@suzania
Susannah Black Roberts
2 months
This question is so strange to me.
@_nomadic_soul
Meg Wise, empathy-based heretic ☕️
2 months
For the Christians: would you still choose to be a Christian if there was actual proof hell didn’t exist?
1K
49
1K
37
0
245

Replies

@markgaspar
markgaspar
2 months
@suzania I don’t know, saving yourself from the lake of fire was a pretty big selling point in my church community growing up. I think there are a lot of Jonah’s out there who follow Jesus because if they’re in then others aren’t.
1
0
5
@suzania
Susannah Black Roberts
2 months
@markgaspar I just can’t wrap my head around that, intellectually or emotionally
3
0
7
@ztech1001
Via Media⚓
2 months
@suzania Luke 16:19-31, Matt 13: 41-42, Matt 25:41, Mark 9:43, etc. etc. How can I be Christian if I don't believe Christ's own words? I can believe in a form of universalism, or annihilationism, I can accept that Jesus, outside of time, eternally harrows hell- I can't reject hell itself
4
0
4
@suzania
Susannah Black Roberts
2 months
@ztech1001 Oh for sure, I of course believe hell exists on that basis.
0
0
7
@elliearomalady
Ellie
2 months
@suzania Most Christian’s seem to act based on their fears of Hell. “If you don’t believe in God, you go to Hell”
1
0
1
@suzania
Susannah Black Roberts
2 months
@elliearomalady That definitely has not been my experience of most Christians, or my own subjective experience
1
0
7
@Salty87134109
Salty
2 months
@suzania Yes because if hell didn't exist, the Golgotha event still stands as a dividing time in history. It is clear that Christ is a being of pure light that shines thru ages. His equivalent exists in many other religions as well. There is clearly something there.
1
0
0
@suzania
Susannah Black Roberts
2 months
@Salty87134109 What do you mean specifically by a “being of pure light”
1
0
3
@BMcGrewvy
Bethel McGrew, PhD 🇮🇱
2 months
@suzania I will say, one of the saddest and most striking things I ever read was a stubbornly atheist young woman who said she wavers in her atheism when she considers hell, because it feels so just and so satisfying. She was an abuse victim. 😔
1
0
17
@TallBlondeGuy
Brendan Berkley
2 months
@suzania I think it makes sense in the context of the perception that some people just believe in God as “fire insurance”, but…I dunno, that’s probably pretty dated now, yeah? I suspect fire-and-brimstone hasn’t been the norm for awhile
2
0
4
@KeturahAbigail
Keturah Abigail
2 months
@suzania I once argued about the idea of hell with a bunch of young christian girls, and they finally told me, "Well the only reason I'm a Christian is because I know hell is real"
0
0
2
@JosiahHawthorne
Josiah Hawthorne
2 months
@suzania Try it this way: If Christian universal reconciliation was true, would there still be a reason for a person to follow Jesus now? I've heard many Christians say "no" as a specific reason why universal reconciliation couldn't be true.
7
0
25
@ladygreenkirtle
The Lady of the Green Kirtle
2 months
@suzania It's weird because it implies that Christians are doing the whole Christian thing as a chore to stave off a bad outcome, like exercise or housework, rather than "I like this thing so much I want to be a part of it, even if it turns out not to be true" which is more where I am.
1
0
9
@AStratelates
Andrew Stratelates ⚓️(Traditional Anglican Church)
2 months
@suzania Hell questions are always strange.
0
0
2
@danjohnsonhymns
Dr Daniel Johnson
2 months
@suzania Are you a Christian because you don't want to go to hell, or because you love Christ - so often the gospel is just seen as eternal fire insurance, driven by fear, rather than it being a positive thing
0
0
2
@CreekHellfire
Mr. Antichrist
2 months
@suzania Hey Christians: if the Christian god came down and told you that there was no hell, would you still believe in the Christian god?
1
0
0
@MelodyFoster05
Melody Foster
2 months
@suzania I think you can look at it 2 ways. 1. Are you a Christian bc you're afraid of hell? 2. Are you a Christian bc you enjoy the idea of other people going to hell? I've seen a lot of people basically saying yes to 2!
1
0
2