Larry Summers says "almost everything" about the flexible average inflation regime was "a mistake," while sitting next to Richard Clarida, who ran and championed the review that created that framework.
Some personal news: Had the best long weekend, said yes, and now have ~a year to convince this guy to let me use “rational exuberance” as a wedding hashtag.
So first, they did not talk about talking about taper.
Then they talked about talking about taper.
Then they talked about taper.
Now they're teeing up taper.
Next they'll announce taper.
Then they'll taper.
I don't have kids, but I'm wondering if this is ~how bedtime works
This is quite the stat, from Brainard: "Federal Reserve staff analysis indicates that unemployment is likely above 20 percent for workers in the bottom wage quartile, while it has fallen below 5 percent for the top wage quartile."
Goldman Sachs estimates that of the 5 m people missing from the job mkt:
- 1.5m retired early
- 1 m retired normally
- 0.9 m 55+, not retired
- 1.7 m prime-age
....aka solidly 50% probably won't come back. Which'd really dent "temporary" labor shortage storylines.
This is interesting: "Beijing has tested expiration dates to encourage users to spend it quickly, for times when the economy needs a jump start." via
@jamestareddy
"A New York Times analysis of data compiled by Capital IQ shows no statistically meaningful relationship between the size of the tax cut that companies and industries received and the investments they made."
Uh: "Instead of simply paying for property with tokens, borrowers pledge their digital holdings as collateral, with no down payments necessary. That enables the holders to keep their coins, avoiding taxes on capital gains..."
"I never hear people from a low-income background telling me that they don't want a college degree," SF Fed President Mary Daly says. It's only higher-income folks saying that maybe other people don't need one.
Fun personal news: I'm writing a book! On the modern Fed, published by Knopf. Coming 2022.
It'll feature 13-3 nerdery, a little history and at least one Gossip Girl reference, so at a minimum, it'll be like no Fed book you've read before. Thoughts? Warnings? My DM's are open.
I'm excited to say that as of April 29, you'll be able to find me
@nytimes
writing about the Fed + the economy. I'm between work emails, but feel free to DM me between now and then.
The Fed:
*Raises rates by three-quarters of a point to 3-3.25%
*Projects 4.4% rates at the end of 2022, suggesting a 75 and a 50
*Rates climb to 4.6% next year (up from 3.8%)
*Sees unemployment rising to 4.4% next year
This is a central bank in full inflation-fighting mode.
The president of the St. Louis Fed spoke at a closed-press, off-record, invite-only event that Citi hosted and asked its clients to.
Against Fed rules? Unclear, though we go through them in the story. Bad look? Definitely, a range of people said.
Elizabeth Warren + Chuy Garcia are introducing a bill that would prevent future bank mergers like BB&T-Suntrust.
It's roadmap of where bank regulation might be headed if Sen. Warren is elected.
Our exclusive:
Self reflection is important, and it's especially important if your job is to inform people.
I've read through
@Noahpinion
's takedown of my Sunday Business piece, and though he did not ask me for a comment, I have one.
Goldman Sachs forecasts that core PCE will fall from 5.1% now to 2.9% by Dec 2023, as supply chain clearing lowers good prices, wage growth starts to slow and rents moderate.
Fun fact: "1 million apartments are under construction or permitted, the largest pipeline since 1974."
Lots of misconceptions circulating about that $500 billion fund in the Senate bill.
(1) $75b goes to air carriers and security-tied co's. Mnuchin has a lot of discretion over how that's used.
(2) $425b would stand up Fed facilities. Mnuchin has much less discretion there.
- 261K job gains
- 3.7 percent unemployment
- slight tick down in participation
- 0.4 percent wage gains on a monthly basis (stronger than expected).
This does not look like a weakening labor market.
NEW: Remember the Fed trading scandal? Vice Chair Rich Clarida corrected his disclosure, and his controversial trade now looks even more eyebrow-raising.
Powell sounds really worried about this: "My assumption is that there will be a significant chunk, well into the millions," of "people who don't get to go back to their old job... there may not be a job in that industry for them for some time."
"It's very tough on their lives."
A week ago, we had the best day.
Now that Jackson Hole is winding down, I will be mostly off of this website for a few weeks for our honeymoon. If you have pressing Fed thoughts that cannot wait until Sept. 12, please email vs DM'ing. ♥️
Since 2018, Lael Brainard has been the lone Democrat at the Fed Board.
Twenty dissents, one crisis and a CRA showdown later, she's a top contender to be the first woman to lead Treasury in its 231-year history.
Fed Chair Jay Powell has been working from home, observing social distancing and mask guidelines in public settings, and has not been in contact with anyone who is known to have tested positive for the coronavirus and so has not been tested. - Fed spokesperson
"We're recovering, but to a different economy," Fed Chair Jay Powell says. "There's going to be a substantial number of workers who are going to need support as they find their way in the post-pandemic economy, because it's going to be different in fundamental ways."
I published two stories with my friend and frequent co-writer
@bencasselman
yesterday. I took the lead byline on one and he took the lead byline on the other.
Only I got this email yesterday evening.
Yikes: While high-income jobs have more than recovered, "employment among low-wage workers remains 14% below pre-pandemic levels and is trending down again."
One of these days the typo that I make in every single template is going to slip past the defenses and make it into print, and you all will learn from the pages of the NYT that Fed officials raise rats.
The London interbank offered rate has died after a long battle with regulators. It was 52.
An obituary for finance's most important number, from
@LananhTNguyen
and me.
I started covering economics 10 years ago today.
I was a newly-graduated intern, and I assumed that after 3 mos I'd go back to covering healthcare, my college beat. The universe had other plans. Grateful for all of the mentors
@business
and
@nytimes
who showed me the ropes.
Fed officials have moved at a breakneck pace over the past 14 days. For those following along at home, a quick rundown of what they've done and why. (1/)
Neel Kashkari doesn't know why markets have dialed back rate expectations so much.
"We’re going to continue to do what we need to do until we are convinced that inflation is well on its way back down to 2 percent — and we are a long way away from that.”
Bank of America, BNY Mellon, Citigroup, Goldman Sachs, JP Morgan Chase, Morgan Stanley, State Street, and Wells Fargo are stopping buybacks for now to focus on lending.
"COVID-19 pandemic is an unprecedented challenge for the world and the global economy," per release.
"Transitory is a word that people have had different understandings of," Chair Powell says, stating the very obvious. He says some people interpret it as short-lived, but the Fed really means not-permanent.
Berkeley usually gives Nobel winners a coveted parking spot near their office, but David Card rides his bike, so they have to come up with an alternative for him.
Card news conference streaming here:
Our story here:
And that's a Jackson Hole wrap. Big takeaways:
1. No urgency to hike in September.
Several Fed officials (including Powell) signaled that another hike might be coming, but the Fed can be patient in making it.
NEW: Fed officials and staffers spent last week quizzing market participants about the risk of a financial accident in the United States, post-U.K. So did the White House.
Prognosis: Not imminent, but not impossible.
w/
@jimtankersley
@JARennison
Today in "fun facts to lose sleep over":
"SVB had sufficient liquidity to handle a $16 billion single day outflow. Put in context, the largest short period outflow ever seen in a U.S. bank failure was Washington Mutual... $16.7 billion over 10 days."
Powell says we've been over-reliant on monetary policy.
"In economic discussion generally, there's much too much focus on demand management, and not enough on things that will make us grow at the maximum sustainable level - sustainable growth - in the longer run."
Ben Bernanke's cell phone was off when the Nobel call came in.
"It was our daughter in Chicago who was finally contacted, and called us on the landline," he says.
The White House is nominating Sarah Bloom Raskin, Lisa Cook and Phillip Jefferson to the Fed Board.
This would the the most diverse Fed Board ever, if these picks are confirmed by the Senate. (1/)
Let's talk about what is going down here.
My friend
@arappeport
and I wrote last week that Treasury might try to kill the novel Fed facilities. Now it is. (1/)
When I was a youth, I swam against a girl who would tell everyone that she had a stomach flu at big meets.
If she PR'd, she'd be like: "wow, even w the stomach flu." If she bombed: "well, my stomach."
Earnings calls referencing "macro headwinds" rn have ~same energy
Chair Powell takeaways:
- The economy is different this time (he said this many times)
- Inflation is too high, and it's gotten worse
- The job market is v strong
- The Fed is set to hike rates in March + after that, but not ready to say how much
- "nimble" + "humble"
Thanksgiving '22 felt very different for the rich vs. the poor.
In Boston last week, I visited a fancy hotel whose $135 Thanksgiving brunch was on waitlist. Then a food pantry where people had lined the frigid block from 4:30 am for free turkeys. (1/)
"Our peers, our competitors, advanced economy democracies have a more built up function for childcare" - Fed Chair Powell
"We used to lead the world in female labor force participation... and we no longer do. It may just be that those policies have put us behind."
The Fed saw big risks at SVB more than a year before its collapse.
It put it under supervisory review.
It put it under a review of risk management.
It banned it from growing through acquisition.
It didn't work.
Now the question is: Why?
Chair Powell takeaways:
- Big rate increases could slow in Dec or shortly after
- But rates will go higher than prior forecast
- And stay there
- His message was blunt: "I would want people to understand our commitment to getting this done."
- Upshot: This was not a pivot.
The guy who came up with the Phillips Curve was originally a crocodile hunter, per Alan Blinder's new book.
(a) Never let anyone tell you that your aspirational career change is too extreme. (1/)
More details on this new Fed emergency lending program, which is SUPER interesting:
- backed by $25B of Treasury money (ESF)
- loans of up to one year
- in exchange for Treasuries, MBS etc at par (og value)
- AKA: workaround for unrealized losses
Housing dynamics are very weird right now.
High rates = few existing home sales (who walks away from a rock-bottom rate mortgage?)
Few existing homes for sale + a big generation ~30 yo + remote work = a new home rebound in spite of 7% mortgage rates
Monroe Gamble was the
@sffed
first-ever Black research assistant. In 2018.
That wasn't a one-off. Black economists and RA's are a rarity across the Fed system, I learned from data the Fed provided for this story. (1/)
Black workers have long faced labor market barriers. As the pandemic costs jobs across racial and ethnic groups, there are reasons to worry those losses will turn out to be especially painful for minorities.
Men between 35-44 (elder millennials, younger gen x) just aren't staging the employment rebound we're seeing in other demographics.
Why?
@lydiadepillis
@bencasselman
and I dug into it.
A man in Penn Station just looked at me closely before saying, in a tone that I can only describe as philosophic, “well, everybody dresses different.”
Brb preparing to overanalyze this for the entirety of my three hour train ride.
Remember the “she-cession”? What about the early-retirement wave, or America’s army of quiet quitters?
We underestimated the healing power of America's labor market — again. What lessons can we learn from it? w/
@bencasselman
My new all-time favorite Fed transcript line. December 2015.
"CHAIR YELLEN. Okay. Boxed lunches will be available. If anybody wants to watch TV in the Special Library and see me get skewered at the press conference, please feel free."
"While tightening policy enough to reduce labor demand by just the amount needed today without causing a recession is possible conceptually, this hasn’t occurred in modern U.S. history," Goldman Sachs writes in a new note.
Jay Powell's big theme at today's subcommittee hearing is basically - I don't want to become a soundbite for your political cause.
At one point he literally said: "Yeah, I have a strong desire not to play a role in your discussion."
Many of my sources say that 2018/2019 reg rollbacks at the Fed mattered for Silicon Valley Bank. But when I follow up with the question: "Which rule changes, specifically?" the answers often haven't been super precise.
Until this one. (thread)
@Noahpinion
This was not a literature review on what macro thinks of MMT. It was a feature story about how MMT is grappling (or not grappling) with the fact that inflation has proven incredibly hard to predict, when so much of its argument relies on predicting inflation.
Fed's Barr gives us new details on the speed of the 3/10 SVB run, and... holy smokes.
"On Friday morning...the bank let us know that they expected the outflow to be vastly larger...a total of $100 billion was scheduled to go out the door that day."
Chair Powell: "We're experiencing a big uptick in inflation, bigger than many expected, bigger certainly than I expected, and we're trying to understand whether it's something that will pass through fairly quickly, or whether in fact we need to act."
This could spell strife down the road:
*Sen. Toomey tells me by email that the new Fed-related language means no future direct muni buying/biz lending w/o Congress' blessing.
*Dems say it will only prevent carbon copy programs
Keep "congressional intent" on your bingo card.
Great CPI figures for the Fed:
- 3% headline inflation, literally 1/3 of last summer
- 4.8% core, beating expectations for slowdown
- cooling supercore
- slowest monthly core increase since August 2021
Just realized that "transitory" is just like purgatory, in that you have no idea how long it's going to last and it's sure to be uncomfortable in the meantime.
A voiceover during Chair Powell's latest 60 Minutes interview suggested that the Fed chair had suggested "the likely time for the first interest rate cut would be the middle of the year."
I checked with 60 Minutes: The transcript they released reflects the full interview.
The college-aged woman sitting next to me at a coffeeshop just confessed that she "still has an Instagram," like it is a sign that she's living in the stone age.
Brb, going home to retrieve my cane.
Chair Powell may not be a Ph.D. economist, y'all, but he has nailed the two-handed thing.
"There's always a risk of going too far or going not far enough. It's going to be a difficult judgement to make, or maybe not, maybe it will be quite clear."
University of Michigan 5-year preliminary inflation expectations: 2.8%
Was: 3.1%
Forecast: 3.0%
Just one number, but that should take some pressure off the Fed to make a big 1 percentage point rate increase this month.
Contrary to some of the quotes floating out there, it's worth noting that the Fed programs legally must be broad-based -- Dodd Frank ensured that. So that $425B cannot bail out specific businesses or favored beneficiaries (eg/Trump hotels).
Claudia Goldin is the third woman to win the economics Nobel.
(She was also, fun fact, the first woman to be offered tenure in the Harvard econ department.)
BREAKING NEWS
The Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences has decided to award the 2023 Sveriges Riksbank Prize in Economic Sciences in Memory of Alfred Nobel to Claudia Goldin “for having advanced our understanding of women’s labour market outcomes.”
#NobelPrize
3. And if you want a chart to worry consumers, this is it. Food and fuel are getting a lot pricier. It's particularly notable that food at home is picking up so much, because it's harder for people to substitute away from (you can skip that dinner out; you can't skip dinner)
“It wasn’t supposed to be possible for job openings to decline by as much as they have declined without unemployment going up." - Chair Powell
Could the Fed achieve the unprecedented?