Principal at Neighborhood Workshop. Small-scale Developer. Faculty with the Incremental Development Alliance. Coined the term, ACU - accessory commercial unit.
Density vs tree canopy:
This neighborhood I'm in in Mexico City has so much tree canopy alongside immense density. Can't even hardly see through to the streets from above.
The built results of Portland’s liberalization of single-dwelling zones now allowing up to four units by-right. A little bit of market research demonstrates that these sell for 60-80% less than a new build single-detached in the same neighborhood.
Reminder that NIMBYs vehemently opposed this mixed-use project despite traditional design, high quality materials, and compact walkable form.
Signs with a monster-toothed building were put up. One NIMBY even played guitar at council singing about saving the ‘heart’ of the town.
Years ago, during Portland's single-dwelling zones update, I did financial modeling to demonstrate how increased density will result in better priced housing options.
The results are borne out in today's new construction listings and my analyses proved true.
The math did not lie
Let’s say every window is a unit plus the three single detached and compare unit count in scenarios: 48 vs 31
Housing abundance over pseudo aesthetics.
@SallyAnn_12
Love these so much. Some of us are promoting a revival of these types in residential neighborhoods, calling them ACUs - Accessory Commercial Units:
Sharing this example of a pizza shop ACU (accessory commercial unit).
ACUs are a particularly useful unit type when existing residential structures are found on a well-trafficked corridor.
Allowing these help to retain existing structures by extending the financial viability.
Where else has either eliminated or liberalized their single-family zones? So far, I have:
Minneapolis
South Bend
Buffalo
Raleigh
Durham
Portland
St. Paul
Albuquerque
Tacoma
Atlanta
Sacramento
#YIMBY
#apartmentbans
#zoning
I walked an urban half marathon today and saw some nice ACUs (accessory commercial units), or front yard businesses. One was a vegan restaurant, the other pizza, and one a boutique shop.
The small house in disrepair is not an affordable housing strategy because as soon as it hits the market it is already unaffordable due to the value of the underlying land. I ran development proformas exploring other options.
#missingmiddlehousing
#yimby
Holy smokes! Look at this ACU (accessory commercial unit) recently shared with me.
And don't think I'm not proposing these in every town I work with. Expect to see these start to popup as towns and cities work to enable small-scale.
#acu
#smallscale
#incrementaldevelopment
How much do current zoning standards contribute to inflated rents? This example suggests two changes to the standards resulting in a discount to rents by 25% while making the same return rates.
Also, infeasible —> feasible
#missingmiddlehousing
#buildsmalllivelarge
#smallscale
I find the ‘preference’ for single-family homes angle questionable, if not dubious. Particularly when we haven’t been legally allowed to build much of anything else since 1959.
In a 10-acre section of the neighborhood, a local small-scale developer is infilling with
#middlehousing
resulting in a 2334% increase in municipal revenue.
The first two buildings in what will be only South Bend's second cottage court are now under construction on Harrison Avenue. Made up of a group of small detached homes arranged around a shared courtyard visible from the street, a cottage court was last built here a century ago.
1-4 units is considered a house by the FHA, VA, Fannie Mae, & Freddie Mac - can be purchased with a standard 30-yr mortgage. Our zoning should reflect this and allow a 4plex on residential lots, otherwise our banks will be more committed to housing choice than our zoning code.
This Portland building was vehemently opposed by NIMBYs. The developer reduced the height to appease the resistance. The building also includes affordable units. No concessions were good enough.
NIMBYism IS NOT ABOUT DESIGN OR SCALE OR AFFORDABILITY
Want to support local small business? Allow inexpensive commercial space to be built in front of houses on a primary corridor.
Every neighborhood should have a walkable donut shop in an accessory commercial unit (ACU).
Portland’s recently updated and more flexible zoning has demonstrated results with rent growth rate falling from 7% to 2% saving renters thousands of dollars.
A neighborhood coffee shop could fit in the front yard space of a residential building. I’ve been calling these, ACUs or, Accessory Commercial Units.
#smallscale
#acu
Tomorrow is the big day! Portland commissioners are projected to adopt some of the most progressive single-family zoning reform in the country.
I am proud for my part in financially modeling the "deeper affordability" to prove it as a viable option.
@nbrhoodwrkshop
@HutchinsMatt
It’s true. I have one of those FHA loans that allows 1-4 units and up to 49% commercial all with a conventional single family mortgage.
I made some maps demonstrating the proliferation of Portland's exclusionary single-family zoning over time (1927-2018). Ideally, we crack these zones open to offer more
#missingmiddle
housing choice.
#YIMBY
@Macarr7
@tristonezidore
@CITYOFCARMELIN
It’s ok if a single street design does not solve all social ills in one fell swoop. I think we often put too so much pressure on a single project that our expectations become unrealistic.
Thrilled to have played a part in making the case for affordable 6-plexes in our single-family zones. This amendment aligns policy with desired development outcomes.
#missingmiddle
#infill
#affordability
Residential Infill Project update thread.
Tomorrow City Council will discuss potential amendments, including the Deeper Affordability Bonus we've been championing. That would allow sixplexes, if half of the units are affordable at 60% MFI for rentals or 80% MFI for ownership.
@Jadentheman1
You should look up sun angles. Lots of shade created by moving the buildings closer because they don’t have to be separated by parking lots.
I am testifying this morning to the New Hampshire State Legislature in support of House Bill 341, ‘the 4-plex is a house’ bill.
This Bill would allow up to four units to be built in all single-dwelling zones statewide.
#livabledensity
┏━━┓┏━━┓┏━━┓┏━━┓
┗━┓┃┃┏┓┃┗━┓┃┃┏┓┃
┏━┛┃┃┃┃┃┏━┛┃┃┃┃┃
make h o u s i n g l e g a l
┃┏━┛┃┃┃┃┃┏━┛┃┃┃┃
┃┗━┓┃┗┛┃┃┗━┓┃┗┛┃
┗━━┛┗━━┛┗━━┛┗━━┛
#HousingForAll
#LegalizeIt
There's a dearth of small scale retail space available in most N.A. cities.
Humans are wired to like cozy, fine-grained urbanism, like these cafes in Japan. It feels good, AND it makes financial sense. Many small business, can't afford super sized retail bays.
More of this >
I really wish this was permitted on every corner lot in Seattle. Imagine these in your neighborhood. A small shop, 4-plex, built in 1 year (courtesy of
@carywesterbeck
)
Hey, my most recent zoning reform project is getting some press:
“St. Paul's recent legalization of up to four units per lot city-wide showcases a smarter, more thoughtful future for zoning reform.”
@The_Outs1ders
Correct, no parking provided for residents but there is a visitor parking area. Seems like a brave concept considering the location but maybe this is exactly what this metro area needs to see.
@mnolangray
South Bend, Indiana - their focus and support of local, small-scale developers is going to be a huge game changing example for the way cities should be doing things.
So exciting to see what started with a site plan that I was coloring as the master planner is now built and even having people move into their new affordable houses.
I researched the vernacular architecture of the area and matched unit types to lot types.
Today, I would have been part of a small developer talk at
@YIMBYtown
.
Thank you to
@Sightline
for your support and the hard work of
@MadelineKovacs
and
@ambrown
for putting together what would have been the top convening of urban-policy-minded folks from around the country.
I've just wrapped up a project in Houston running pro formas and funding strategies for various NOAH redevelopment scenarios, but the built environment is unlike anything I've ever seen. The whole area is carpeted with low-rise garden apartments as far as the eye can see. Wild!
Auxiliary Commercial Unit (ACU): This is a classic ACU office, built in front of a home in Portland. Over time, it could be retail, a restaurant, or a bar as well.
Reminder that NIMBYs also vehemently opposed this highly traditional and contextual building. It wasn’t that they were against affordable housing, it just “wasn’t the right spot”.
Reminder that NIMBYs vehemently opposed this mixed-use project despite traditional design, high quality materials, and compact walkable form.
Signs with a monster-toothed building were put up. One NIMBY even played guitar at council singing about saving the ‘heart’ of the town.
@BeezyManzell
Ohhh, you are looking at the 2-story 6-plex in the diagram and using the 2,100sqft from the house at the top? The actual unit square feet modeled for the affordable 6-plex was 1,028 and the overall building height was three stories. I include an image for reference.