Districts are in an untenable position b/c state leaders failed to adequately fund public ed w/ a huge budget surplus despite inflation & yrs of rising cost of living in TX communities. Schools in low-income communities will likely take the biggest hit. That's failed leadership.
Vouchers aren't driven by evidence but by billionaires funneling millions into state elections. Texas's independence is being sold by opportunistic politicians swapping a proven loser of a policy (ineffective, inefficient, & discriminatory) for power. Our kids deserve better.
Vouchers were 1st proposed in TX in 1956 to stop school integration after the Brown decision. Today, voucher advocates REMAIN COMMITTED TO PUBLICLY-FUNDED DISCRIMINATION. Listen to the shameful response of the voucher bill author to a proposal to add text to prohibit
I couldn't be more humbled & honored to be promoted to full professor at a place that strives to change the world every day. So grateful to the many people & communities who invested in me, lifted me up, carried me, educated me, and made this possible... from NJ to BMORE, DC, El
A Master Class on Failed Leadership: With a massive budget surplus at hand, Abbott is holding teacher salaries hostage amid massive inflation in a state that had 50k teachers leave their positions last yr & ranks 41st for school funding. This is not about kids, evidence, or the
Policymakers saying vouchers improve outcomes for students w/ disabilities is like doctors saying smoking improves a runner's mile time - It's malpractice. Vouchers create a dual, unequal system that leads to discrimination against children w/ disabilities. The focus must be on
It's DECEITFUL for the voucher bill's author to suggest parity in public & private schools serving students w/ disabilities. He surely knows there are many types of disabilities that differ in nature, severity, & cost. Many private schools only admit students w/ less severe
I'm very proud & very grateful of the Texans who stood up for public education, & more importantly our state's children. A bi-partisan consensus continues to agree that vouchers have a negative impact on voucher users, promotes discrimination, & should not be funded by Texans.
The
#Txlege
& state leaders failed to appropriately fund special ed. That's not my opinion, that's a federal court decision. Vouchers deplete an already underfunded system & will harm kids w/ disabilities. Instead, raise special ed teacher salaries & recruit service providers.
The Texas House voted to ban school vouchers including education savings accounts. That's great news for KIDS b/c vouchers lack accountability, are prone to fraud & failure, discriminate against kids w/ disabilities, & don't raise achievement.
@pastors4txkids
@TexasAFT
Vouchers don't raise student achievement. They promote discrimination against students w/ disabilities, hurt rural schools & subsidize wealthy families."To put it in Texas terms, vouchers are as worthless as a sidesaddle on a sow."
@pastors4txkids
@TexasAFT
@DianeRavitch
@RYHTexas
Every Texan should be outraged by the state-appointed
@HoustonISD
sup's decision to eliminate librarians in 28 schools w/ low reading scores serving mostly Black/Latino kids. This is senseless/indefensible/indicative of failed leadership.
@TexasAFT
@MomsAGAbbott
@DianeRavitch
The TRUTH is TX families want teacher retention & safe schools - not vouchers. Right-wing extremists push vouchers & donate to politicians to attack public schools. Voucher polls are skewed by these attacks & tricky analyses.
@TexasAFT
@DianeRavitch
@MomsAGAbbott
@pastors4txkids
I wrote this b/c I've yet to meet a TX parent that believes a few billionaires & their think tanks should dictate how education tax $$ are spent. I don't know why a billionaire cartel wants vouchers, but I can tell you they are pushing a false bill of goods that are unsupported
“Do I want billionaires in Michigan and California or elite think tanks in Austin making decisions about how my child’s education is funded?”
@DrDeMatt
writes.
Vouchers = Education Malpractice because it has no parental due process, no accountability, removes $ from public schools, & disproportionately harms rural communities. The most recent bill acknowledges this fact.
#Txlege
#
@TexasAFT
@pastors4txkids
@txstateteachers
@DianeRavitch
We elect politicians to serve the public & prioritize the public good - not special interests. WHAT ELSE BUT a flood of voucher supporting special interest $$$ has propelled our governor to prioritize a few billionaires' policy preference over the adequate funding of public
Why on🌎are policymakers discussing property taxes & vouchers when $33,660 is the min. salary for 1st yr teachers? At 10 yrs exp, the min. pay is $45,630. This willful neglect is an attack on low-income rural communities!
@TexasAFT
@MomsAGAbbott
@DianeRavitch
@pastors4txkids
The only reason we're still talking about vouchers in TX is b/c a few out-of-touch billionaires are funneling millions into campaigns of opportunistic politicians who don't know or don't care about the evidence - vouchers are anti-civil rights legislation.
@TexasTribune
@TexasAFT
The Texas governor "led" through multiple school mass shootings w/o making schools safer, failed to raise teacher pay despite shortages or reign in charter sector fraud. He oversees a state that violated special ed laws & is annually rated as "Needs Improvement" for special
To be clear:
Hugh Shine voted to stop a bill that included $6 billion in funding for public schools & teacher pay raises, more money for school security, and an end to the STAAR test.
Hillary Hickland would have supported that bill.
One of many reasons I support Hillary
Passing vouchers is as senseless as a surgeon mending a broken leg before stabilizing a patient's breathing. Let's call it LEGISLATIVE MALPRACTICE to pursue an optional policy for a small group of parents before ensuring all 5.5 million students in TX public schools are safe &
Republicans & Democrats don't have to agree on everything, but we can all agree democracy wasn't for sale in Beaumont, TX tonight. Grateful to see
@DadePhelan
retain his seat after the governor & right-wing billionaires sought to oust him for not pushing private school vouchers -
TX has the worst state-level public ed leadership in the nation, riddled w/ perpetual scandals/failures: special ed caps, ever-changing dyslexia policies, mass shootings, charter school corruption, no-bid contracts, failed roll outs of testing, public attacks on teachers,
TX failed to protect kids in foster care for more than 10 yrs leading to at least 23 deaths in custody between 2019 & 2021. Yet, some TX politicians prioritize DEI, tenure, CRT, & school choice bills? This entire agenda is bogus, immoral, & profoundly anti-child.
#txlege
#txed
The continued push for vouchers in TX despite decades-long bi-partisan opposition is not about parents, kids, or what works - it's a few billionaires's policy preference & a distraction from real issues: school finance, teacher salaries, school safety, mental health, & a shortage
School choice is not the way forward for Texas. Proposed voucher legislation transfers taxpayer $$ from our already underfunded public schools to private schools w/o accountability or protections against discrimination based on race, disability, or class. Join me
@UTexasLaw
for a
TX is engaged in a anti-democratic, ideologically-driven, hostile takeover of
@HoustonISD
. Punitive measures - like swapping out libraries for discipline centers - don't improve schools/kid's lives. This is predictable failure/harm.
@TexasAFT
@MomsAGAbbott
@DianeRavitch
@nytimes
QUESTION: Would Texas have 50k teachers exiting their jobs last yr, a 2,400-to-1 school psychologist to student ratio, & guns as the leading cause of child death if our governor supported public education, mental healthcare, & school safety half as much as he supports vouchers?
Vouchers have NEGATIVE impacts on achievement in other states. So why transfer public schools $ to unaccountable private schools? Why not pay teachers fairly? This is ideology/politics, not about evidence & helping kids.
@tasanet
@RYHTexas
@TexasAFT
@pastors4txkids
@DianeRavitch
Do your homework on proposed voucher legislation. Vouchers fail to raise achievement & take $$ out of public schools, which disproportionately hurts rural schools. Instead, let’s focus on teacher pay and retention
#TXlege
@pastors4txkids
@TexasAFT
@DianeRavitch
@jamestalarico
The WRONG question: Is there a teacher shortage? The RIGHT question: Why has our society & politics undervalued the teaching profession? Quality public schools are the bedrock of democracy & engines for social mobility so reforms must invest in (pay/quality) the profession.
You don’t need a JD or a PhD to know vouchers are a bad policy, esp for students w/ disabilities. Grateful for the opportunity to join a
@FedSoc
debate at
@UTLaw
. We need more forums like this to debate. Here is a snippet someone shared w/ me
@DisRightsTx
@TexasAFT
Imagine a legislature holding DEI hearings, but not hearings on a broken foster care system, high rates of teacher turnover & uncertified teachers, school funding inequities, the closing of rural hospitals, or an inability to staff counselors & armed security after Uvalde. We
So much attention spent on failed policies (vouchers) this session while TX had 50k teachers leave in 2022. Teachers are a school's most valuable resource & our policies aren't keeping them in the classroom, esp where they're needed most.
@TexasAFT
@MomsAGAbbott
@pastors4txkids
Vouchers are no choice b/c: "No rational Texan wants a choice that doesn't improve outcomes, promotes discrimination against kids w/ disabilities, & takes $$ out of public ed to subsidize private school tuition for the wealthy."
@pastors4txkids
@TexasAFT
@DianeRavitch
#TXLege
I hope Texans ask: Could we've done better by our kids given our state’s resources? We owe them an honest answer with 20yrs of flat test scores, an inequitable finance system, reckless charter growth, teacher shortages, & illogical voucher proposals.
@TexasAFT
@pastors4txkids
Important story in
@dallasnews
on governor's attack on incumbent House Republicans who didn't support vouchers. He can do that, but the fact remains: HE HAS FAILED to support public schools serving 5.4 million TX kids. Voters will remember, esp in rural TX.
#txlege
@MomsAGAbbott
PUZZLING: TEA thinks they should take over
@HoustonISD
(TX's largest district/200k kids w/ a "B" rating on it's accountability system), but cannot coordinate publishing a takeover announcement before posting takeover job descriptions!
@TexasAFT
@pastors4txkids
@DianeRavitch
Vouchers are about individual preferences not the public good or for those w/ greatest need. Happy
@pastors4txkids
are fighting for public ed b/c TX can't stop charters from buying luxury condos. Giving private schools $ w/o oversight is predictable fraud.
If we want to improve special ed in
@HoustonISD
or
@AustinISD
, TEXAS must address the STATEWIDE shortage of school psychologists so districts can hire people to provide needed services. The student-SP ratio in Texas is UNACCEPTABLE: 1-2,338!
#txlege
#txed
@DisRightsTx
Rejecting vouchers is about as "Texas a thing" as cowboy boots, longhorns, & Friday night lights.
@GregAbbott_TX
has every right to make endorsements based on voucher votes, but just b/c he has that right doesn't mean he should exercise it. Leadership sometimes requires
Proud to endorse 58 Texas House Republicans for re-election in 2024.
I encourage Texans to join me in supporting these strong conservatives so we can deliver school choice for every family in Texas.
Full endorsement list below.
Public schools are closing b/c of financial constraints due to inflation, security costs, & shrinking enrollment. This was preventable w/ a budget surplus but the governor pushed an externally-funded private school voucher program at the expense of 5.4 mill TX kids in public ed.
I see a lot of advice from academics lately. The only advice I can give: Success in academia requires healthy relationships & collaboration. So, treat people well, share your time, assume others are doing their best, & take note of those who mistreat/take advantage of others.
Let me remind you
@DeAngelisCorey
that we have, respect, & abide by something called the Texas Constitution. Since the 1800s, hardworking, honest Texans paid taxes for the support & maintenance of public free schools. Our tax dollars belong in public schools. No such law has ever
State takeovers don't change the fact that Texas has reported a special education teacher SHORTAGE every yr since 2014-15.
@HoustonISD
@AustinISD
NEED the state/
#txlege
to create conditions that ensure a stable pipeline of teachers/staff necessary to provide high quality special
I'm launching the TX EDUCATION LEADERSHIP LAB to conduct relevant research to improve TX schools. WE are already studying the TX educator workforce, special ed, and the impact of vouchers. STAY TUNED, CHECK US OUT, & SUPPORT OUR WORK.
@utexascoe
@TexasAFT
@UCEA
@DianeRavitch
We need a special session to address public school funding. It's irresponsible/harmful for the governor to hold funding for 5.4 million public school kids for his donor's pet private school voucher policy - allowing private schools to reject any kid & not follow federal/state
HB 100 was my signature piece of legislation for the 88th Regular Legislative Session. I'm very sad to say that it ultimately did not pass! Below is my statement.
SB 8 (voucher) substitute is A JOKE. Its authors claim to be for students w/ disabilities but place NO RESPONSIBILITY on private schools for following federal law or providing research-based instruction like public schools.
@TexasAFT
@pastors4txkids
@MomsAGAbbott
@DianeRavitch
Texas has long been the Wild West for special ed.
@AustinISD
/
@HoustonISD
must improve but failure is largely a product of the state's: old 8.5% cap, insufficient $, teacher/staff shortages, & flawed monitoring/technical assistance.
@TexasAFT
@GinaForAustin
@DisRightsTx
I love my neighbors & the UNITED STATES so I believe in public schools for all not a DIVIDED STATE w/ a taxpayer funded private system that denies access to students w/ disabilities or those w/o enough $ for tuition.
@TexasAFT
@MomsAGAbbott
@pastors4txkids
@DianeRavitch
@RYHTexas
The numbers don't lie: a majority of Texans from rural, urban, and suburban communities support school choice.
Parents know what's best for their children's education.
This session, we must put mom and dad back in charge.
Appointed HISD board of managers just now appears to struggle to maintain order as they vote to make Mike Miles acting superintendent of the district after the state takeover last week
It's time to stop arguing about learning loss. It's an elite talking point. We should all agree schools/teachers/classrooms positively impact kids & the pandemic took that away. Let's focus on teacher development/retention, curriculum, family engagement, & quality assessments.
After prior TEA investigations, it was a 2021 internal audit by IDEA Charters that found serious misuse of funds. A special
#Txlege
session on school choice is needed... on charter fraud, embezzlement, & unethical practices.
@MomsAGAbbott
@pastors4txkids
@TexasAFT
@DianeRavitch
We're at a point in TX (& this country) where a school shooting TODAY wasn't the TOP STORY in the local paper. Have we given up? The top story was a demolished mall. We CANNOT accept violence in schools or the mass proliferation of guns. We need common sense gun reform.
@TexasAFT
Texas has failed to adequately fund schools in poorer communities. Texas has failed to create a stable pipeline of high-quality teachers. We need to be honest about those failures & we need change!
@dsknight84
@txstatepta
@TexasAFT
@pastors4txkids
Congratulations to our ELP professor David DeMatthews, elected as the President-Elect for UCEA. He will be the President for next year’s UCEA conference (2021)
Grateful to
@utexascoe
for recognizing my scholarship. Also grateful to countless colleagues & students who made that work possible AND all the superintendents, principals, teachers, parents, & students who choose to be research participants along the way.
The
#TXlege
should not underwrite DISCRIMINATION of kids w/ disabilities. Any special ed voucher bill (HB 4340) that explicitly states private schools receive state $ but need not follow federal civil rights laws for students w/ disabilities MUST be rejected.
@TexasAFT
Why send tax $ to private schools w/ UNLICENSED personnel? TX voucher bill requires private tutors/therapists to hold "a relevant license" to receive voucher $ but lacks same requirement for private school principals/teachers. The state requires this for public schools.🤔
#Txlege
There's NO CASE for vouchers. These
#Txlege
ANTI-CIVIL RIGHTS bills have no fraud protection/accountability or evidence they benefit kids. Vouchers are about privatization, legalizing publicly-funded discrimination against kids w/ disabilities, & harming rural schools.
#txed
Predictable Failure: A commissioner unable to get TX out of NEEDS ASSISTANCE for special ed, w/ no teaching/school/district exp, unable/unwilling to monitor charter fraud or his agency (see SpedEx), picks the founder of a charter network to lead
@HISD
.
@TexasAFT
@DianeRavitch
20% of TX principals left their jobs last yr (12yr high). Turnover leads to school instability & teacher attrition, esp in high-need urban/rural schools.
#Txlege
must support policies to improve educator/admin working conditions.
@TexasAFT
@MomsAGAbbott
@RYHTexas
@NASSP
@naesp
We actually have some
#TXlege
policymakers more concerned about "CRT" being taught to ADULTS choosing to go to college than deadly gun policies making it legal for 18yr olds to buy assault rifles to slaughter CHILDREN/teachers.
@AAUP
@TexasAFT
@DianeRavitch
@MomsAGAbbott
@ACLUTx
TX kids are no safer after
#Uvalde
& legislative session b/c districts can't find enough armed security/police for all 8,900 campuses. Sad, predictable failure given TX's inability to improve gun laws, mental health, & school funding.
@TexasAFT
@MomsAGAbbott
@DianeRavitch
#TXlege
The sad truth is some opportunistic politicians care more about a fabricated DEI problem than funding schools, keeping rural hospitals open, fixing the foster care system, & having a counselor & armed security in every school after Uvalde & Santa Fe. Let's have those hearings
The best ed policy is investing in public schools & teacher quality not importing failed policies from other states/cities. Research is clear: vouchers don't work. Grateful to talk to Texans about it tonight. Link below
@TexasAFT
@pastors4txkids
@tasanet
A
@fox7austin
segment used my quote to have "both sides" discuss vouchers but there aren't 2 sides to facts. Vouchers don't ⬆️achievement, but they do promote discrimination of kids w/ disabilities, hurt rural schools/take $ from public ed.
@pastors4txkids
@TexasAFT
@DianeRavitch
What would you say if voucher legislation sent public $ to private schools w/o having to admit/serve students w/ disabilities? That's LEGISLATING DISCRIMINATION & that's SB176. Read for yourself!
#txlege
@RYHTexas
@pastors4txkids
@DianeRavitch
@tasanet
@Kress_Sandy
@1in5advocacy
Fund the regular system adequately, don't make illegal cuts, don't cap special ed, hire a commissioner w/ experience, hold charters accountable for not serving kids w/ disabilities (or for corruption/waste), eliminate low-quality teacher alt cert programs, address 20yr shortage