corrections to two articles that Gay asked for, which Harvard has already acknowledged.
Stumbled across this earnest email that I, at age 16, sent to Time Magazine, asking for advice on becoming a journalist.
"I'm not exactly sure who will be reading this or if anyone will even respond, but I just thought hey, why not give it a shot."
Basically how I email now.
Now this is something.
FL College System presidents say they won't fund any policy or requirement that "compels belief in critical race theory or related concepts such as intersectionality..."
@chronicle
First, Harvard says the U and Gay learned of the allegations when contacted by the New York Post, in October.
Five days later, President Gay asked the Harvard Corporation to "conduct an independent review of the articles referenced" in the Post’s outreach.
Some more UF news, from me:
The dean who rejected one expert witness request says he was directed to do so by central admin.
He asked for "further discussion, negotiation, or understanding" of the policy but "did not receive that opportunity."
FIRE is petitioning San Francisco State to drop its investigation into a professor for showing a drawing of the Prophet Muhammad during a history class.
I first reported on the professor's case, as part of a trend story on classroom dynamics, here:
1/ Déjà vu!
Once again, a professor is under investigation for showing an image of Muhammad while teaching about the history of the Islamic world.
TAKE ACTION: Demand that
@SFSU
drop its bogus investigation.
A new national poll from
@chronicle
has some curious findings, including that most Americans, regardless of political party, don't want government substantially influencing what's taught in college.
Read all about that bipartisan finding here!
My favorite part about contentious public meetings is that the controversial bit on the agenda never happens right at the beginning so everyone in the audience just has to sit and listen to workplace awards for like 20 minutes
"We beg teenagers to think of our babies, to feel for our dead, and please not to kill us. Some of them oblige. Some do not — an alarming number do not. The university’s response so far amounts to: Beg better."
@chronicle
As for the complaint filed Dec. 19 with Harvard's research integrity office (first reported by
@FreeBeacon
): Harvard says it included old allegations already adjudicated, plus four new ones that the subcommittee determined "to be without merit."
@chronicle
So who looked at what?
Per Harvard, the expert panel looked at all “all of the anonymous allegations” from the Post's inquiry.
The subcommittee “further reviewed all of President Gay’s other published works from 1993 to 2019.”
The review *did not* include Gay’s diss...
@chronicle
Because, per Harvard, “the allegations at the time concerned Gay’s published works.”
Since then, the subcommittee *has* taken a look and found one issue that had already been flagged, plus "two other examples of duplicative language without appropriate attribution."
From my inbox: AAUP groups representing nine states across the southeast — Georgia, Indiana, Louisiana, South Carolina, Texas, Tennessee, Virginia, Kentucky, and Oklahoma — are lobbying to get colleges covered by Biden's vaccine mandate for federal contractors.
@chronicle
The Post has said it asked about two journal articles and her 1993 essay.
Per Harvard, the corporation put together a subcommittee to assess the allegations.
On Nov. 2, three experts with no ties to Harvard were appointed to undertake a review.
If you're a faculty member who quit or retired or got fired this fall because of Covid planning, please let me know! Please also send me any news clips about this if you see any — thank you!
@chronicle
@FreeBeacon
As for why the Harvard corp. was even tapped in the first place, as opposed to some internal process, Harvard says that decision was made "due to the potential for the appearance of a conflict of interest, because these offices ultimately report to the President."
@chronicle
Per Harvard, Gay is updating her diss to correct "these instances of inadequate citation." See my above tweet for the specifics.
Ok now back to what *was* looked at during the review...
Two Iowa state senators complained about a U of Iowa research engineer's blog on water quality issues.
In a state run by Big Ag, things got interesting:
@chronicle
Harvard points to the FAS policy on research misconduct (which I'll link below).
Neither the panel or subcommittee "found evidence of intentional deception or recklessness in Gay’s work, which is a required element" for finding misconduct under this policy.
@chronicle
Here's that policy.
Harvard also told me that the subcommittee consulted Harvard's guide to using sources but says its a "reference resource," not a "governing policy."
For context, Gov. DeSantis proposed a host of reforms to Florida higher ed a few weeks ago.
At the presser, Chris Rufo, a new New College trustee, said faculty hires "have to sign a loyalty oath to radical race and gender theory in order to just be considered for employment."
A GOP state senator in Florida has introduced a bill that would prohibit colleges or universities in the state from requiring "a person to complete a political loyalty test as a condition of employment," which is defined to include support for "diversity, equity, and inclusion."
Tried to get at that here in my piece on these bills, which traces their impetus to a conservative writer/activist and also attempts to characterize what CRT actually is, according to the scholars who study it:
It's a failure of journalism if stories on the critical race theory "controversy" do not include the factual and contextual reporting that this is a well-planned Republican misinformation strategy and that nearly nothing being labeled critical race theory actually is CRT.
Some news: Next week will be my last at
@ArkansasOnline
. Thrilled to say that later this month, I'll be starting at
@chronicle
, covering faculty life/issues.
I'm so so thankful for the 2 yrs I've spent in AR. And if you're a professor, DM me! I need your story ideas!
In interviews with 40 faculty members from various academic disciplines who have left Florida colleges in recent years, 33 said the state’s political climate was a direct factor in their decision.
As many, many people have already pointed out on this app, this story about UNC's BOT rejecting Nikole Hannah-Jones' tenure bid because of the 1619 project is a reminder of *who* holds the power on college campuses.
So proud of my dad,
@TerryPettit1
, who was inducted into the University of Nebraska Athletics Hall of Fame today. A legendary coach who paved the way for women’s athletics, and also a pretty decent Scrabble player and father.
Ok I'm almost done self-promoting this story but the New York Times Education Briefing called it "a good read" so you bet your ass I'm tweeting it again
Moved in with my boyfriend a couple weeks ago and he never had a cat growing up, and he is absolutely mystified that Petal sleeps like 20 hours a day. He keeps pointing to her on the couch to say “she’s just sleeping!!!” Yes yes she is and she’s doing it perfectly
There should be some kind of journalism training program where you send recordings of interviews you've conducted to veteran reporters and they give you feedback on what you did well and where you could have pushed harder, or found a different opening, or asked a better question
I am about to start playing in an overnight volleyball tournament. As in, you start playing at 8 pm and stop playing at 2? 4? Sometimes later? It does not sound like a good idea, and I am not exactly sure why I agreed to do this. All I know is that I am here now.
🧵Two years ago, I read a letter, written in 1959, from a professor to his friend.
He'd been found out, he confided. Under interrogation, he had admitted to engaging in homosexual acts.
That confession cost him his job and nearly cost him his life...
Rec for journalists if you haven't tried it already: Google Pinpoint. Upload any records (emails, pdfs, excels) and it makes them all searchable, and pulls out key names and places. I just started using and have the zeal of a convert:
I should say a little more about my project. I'll be researching and reporting on the Johns Committee, a state of Florida investigative body that, from 1956 to 1965, persecuted actual and suspected gay professors and students, expelling them from higher education institutions...
“Harvard and President Gay stand together in their determination that the proposed article must not be published."
Any suggestion of plagiarism “rests on a fatally flawed understanding of what ‘plagiarism’ is (and is not) in scholarly work performed in academic journals.."
Sorry to put this out into the universe but do acrylic nails….decompose? At the same rate as bodies? Are there skeletons out there that are just bones and then also there’s some fun nail art mixed in? sorry sorry sorry
“Check out this numnut who...has nothing to do but highlight slavery at UVA,” texted a board member to two others about a vice provost at the U of Virginia.
Just catching up on this story from
@wpnick
and wow wow wow:
Richard Corcoran, interim prez of New College of Florida, reportedly offered $5K bonuses to admissions staff if they reached a goal of 300 more students.
That may have violated federal law, experts told
@chronicle
.
As it’s my last day in Arkansas, here’s a list of things I didn’t know I loved before living here:
-Mockingbirds
-Waffle House at 10 am
-Waffle House at 2 am
-Smoky bars (sorry mom)
-Everyone’s ‘Clinton stood near me once’ stories
-SEC underdog fandom
me pitching: hey instead of news can i interest you in something that happened 60 years ago and everyone is dead and wait here is the really good part — no one has heard of it
The all-out blitz that's going on in state legislatures rn to suppress "woke" viewpoints in higher ed should be getting waaaay more attention than it seems to be:
Right now, WVU's University Assembly is considering a vote of no confidence in President Gee, and a vote to freeze the pending program cuts. If you're interested, you can watch along here:
For all of you evening readers...Howard was playing the long game,
@Brown_e_Points
reports.
The president had been talking with Coates "for more than two years" about him returning. Coates then introduced the prez to Hannah-Jones.