Lehner v Lant Street Management Company Ltd (BUILDING SAFETY - LEASEHOLDER PROTECTION - qualifying lease - contribution condition) [2024] UKUT 135 (LC) (17 May 2024)

Leasehold and Freehold Reform Bill - a lot to unpick here, but from what I can tell (at a cursory glance), re: price / premium - MV to be abolished, assumption when valuing term that GR capped at 0.1% of pty value and cap rates to be prescribed by Regs

Well, I wasn’t expecting that! Congratulations to everyone in our Prop Man, Prop Lit and Resi Leasehold teams. A real team effort.

… also a new form of landlord certificate; amendments to Regs 3-5 of The Building Safety (Leaseholder Protections) (Information etc.) (England) Regulations 2022 (including right for landlord to apply for 30 day extension); and RTM Co’s & RMCs can apply for RCOs. (2 of 2)

The Building Safety (Leaseholder Protections etc.) (England) (Amendment) Regulations 2023 are now in force. Copies of landlord certs & leaseholder deeds of cert must be given to RTM Co’s, RMCs & other landlords within one week or very serious consequences follow! … (1 of 2)

Delighted to be involved in my first case in the Supreme Court with Emma Bush, @justinbates28 and Harley Ronan. Is Elim Court correctly decided and what approach should be taken to defects in statutory notices?

Avon v Canary Gateway - Court of Appeal affirms Upper Tribunal decision and earlier case law - shared ownership leaseholders who have not staircased to 100% are qualifying tenants (unless excluded) if the lease has a term exceeding 21 years. No link yet!

Assethold v Eveline Road RTM Co - where premises capable of being divided into smaller sets of premises, lessees not obliged to set up multiple RTM Cos & issue multiple claims in respect of each smallest set of premises (Craftrule applied)

Baron Estate Management v Wick Hall RTM Co - no new law, but a useful reminder that failing to serve a notice of invitation to participate on every person who is not or has not agreed to become a member of RTM Co is fatal to claim

Avon Ground Rents v Ward - Para.5A and s20C orders awarded (preventing L from recovering costs under 69 Marina clause or as a service charge) despite L succeeding in its s.168 app, because right of forfeit had been waived

Aneesh v Hinchlifee - collective enfranchisement - L not entitled to compensation for diminution in value of pty owned by another company associated with L - DNH v Tower Hamlets (where piercing corporate veil was allowed) distinguished

Charles Hunt (Holdings) Ltd v 77-82 Bridle Close Freehold Ltd - collective enfranchisement - no value in prospect of deeds of variation to permit subletting and minimal roof development value

Reekie v Oakwood Court RA - Man Co not obliged to exercise discretionary power to apportion service charges amongst leaseholders who “have the use of” certain services

Another day, another article about leasehold reform in the national press. The Law Commission made a number of detailed proposals in their papers on enfranchisement, the right to manage and commonhold, which the government have yet to formerly respond to

And after all the excitement of Fearn v Tate, we have another blockbuster SC decision - Williams v Aviva - Windermere, Gater & Oliver all overturned - “fair and reasonable” service charges and contractual powers to vary service charge proportions are valid

Well, that was a rather important decision … Fearn v Tate - Supreme Court holds (3-2) that visual intrusion into flats by Tate viewing platform constitutes a nuisance, overturning first instance decision and Court of Appeal

remediation contribution order FTT decision. This might be the first one. Short 🧵1/5 https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/63c57179e90e074ef04efe0a/20230113_Decision___Order_Combined.pdf

Lambeth v Kelly - despite wholesale failure to comply with s.20 consultation requirements unconditional dispensation granted due to insufficient evidence of relevant prejudice