Robert Colvile
@rcolvile
Followers
62K
Following
71K
Media
7K
Statuses
95K
Director of @CPSThinkTank, EIC of @CapX, Sunday columnist for @thetimes, author of 'The Great Acceleration'. Politics, policy and parenting.
London
Joined December 2008
Last week, the price of natural gas dipped below 72p/therm. It was a significant moment. Why? Because according to Ed Miliband's maths, it's impossible. (1/?)
10
55
267
Both these charts are true! And in both cases, the solution is to approve vastly more homes in urban areas. Building more will bring down private rents, and allow people to move to the permanent accommodation they need to rebuild their lives. And it will save the state millions
0
4
39
This is done according to Treasury rules, so it's not NESO's fault, but they seem like dumb rules if you're trying to compare the cost of different energy pathways, which this exercise is.
1
1
27
Want to invest in the next big AI stocks? IBD can show you how.
14
31
190
PPS In the column, I also mention an issue with the new NESO report that a colleague spotted. They've used better gas prices, but the carbon cost for comparing the different pathways is the 'social cost', not the actual traded price, which is about 6x higher.
2
1
25
PS Obviously 72p/therm was a projected average over the decade, not a hard boundary. But the numbers really aren't looking good. Here are all the contemporaneous projections we could find...
2
3
26
And as the recent news on EVs shows, it's far from the only way in which his plans are running into trouble. Plenty more in my column - please give it a read https://t.co/FCrbNQVMcg
3
4
40
Atlas: “More information—that was the original promise of the Internet. To my horror, it became a tool for censorship. Once everyone was on social media, it became a way to manipulate people and censor things they didn’t want out there.”
52
685
3K
In short, Ed's numbers add up only if gas prices stay at a historic high, for a decade. Instead, they're already below the lowest level his report said they could go - leaving him and us billions of pounds in the hole.
2
8
34
In fact, Miliband's own department was predicting a price range of 42p-114p. The International Energy Agency forecast an ‘LNG glut’, cutting gas prices by a half or two thirds by 2030.
1
3
24
As @CPSThinkTank showed here, they did it by taking respectable independent forecasts of the market price - *and then turning the worst-case scenario (101p/therm) into the new central forecast*. Because global uncertainty, or something.
cps.org.uk
Ed Miliband hailed a recent report from the National Energy System Operator (NESO) as vindicating his plan to decarbonise the grid by 2030. But new analysis shows that the NESO report is built around...
3
1
34
If you dig into it, the NESO report assumes a gas price over the decade of between 72p/therm (sound familiar?) and 290p, with a central estimate of 101p. This is pretty punchy , given the non-Ukraine range of 15-80p. So how did they get to it?
1
3
29
Ottawa and Alberta sign an MOU for a pipeline through BC, but opposition could stop it. What does this mean for Canada's economy? You'll want to hear this episode.
0
7
48
The NESO report actually said Ed's plan would be *no more expensive* than the counterfactual of sticking with gas. But to get to that verdict, it had to make a series of fairly eye-popping assumptions - especially about the gas price.
1
2
36
When Ed came to power, he commissioned NESO to show that his plans would save money. He claimed the resulting report proved it. It didn't.
1
5
43
Last week, the price of natural gas dipped below 72p/therm. It was a significant moment. Why? Because according to Ed Miliband's maths, it's impossible. (1/?)
10
55
267
The Cline CLI lets you run tasks headlessly from the terminal and integrate Cline anywhere. You can use him to power GitHub Actions, Discord bots, video game characters, and Linear tickets.
6
5
76
Is Washington about to demolish the UK's Online Safety Act? The GRANITE Act would make foreign censorship of Americans legally radioactive – ignore it, and you face ‘thermonuclear’ damages of up to $75m per threat. Watch @prestonjbyrne now on The Capitalist.
0
14
41
Fun fact about this film: the energy used to make it was generated entirely by George Orwell's body spinning in his grave
First trailer for Andy Serkis’ animated adaptation of ‘ANIMAL FARM’ Starring Seth Rogen, Gaten Matarazzo, Steve Buscemi, Glenn Close, Laverne Cox, Kieran Culkin, Woody Harrelson, Jim Parsons, Kathleen Turner and Iman Vellani. In theaters on May 1, 2026
45
1K
13K
Last quarter I rolled out Microsoft Copilot to 4,000 employees. $30 per seat per month. $1.4 million annually. I called it "digital transformation." The board loved that phrase. They approved it in eleven minutes. No one asked what it would actually do. Including me. I
5K
24K
161K
Two top programs. One unforgettable night. Arkansas & Houston bring big time college basketball to the Garden State at Prudential Center on Saturday, December 20 for the 2025 Never Forget Tribute Classic! Buy your tickets today.
1
1
17
This is a bombshell, but it's also an infuriating example of burying the point. It's not until 4,400 words into a 9,000-word piece that we are told that the key stories in one of the most famous science nonfiction books of the 20th century are made up!
Bombshell: Oliver Sacks (a humane man & a fine essayist) made up many of the details in his famous case studies, deluding neuroscientists, psychologists, & general readers for decades. The man who mistook his wife for a hat? The autistic twins who generated multi-digit prime
87
481
5K
Ninety-one years old, and those bloody elites still cut him down.
1
0
6