David Neumark Profile
David Neumark

@NeumarkEcon

Followers
703
Following
328
Media
12
Statuses
2,673
Explore trending content on Musk Viewer
@NeumarkEcon
David Neumark
6 months
Funny, sometimes I feel the same way.
@arindube
Arin Dube
6 months
I would prefer to not keep writing more minimum wage papers. I've other things to write about. But when people write bad papers claiming they found some flaws in my papers, I have to spend time writing more minimum wage papers to explain why said papers were bad. Such is life.
11
6
244
4
7
82
@NeumarkEcon
David Neumark
7 months
@SFJCRC @SJSU Universities should simply expel students who interfere with lectures and events in a manner that prevents them from being held or stops speakers from speaking. That's how we protect free speech.
7
9
79
@NeumarkEcon
David Neumark
1 year
Why do you only cite the rock stars for advice and insight into the profession? Most econ faculty are in very different environments and would benefit from advice of their more senior peers. I'm afraid you are reinforcing the "only superstars have something valuable to say" view.
@SimonBowmaker
Simon Bowmaker
1 year
Daron Acemoğlu speaking in 2010 about the publication process in economics:
Tweet media one
5
90
478
3
5
74
@NeumarkEcon
David Neumark
10 months
This is exactly the point. A leader of a prestigious organization should be beyond reproach, not just "not proven guilty."
@davidautor
David Autor
10 months
Appointment to leadership not akin to a criminal trial--guilty or innocent. Leadership is a privilege earned through trust. Armin Falk has lost that trust.
1
9
135
2
8
66
@NeumarkEcon
David Neumark
1 year
It gets perpetuated when departments make having one a requirement for tenure. That's a lazy short-cut. At tenure review, read the papers and evaluate them! Especially when editors are entrenched at journals for decades, why should others rely on them as the key arbiters.
@mushfiq_econ
Mushfiq Mobarak
1 year
Economists complain about "Tyranny of Top-5", but we perpetuate it. I too share the blame - it's a tempting shortcut. To move the needle, we need to celebrate valuable non-top-5 research as much as top-5. But top-5 articles are often great, so shouldn't poo-poo those either.
5
10
120
2
2
50
@NeumarkEcon
David Neumark
2 years
@CharlesWMcKinn2 Keep these stories (not quite the right word) coming. We need to hear them. For me personally, at least, they change consciousness.
1
2
47
@NeumarkEcon
David Neumark
10 months
First time you and I signed the same letter, I bet!
@arindube
Arin Dube
10 months
1
0
8
1
0
32
@NeumarkEcon
David Neumark
11 months
@IAMRI0T @StopAntisemites No one is contesting the right to take signs down. But if you take a public action, you can also be called out publicly for those actions.
1
0
29
@NeumarkEcon
David Neumark
7 months
Plus, in general lots of policies change at borders, at least state borders. And for other issues, especially in relation to @minimumwage effects, see Now forthcoming in JPE Micro.
@marcfbellemare
Marc F. Bellemare
7 months
Bad news for border discontinuities as an RD design: Shaping states into nations: The effects of ethnic geography on state borders
3
41
214
1
4
29
@NeumarkEcon
David Neumark
1 year
The #minimumwage literature is an interesting exception where journal editors have been quite open to replication/re-evaluation papers. Interesting question why this is so, more than other topics, and why on so many topics editors are uninterested in this kind of inquiry.
@thomas_hegland
Thomas
1 year
Interesting article about the low impact of replication failures in psych. I think similar questions can be asked of econ. Every couple years we have some methodological advance that proves the old ways unreliable. Are we very interested in knowing which old results hold up?
2
4
14
1
5
19
@NeumarkEcon
David Neumark
6 months
@johannarickne @Jopieboy @OlleFolke Always gotta be careful with heavily saturated models when some dummies get dropped. What looks like a treatment effect might not be. I always advise students to think through what is getting dropped and why to avoid this error.
0
1
19
@NeumarkEcon
David Neumark
10 months
Is it remotely possible that IZA will ignore a letter signed by approaching 1/2 of fellows saying they will resign if the decision is not rescinded? Unfortunately I think the answer may be yes. Strange hill to die on. There many great candidates to lead IZA.
@BelotMichele
Michele Belot
10 months
A number of people have reached out because they would like to add their signature to the "IZA letter", even if the letters have been sent. Given the demand, we decided to re-open signatures. If you are a fellow or affiliate, request access and you will receive a link.
1
37
81
1
4
18
@NeumarkEcon
David Neumark
7 months
You can just turn down that TA assignment. But I disagree with the premise. You will learn a ton by TAing grad students. When you have to explain things to others--that's when you really understand the material.
@jadonbuzzard
Jadon J. Buzzard
7 months
If doing well in 1st year econ classes leads to TAing the core, and PhD TA assignments are strictly worse than both UG TA and RA in terms of what the job market values, is doing well in the core a strictly dominated strategy? (Assume student w/ applied interests!)
6
1
22
1
0
18
@NeumarkEcon
David Neumark
1 year
Borjas actually argues for many benefits of immigration, but just argues that a small subset of workers gets hurt.
@VincentGeloso
Vincent Geloso
1 year
Thread: I dont get why people like citing Borjas so much to argue against immigration. Taking Borjas' worst case scenario still makes a case for a liberalization of many aspects immigration policy relative to current conditions #econtwitter
4
14
93
1
3
17
@NeumarkEcon
David Neumark
6 months
JUE special issue on Race, Social Justice, & Cities is finally out! Thanks to authors, and my other co-editors @leah_boustan and Nate Baum-Snow!
0
5
16
@NeumarkEcon
David Neumark
1 year
This seems like investment in human capital and R&D, with an added concern for national security implications. That seems far from protectionist industrial policy.
@Noahpinion
Noah Smith 🐇🇺🇸🇺🇦🇹🇼
1 year
Here are policies that the Hoover Institution recommends to improve the U.S.' long-term competitiveness in the semiconductor industry. Folks, Reaganomics is over. Industrial policy has won. All that's left is to hash out the details of what the new world looks like.
Tweet media one
41
106
762
2
4
16
@NeumarkEcon
David Neumark
1 year
Strongly disagree, and still looking for many examples of results that don't stand up to new methods. I maintain that careful researchers were considering the biases identified in the new literature, albeit in a more ad hoc and less formal way.
0
0
16
@NeumarkEcon
David Neumark
8 months
I don't think these are the criteria. I make RAs co-authors when they contribute intellectually to a project -- going above and beyond simply doing what I instruct them to do.
@EliraKuka
Elira Kuka
8 months
Dunno, I may be the only contrarian on this. Offering co-authorship to RAs will only widen inequalities in the field. People that are doing PHDs at top schools will now have more top-5 (or equvalent papers) even before beginning the tenure track.
8
1
66
3
0
15
@NeumarkEcon
David Neumark
1 year
@ojblanchard1 I trust you didn't turn a deaf ear to that advice.
1
0
14
@NeumarkEcon
David Neumark
1 year
Agreed. Moreover, @jenniferdoleac is a great hire.
@JohnArnoldFndtn
John Arnold
1 year
Implicit in these criticisms is a preposterous notion that if the finding of any one paper is counter to what advocates wish it to be that (1) the finding is wrong (2) the researcher should be disqualified from certain jobs (3) the researcher is biased.
19
52
366
1
3
14
@NeumarkEcon
David Neumark
1 year
A new and extensive survey of studies of the impact of the #minimumwage on many dimensions of health and related behaviors. The Effects of Minimum Wages on (Almost) Everything? A Review of Recent Evidence on Health and Related Behaviors
0
6
15
@NeumarkEcon
David Neumark
2 years
Just a slight correction. "Disemployment effect." Unemployment counts job searchers, so nearly every #minimumwage paper focuses on effects on employment.
@s8mb
Sam Bowman
2 years
Now this is interesting. One of the key results in the modern minimum wage literature may have been overturned - and a significant unemployment effect found after all.
Tweet media one
24
94
510
1
2
14
@NeumarkEcon
David Neumark
10 months
Is there still no word from @iza_bonn or Falk?
@dynarski
Prof Dynarski
10 months
617 of 1700 IZA fellows have signed this letter, including Nobel Prize and Clark Award winners If you are a fellow who loves the network and has not signed, please understand the status quo is not an option if Falk takes over, 1/3 of IZA is gone The network you value is gone
2
35
148
2
1
14
@NeumarkEcon
David Neumark
1 year
Me too! See you there! Very excited about this opportunity to spend time at @HooverInst .
@mattkahn1966
Matthew E. Kahn
1 year
I have been appointed a Visiting Fellow at the @HooverInst for the AY 2023-2024 year. I look forward to seeing more of my friends at Stanford.
6
2
125
0
0
14
@NeumarkEcon
David Neumark
5 months
Do they reveal individual hiring managers' names, or just company names? My understanding is that companies/corporations are not human subjects.
@CFCamerer
Colin Camerer
5 months
Very curious how IRB approved this. Core of IRB is protecting dignity of subjects, privacy, cost/ benefit etc. Obviously there are zillions of correspondence studies (originated in sociology) but those report aggregated data and afaik do not reveal subjects names or employers
Tweet media one
5
2
36
3
0
12
@NeumarkEcon
David Neumark
1 year
I once had a Congressman yell at me for talking about the #minimumwage when I had never worked a min wage job. I replied "my brother-in-law is a highly-qualified cardiologist, even though he's never had a heart attack." (Still don't know how I came back with that one so quickly.)
@AlexNowrasteh
The Alex Nowrasteh
1 year
You haven’t really lived until a member of Congress has yelled at you.
21
16
155
0
0
11
@NeumarkEcon
David Neumark
11 months
I too would like to hear more, including why whoever is making this decision thinks it makes sense and why they think there is nothing to the sexual harassment claims.
@LauraKGee
Laura K Gee
11 months
Why? Why? Why? Why is IZA replacing Simon Jager (who had done great things for IZA) with Armin Falk who has been embroiled in sexual harrassment allegations. This 1 page letter is not giving me the context to understand this! ...
Tweet media one
4
25
179
0
1
11
@NeumarkEcon
David Neumark
5 months
The coffee in Melbourne is insanely good!
@JustinWolfers
Justin Wolfers
5 months
Visiting Melbourne. Just learned what a Magic is. Would recommend. Strongly.
10
1
49
1
1
10
@NeumarkEcon
David Neumark
5 months
What a story/eulogy. Thanks for sharing. I imagine many of us have older (then younger) scholars who helped make us what we are.
@Econ_Marshall
Marshall Steinbaum 🔥
5 months
I'm devastated about the loss of my dear friend, collaborator, and role model in all things, Bernie Weisberger, who died yesterday at 101. Among other things which I'll get to in a moment, there's no way I would have survived the UChicago Econ PhD program without him close by. /1
16
15
294
0
2
9
@NeumarkEcon
David Neumark
6 months
My op-ed on the California fast-food #minimumwage . Editors, not authors, pen the title. In this case I don't think "crazy" is an overstatement. (I expect a study from Michael Reich within weeks showing that fast-food employment skyrocketed.)
5
0
8
@NeumarkEcon
David Neumark
1 year
But to be fair, their papers may have been under review for 8 years...
@KhoaVuUmn
Khoa Vu
1 year
Economists be like "Recent studies have examined this issue" then cite a paper from 1998.
24
27
493
0
0
9
@NeumarkEcon
David Neumark
5 months
I know it's facile to say Hamas can end this war tomorrow by laying down arms, with its leaders going into exile. But is there any question that Palestinians in Gaza wouldn't be better off with Hamas gone, and a technocratic PA government with strong moderate Arab support?
1
0
9
@NeumarkEcon
David Neumark
5 months
Yeah I can't think of anything that happened recently that might trigger disgust with Palestinian leadership and recognition of why there has to be a Jewish state. Ironic (?) that Hamas has made clear the imperative for Zionism.
@PriyamvadaGopal
Priyamvada Gopal ©
5 months
I know someone who went from ardent support of Palestine/self-determination/anticolonialism to Zionist apologist literally overnight. All it took was a promotion to a senior managerial position and a tripled salary. Money & power are serious drugs.
44
434
2K
2
0
9
@NeumarkEcon
David Neumark
2 years
Great thread. Nailed it! #minimumwage
@kingofthecoastt
KingoftheCoast
2 years
I have hyped it up long enough! Here is a thread on Neumark and company’s recent paper, and what it means for the future of minimum wage research.
Tweet media one
8
52
150
0
1
7
@NeumarkEcon
David Neumark
7 months
Do you think the narrowness of the schools on this list suggests missing some outstanding scholars outside the top departments? I think Econ is worse on this dimension than other fields. (And yes, I recognize that on average the best young scholars are at the best places.)
@Econ_4_Everyone
John A. List
7 months
Congrats to the wonderful new @SloanFoundation Research Fellows! I don't know all of them personally but I have learned much from their work. Keep changing the world @zoebcullen Eduardo Davila, @EDerenoncourt Laura Doval, Maryam, Kilian, Ryota Iijima, and @ludwigstraub
Tweet media one
0
2
46
1
0
8
@NeumarkEcon
David Neumark
2 years
Ha! A great paper!
@A_Schwa
Aaron Schwartz
2 years
First question for my students when discussing the work of @jenniferdoleac and @lukestein today: "Who can tell me what they are holding here?"
Tweet media one
11
3
73
0
1
8
@NeumarkEcon
David Neumark
2 years
Woo-hoo! Keep an eye on this guy. Already doing great work.
@DanielFiroozi
Daniel Firoozi
2 years
Starting this fall, I'll be an Assistant Professor of Economics at Claremont McKenna College @CMCnews ! Many thanks to my dad, mom @FirooziForouz , and partner @anthonyberteaux , as well as my advisors: Damon Clark, @NeumarkEcon , and Matt Freedman! #EconJobMarket #EconTwitter
9
6
100
0
0
8
@NeumarkEcon
David Neumark
8 months
I know. That's a coffee stain.
@mattkahn1966
Matthew E. Kahn
8 months
I am at parent's place and found this. How many teens know what this is?
Tweet media one
14
0
38
0
0
7
@NeumarkEcon
David Neumark
6 months
@profsamperry A few things. 1. Too few publications, esp moving beyond the dissertation. 2. Too much co-authorship with senior scholars/former advisors, making it hard to identify individual creativity. 3. Not enough pipeline signaling future productivity. 4. Lack of recognition/impact.
0
0
7
@NeumarkEcon
David Neumark
4 months
Seems a bit contrary to "replication file."
@PhilWMagness
Phil Magness
5 months
Zucman executed this change by sleight of hand. In October 2019 - with no announcement - he deleted the old replication file for his QJE paper from his @UCBerkeley website and replaced it with the new numbers. He only restored the old file after he was caught & heavily criticized
Tweet media one
3
26
252
0
0
7
@NeumarkEcon
David Neumark
1 year
My advisor (Jim Medoff) gave me the same advice in 1984.
@mikekofoed
Michael Kofoed
1 year
I should not write a minimum wage paper. I should not write a minimum wage paper. I should not write a minimum wage paper. I should not write a minimum wage paper. I should not write a minimum wage paper. I should not write a minimum wage paper. I should not write a minimum wage
7
2
57
1
0
7
@NeumarkEcon
David Neumark
6 months
I wouldn't mind paying more for my fast food to get more income to poor families. But... 1. Lots of fast food workers aren't in poor families. 2. Lots of poor families are also going to pay the higher prices (and a much larger share of their income).
2
1
7
@NeumarkEcon
David Neumark
2 years
Hi all. Took a break from Twitter, including deactivating my account, but jumping back on. I really miss following the new research from junior folks on #EconTwitter (and maybe a little gossip). Deactivating did cost me all my followers, so please share and follow!
0
4
7
@NeumarkEcon
David Neumark
1 year
I actually value the feedback from seminars above all else. That's also why I'm not averse to econ seminar culture. I want people to probe for weaknesses because they inevitably think of things I haven't thought of.
@SimonBowmaker
Simon Bowmaker
1 year
"The main reason why you give a seminar is to advertise the work. Originally, I thought the point was to get comments, but I now believe it’s the networking; people get to see the work, they get to understand it, and you get to clarify what they don’t understand." Daron Acemoğlu
2
9
67
0
0
7
@NeumarkEcon
David Neumark
1 year
No fear here: 1. All Too Well. 2. Wildest Dreams. 3. State of Grace. And honorable mention to Never Grow Up, which my daughter and I danced to at her wedding last Sept.
@btshapir
Brad Shapiro
1 year
You wouldn't believe the number (and identities) of the people who have replied to me off-twitter for fear that the public might learn of their love for Taylor Swift and that might hurt their brand.
12
2
61
2
1
7
@NeumarkEcon
David Neumark
2 years
And don't forget this paper overturning another key result in the #minimumwage literature claiming no job loss (indeed strong job gains!): @ATabarrok
@s8mb
Sam Bowman
2 years
Now this is interesting. One of the key results in the modern minimum wage literature may have been overturned - and a significant unemployment effect found after all.
Tweet media one
24
94
510
0
1
7
@NeumarkEcon
David Neumark
5 months
Are you claiming they are agitators from pro-Israel groups, or hard-core antisemitic Islamists? If the former, this is continuing proof that the hard left is as loony and conspiracy-minded as the hard right.
@CoriBush
Cori Bush
5 months
As a Ferguson activist, I know what it’s like to have agitators infiltrate our movement, manipulate the press, & fuel the suppression of dissent by public officials & law enforcement. We must reject these tactics to silence anti-war activists demanding divestment from genocide.
2K
2K
11K
0
2
6
@NeumarkEcon
David Neumark
5 months
Theory doesn't tell us what AI will do. It predicts what AI might do if the world matches the model reasonably well. That's a useful exercise, but let's describe the conclusions more cautiously.
0
0
6
@NeumarkEcon
David Neumark
1 year
As a third cousin of Leon Trotsky, I guess I now have something in common with Prigozhin's family.
@BBCBreaking
BBC Breaking News
1 year
Wagner boss Yevgeny Prigozhin killed in plane crash in Russia, with nine other people on board also dead
3K
10K
18K
0
0
5
@NeumarkEcon
David Neumark
1 year
Congratulations Chloe!
@lhnicholas
Lauren H. Nicholas
1 year
Best start to the weekend celebrating @ChloeNEast tenure! (And @a_velasquezg , not able to celebrate yet), congratulations to both! @CUDenver
Tweet media one
Tweet media two
19
2
111
1
0
5
@NeumarkEcon
David Neumark
6 months
This evidence on MW effects in the hairdressing sector is interesting. Mostly passed through to prices. I think that's a reasonable expectation--likely very inelastic demand (said the bald guy) and little if any scope for input substitution.
1
0
6
@NeumarkEcon
David Neumark
1 year
What is the TA budget?
@uaw_4811
UAW 4811
1 year
UCSD told workers they can only afford 85% of the typical number of TA jobs next year. Meanwhile, the UC Regents voted to give Chancellor Pradeep Khosla a $500,000 raise. @UofCalifornia has the money for our contract. They just lack the will to implement it
3
49
148
0
1
6
@NeumarkEcon
David Neumark
2 years
The fact that one can say anything remotely like this without sparking consequences speaks to the acceptability of ageism compared to other kinds or discriminatory attitudes. #ageism
@nytimes
The New York Times
2 years
A Yale economics professor has some ideas for how to deal with the burdens of Japan’s rapidly aging society. The “only solution,” he said, is mass suicide of the elderly, including ritual disembowelment.
5K
4K
14K
0
2
6
@NeumarkEcon
David Neumark
5 months
There are income effects and substitution effects. Wealth windfalls have income effects only. Higher "incomes" usually means higher wages, which can have substitution effects that reduce fertility.
@GeorgistSteve
Stephen Hoskins 🔰🏗️🧦🪩
5 months
Higher incomes tend to lower fertility rates, which makes it fascinating that windfall gains in housing wealth tend to increase fertility. The injustices of privatized land rents might be quite literally transferring the ability to have kids from the landless to the landed.
4
8
71
1
0
5
@NeumarkEcon
David Neumark
1 year
Agreed
@jmwooldridge
Jeffrey Wooldridge
1 year
Stunning day on MSU’s campus. We U.S. academics find things to complain about — salaries, teaching loads, parking — but we are incredibly privileged to work on college campuses and think for a living.
Tweet media one
7
29
675
0
0
6
@NeumarkEcon
David Neumark
1 year
My cats' yin and yang interpretation.
Tweet media one
0
0
7
@NeumarkEcon
David Neumark
1 year
Mediterranean sunset.
Tweet media one
0
0
7
@NeumarkEcon
David Neumark
5 months
Anyone who doesn't think this is immoral and appalling needs to take a serious look in the mirror.
@canarymission
Canary Mission
5 months
A graduate @Northeastern flashes the "Red Hands" symbol at a commencement ceremony. The image became an iconic symbol of the Second Intifada after Palestinian terrorists held up their bloody hands as the crowd cheered after lynching 2 Israelis who took a wrong turn into Ramallah.
201
716
1K
0
0
6
@NeumarkEcon
David Neumark
1 year
There is only one country in the world for which people make excuses and offer justifications when civilians are slaughtered. I don't know for sure whether that is anti-Semitism, but it sure smells like it.
0
1
6
@NeumarkEcon
David Neumark
1 year
Today's affirmative action decision is not like Roe v Wade in overturning precedent. The court had long expressed reservations about affirmative action, with a nuanced decision in Bakke, and a statement in Grutter that affirmative action should not be needed long term.
0
0
6
@NeumarkEcon
David Neumark
7 months
Does IIA hold?
@KhoaVuUmn
Khoa Vu
7 months
These discrete choice models are getting out of control.
Tweet media one
4
23
371
1
0
5
@NeumarkEcon
David Neumark
1 year
Here's a related early paper by Sara Solnick, one of my first students: (Also wrote a classic gender bargaining paper.)
@annastansbury
Anna Stansbury
1 year
Really interesting new @nberpubs working paper: Among all admits to Wellesley (a women's college), those who enrolled were twice as likely to major in Economics as those who didn't. They attribute much of this effect to gender-related variables: female peers and instructors.
5
26
174
0
1
5
@NeumarkEcon
David Neumark
1 year
Skewed, but not highly. Very hard to predict quality of PhD students on the way in, among a group with so many similarities. Outcomes end up more skewed because of greater opportunities at the top departments, which I think gets interpreted as highly skewed initial talent.
@TrevonDLogan
Dr. Trevon D Logan
1 year
Beneath the stark disparity in academic career outcomes is a sincerely held belief that the distribution of talent among graduate students is highly skewed to top ranked departments. I’m not convinced (top ranked places have just as many mediocre students IMO), but that’s me.
1
12
78
0
0
5
@NeumarkEcon
David Neumark
1 year
Exactly.
@kearney_melissa
Melissa S. Kearney
1 year
Just in case it makes any aspiring economist feel better, my own curiosity led me to take a bunch of undergrad courses in history, sociology, politics, literature, even - gasp - music and the history of art, but not real analysis.
6
15
403
0
0
5
@NeumarkEcon
David Neumark
8 months
@byJoshuaDavis "Context matters" redux.
0
1
3
@NeumarkEcon
David Neumark
8 months
My daughter told me they discussed one of my papers (on living wages) at summer camp. Unusual summer camp, to be sure.
@kearney_melissa
Melissa S. Kearney
8 months
Is there any better feeling as an economist mom than when your kid texts you a photo from his college econ class showing a lecture slide citing one of your papers. 🥰☺️
11
6
471
1
0
4
@NeumarkEcon
David Neumark
4 months
I can't see a reason to honor a strike over political demands. The students, the union, and anyone else are free to express their views. And unions have rights to strike over work-related issues. But this is an improper hijacking of what unions are for.
0
3
5
@NeumarkEcon
David Neumark
7 months
No equilibrium?
@mattkahn1966
Matthew E. Kahn
7 months
True, False, Uncertain. Briefly explain.
Tweet media one
20
3
48
1
0
5
@NeumarkEcon
David Neumark
4 months
I hope something about the @minimumwage too!
@JohnJSSoriano
John J.S. Soriano
4 months
Reading @NeumarkEcon and @arindube taught me a lot of labor econ and lot of econometrics
0
0
12
1
0
5
@NeumarkEcon
David Neumark
1 year
Way to go Daniel!
@ucisocsci
UCI Social Sciences
1 year
Congrats to @DanielFiroozi , @UCIrvine economics Ph.D. #Classof2023 & @ucisocsci Outstanding Scholarship award winner! Daniel is heading to @CMCnews in the fall as an asst prof. Learn more about his award-winning academic pursuits: #zotzotzot #ucipride
Tweet media one
0
5
16
0
0
5
@NeumarkEcon
David Neumark
1 year
Yeah, the problem we all face is that we don't like the edits that were forced on our Econometrica papers. #EconTwitter
@SimonBowmaker
Simon Bowmaker
1 year
Tom Sargent on the refereeing process in economics:
Tweet media one
8
52
267
0
0
4
@NeumarkEcon
David Neumark
1 year
You can learn that in a PhD program. These are so unnecessary.
1
0
5
@NeumarkEcon
David Neumark
7 months
That can be true, which can give us a result like this in some settings. These meta-analysis tools are based on a framework where what varies across studies is just sample size and hence precision. When estimates and precision vary for other reasons, I don't see their validity.
@kingofthecoastt
KingoftheCoast
7 months
@NeumarkEcon So if I could re-phrase: The empirical strategies that are most credible -- in the sense that they are most likely to recover a causal effect -- may also be the more imprecise ones?
0
0
0
2
1
5
@NeumarkEcon
David Neumark
1 year
Don't scream. Do it. Even more important -- study the questions that interest you and you think are important. That's what makes all we go through worth it. If you want to do what others tell you to do, go to the private sector and make more money.
@BarbaraBiasi
Barbara Biasi
1 year
Next time I hear the advice that people should pick big questions with imperfect identification over less important but better identified ones, I am going to scream. This is not the game this profession is playing.
29
49
654
1
0
5
@NeumarkEcon
David Neumark
4 months
And 3: neither group speaks for all Palestinians or all Zionists.
@DinaPomeranz
Dina D. Pomeranz 🟣
4 months
Can we please acknowlege multiple things at the same time? - Yes, there are some explicitly antisemitic slogans among some of the student protests. - And yes, some members of the Israeli government are explicitly calling for occupation and ethnic cleansing of Gaza.
8
17
105
1
2
5
@NeumarkEcon
David Neumark
1 year
There is a good deal of price discrimination allowed in product markets that isn't allowed in labor markets. I don't think we have great rationales for this.
@paulnovosad
Paul Novosad
1 year
Is there a theoretical basis for being comfortable with charging men more for car insurance? It's statistical discrimination, it's clear why firms do this, and it seems fine with me. But do we have a theory for deciding which forms of statistical discrimination we are fine with?
Tweet media one
218
197
2K
1
0
5
@NeumarkEcon
David Neumark
7 months
Here's the argument formally, in relation to public sector workers extracting rents based on local amenities.
@kingofthecoastt
KingoftheCoast
7 months
Areas w high private sector wages have... -Higher tax rates -Average quality public goods -Higher public-sector wage premiums Are governments leveraging their local attractiveness to extracts rents...and generating spatial missallocation in the process?
Tweet media one
1
0
4
0
0
3
@NeumarkEcon
David Neumark
2 years
I tend to think policy can have a lot more influence in reducing inequities than language can. Maybe that's obvious. But with limited bandwidth for news and debate, the focus on language may be costly.
@itaisher
Itai Sher
2 years
This obviously got a lot of pushback. My view is that being overly sensitive to language is a bad trend. People shouldn’t have to be so worried about their precise wording. Some phrases it is better to avoid but it’s better to economize and save that for important cases.
10
4
48
0
0
5
@NeumarkEcon
David Neumark
6 months
Which is interesting for those who think AI is going to kill massive numbers of jobs.
@KwekuOA
Kweku Opoku-Agyemang, Ph.D
6 months
A QJE paper finds the labor market increasingly rewards social skills. Between 1980 and 2013, the jobs requiring high social interaction gre by ~13 percentage points as a share of US labor. Math-intensive less social jobs fell by 3.3 percentage points:
2
23
56
0
1
4
@NeumarkEcon
David Neumark
5 months
I like to hear a senator tell it like it is.
@SenFettermanPA
Senator John Fetterman
5 months
I don't know who needs to hear this, but blocking a bridge or berating folks in Starbucks isn't righteous, it just makes you an asshole. Demand Hamas to send every hostage back home and surrender.
5K
7K
47K
0
1
4
@NeumarkEcon
David Neumark
9 months
We have some new material in the revised version but haven't reposted WP. As usual, in my experience, this makes no real difference.
@libertarianwonk
BuddyTheta
9 months
@NeumarkEcon Do you have plans to add in some of the new diff-in-diff/synthetic control estimators before it gets published? Think it would be a great addition to the discourse using the CZ design
0
0
1
1
0
4
@NeumarkEcon
David Neumark
1 year
Well there are probably at least 20 of them!
@jmwooldridge
Jeffrey Wooldridge
1 year
You think Trump has problems? In a 37 year career, I haven't even given a seminar at every top 10 economics department. 😬
6
4
153
0
0
4
@NeumarkEcon
David Neumark
6 months
I kinda doubt @mckinsey is in the replicable study business.
1
0
4
@NeumarkEcon
David Neumark
5 months
This is quite a document. All should read this, including those in the encampments and those supporting them. That's not to say there is nothing to protest. But it's also clear that the language and actions of some of the protestors is hateful, violent, and racist/antisemitic.
@Daniel_Sugarman
Daniel Sugarman
5 months
More than 250 Jewish students at Columbia have signed this open letter. If you have 5 minutes today, take the time to read it. Because the sentiments it expresses are what the overwhelming majority of Jewish people feel.
Tweet media one
Tweet media two
Tweet media three
Tweet media four
224
2K
7K
0
1
4
@NeumarkEcon
David Neumark
7 months
@florianederer We have not had anyone break such commitments yet. I imagine after the first one does, we will stop making these kinds of offers. Bad externality problem.
2
0
3
@NeumarkEcon
David Neumark
5 months
I asked what you think. I didn't tell you what I thought you think. I fully support an independent Palestine alongside Israel. I'm also 100% sure that for many, "from the river to the sea" means eliminating Israel.
@ChloeNEast
Dr. Chloe N. East (she/her)
5 months
@NeumarkEcon I endorse the cessation of apartheid and ethnic cleansing everywhere. It's very telling that you interpret that as an existential threat to Israel
1
0
1
0
0
4
@NeumarkEcon
David Neumark
10 months
And the removal of Hamas from power is not part of your agenda?
@JamaalBowmanNY
Rep. Jamaal Bowman Ed.D.
10 months
I'm grateful that our continuous calls for a ceasefire and the return of the hostages has begun to make a difference. Soon, we'll see a 4 day ceasefire and the return of 50 hostages. Let's keep fighting until we see an end to all of the violence and bombing and the return of
962
162
1K
0
0
1
@NeumarkEcon
David Neumark
1 year
@IfNotNowOrg This "caged in an open air prison" is hyperbole. Yes there is a blockade. But that's because Hamas is so focused on smuggling weapons. And Gaza is self governing.
0
0
3
@NeumarkEcon
David Neumark
6 months
Yes, I don't see why this is bad practice. And if you see differences you might be prompted to think about which assumptions are more appropriate and why, and maybe even bring indirect evidence to bear. And conversely, why don't we care about robustness to different assumptions?
@eames_taryn
Taryn Eames
6 months
@borusyak But in this case the estimators all tell the same story, indicating that regardless of estimator-specific assumptions, results hold. Is that not a useful result to show, especially if the authors discuss which is their preferred specification?
1
0
10
0
0
4
@NeumarkEcon
David Neumark
7 months
So you think people should make commitments and then break them? Do you also think they should accept offers and then keep searching in the same year? Bad (and unethical) advice in my view.
@florianederer
Florian Ederer
7 months
Personally, I think that's what candidates should do. Or maybe I am still mad that UCLA Anderson didn't let me do that Yahoo Research postdoc year. 🤣
2
0
29
1
0
4
@NeumarkEcon
David Neumark
8 months
@ctaylor463 Must explain the Somali immigrants in Minnesota!
0
0
4
@NeumarkEcon
David Neumark
5 months
That, plus it's not genocide. It's an unfortunate war brought on by Hamas. One could clearly argue Israel could be more cautious and targeted, but the goal obviously isn't to kill civilians.
@yanisvaroufakis
Yanis Varoufakis
5 months
Let's be clear: The Jewish people are NOT committing genocide. Israel is! And, no, Israel does not represent all Jews (no more than every Greek supports Greek state policies). Invoking the Jewish people to defend Israel's genocide is a vile form of antisemitism.
843
4K
15K
0
0
4
@NeumarkEcon
David Neumark
1 year
Jan Brueckner and I explained why the nicest places to live likely have the highest public sector costs -- because workers (and others) can extract rents given the high amenities residents enjoy.
@sfexaminer
SF Examiner
1 year
San Francisco is the worst-run city of the 149 biggest in the U.S., according to a new ranking of their operating efficiencies.
236
330
2K
0
0
4
@NeumarkEcon
David Neumark
1 year
Well those of us who know you like you. The opposite would be worse!
@jenniferdoleac
Jennifer Doleac
1 year
It’s weird how many people I’ve never met really, really hate me. Difficult to take personally, bc they don’t know me, but bizarre & puzzling.
31
1
137
0
0
4
@NeumarkEcon
David Neumark
9 months
Protecting property is pretty important to a well-functioning society.
@ecomarxi
Tiberius
9 months
This is a great time to remind everyone that the police exist primarily to protect wealth, not people
Tweet media one
Tweet media two
475
9K
28K
0
0
4
@NeumarkEcon
David Neumark
9 months
I'm pretty skeptical that many humanities departments are open to inquiry about the right questions or the right answers.
@Mustafa__Gurbuz
Mustafa Gurbuz
9 months
@FareedZakaria Fareed, humanities are not overfunded, they’re systematically underfunded as colleges have turned to $ machines. And the result is this travesty: A good humanities education will teach you asking the right question, which the Congress members shockingly failed in this context 👇
11
15
83
0
1
4
@NeumarkEcon
David Neumark
4 months
Is there a curfew for the noisy helicopters over @UCI ? I know the police like to use their toys, but it's bedtime!
0
0
3