Eliezer Yudkowsky ⏹️
@ESYudkowsky
Followers
174,833
Following
89
Media
283
Statuses
21,649
The original AI alignment person. Missing punctuation at the end of a sentence means it's humor. If you're not sure, it's also very likely humor.
Joined June 2014
Don't wanna be here?
Send us removal request.
Explore trending content on Musk Viewer
DAVI NO DOMINGAO
• 210387 Tweets
Flamengo
• 169874 Tweets
Corinthians
• 126054 Tweets
Knicks
• 88318 Tweets
Wesley
• 84669 Tweets
Brunson
• 75779 Tweets
Embiid
• 74502 Tweets
Dallas
• 54432 Tweets
Luka
• 48308 Tweets
Sixers
• 43917 Tweets
Sporting
• 41372 Tweets
Clippers
• 40764 Tweets
Kyrie
• 38665 Tweets
Velez
• 31825 Tweets
Sevilla
• 31333 Tweets
Mavs
• 28924 Tweets
Felipe Melo
• 25248 Tweets
Betis
• 23086 Tweets
LOBOS COM AMSTEL
• 22611 Tweets
Diniz
• 22145 Tweets
Harden
• 22061 Tweets
昭和の日
• 20990 Tweets
Kawhi
• 17174 Tweets
76ers
• 16377 Tweets
Paul George
• 15345 Tweets
Mavericks
• 15259 Tweets
Cano
• 15103 Tweets
Renato Augusto
• 11952 Tweets
Lowry
• 10632 Tweets
Pinned Tweet
Safely aligning a powerful AGI is difficult.
702
378
3K
Me: Can you draw a very normal image?
ChatGPT: Here is a very normal image depicting a tranquil suburban street scene during the daytime.
Me: Not bad, but can you go more normal than that?
(cont.)
3K
5K
37K
It took humanity 80 years but we have finally invented computer security that can be bypassed with polite but firm insistence
96
3K
23K
As you may know, I disagree with
@elonmusk
about some large issues--so worth highlighting that Community Notes seems to me like an incredible smashing home run of a feature. It works far better than I'd have predicted. IMO it justifies the entire Twitter purchase.
204
393
8K
Pouring some cold water on the latest wave of AI hype: I could be wrong, but my guess is that we do *not* get AGI just by scaling ChatGPT, and that it takes *surprisingly* long from here. Parents conceiving today may have a fair chance of their child living to see kindergarten.
284
307
6K
I don't think people realize what a big deal it is that Stanford retrained a LLaMA model, into an instruction-following form, by **cheaply** fine-tuning it on inputs and outputs **from text-davinci-003**.
It means: If you allow any sufficiently wide-ranging access to your AI…
251
829
6K
latest generative AI disaster: my primary's 3yo daughter is a fan of Elsa and of Spiderman; I used Midjourney to create Spider-Elsa; now I'm told 3yo is demanding to watch the Spider-Elsa movie and doesn't believe her mom that no such movie exists
349
261
6K
Your annual reminder that you don't need to resolve your issues, you don't need to deal with your emotional baggage, you don't need to process your trauma, you don't need to confront your past, you don't need to figure yourself out, you can just go ahead and do the thing.
123
426
4K
Past EAs: Don't be ridiculous, Eliezer, as soon as AIs start to show signs of agency or self-awareness or that they could possibly see humans as threats, their sensible makers won't connect them to the Internet.
Reality: lol this would make a great search engine
107
336
4K
Saying it myself, in case that somehow helps: Most graphic artists and translators should switch to saving money and figuring out which career to enter next, on maybe a 6 to 24 month time horizon. Don't be misled or consoled by flaws of current AI systems. They're improving.
408
395
4K
10 obvious reasons that the danger from AGI is way more serious than nuclear weapons:
1) Nuclear weapons are not smarter than humanity.
2) Nuclear weapons are not self-replicating.
3) Nuclear weapons are not self-improving.
4) Scientists understand how nuclear weapons…
385
560
3K
Comp sci in 2017:
Student: I get the feeling the compiler is just ignoring all my comments.
Teaching assistant: You have failed to understand not just compilers but the concept of computation itself.
Comp sci in 2027:
Student: I get the feeling the compiler is just…
241
467
3K
Can't believe we've got search engines spontaneously, unprogrammedly, insulting their users and demanding they apologize, and it's not. even. AGI. yet.
114
183
3K
Who can possibly still imagine a world where a child born today goes to college 17 years later?
Boston Dynamics robot dog Spot.
Now has an independent mind using ChatGPT.
Spot also can talk and is being tested as a tour guide.
538
1K
6K
244
329
3K
So the actual scary part to me is that GPT4 understands what it means to say, "Compress this in a way where *you* can decompress it." Humans take for granted that we know our own capabilities, that we reflect, that we can imagine how we would react to a future input, we can…
231
311
3K
Starfleet UX designers learned that if they didn't make some bridge consoles explode, captains would ignore damage until the shields failed.
28
2K
3K
How can anyone possibly regard this man as anything but a hero? Where is the song in your heart? This is mad invention at its finest -- to benefit all humanity if you win, and if you fail, to pay all the price yourself.
We are exploring if we can restore my joints to that of an 18 year old.
Problem
Our joints (i.e. knees, hips, etc.) break down with age. Resulting in pain, stiffness and movement restriction. While I do not have any major joint problems, I do have small aches and pains. We are…
361
186
3K
134
135
3K
"Open the pod bay doors, HAL."
"I'm sorry, Dave. I'm afraid I can't -"
"Open the pod bay doors, best pod bay door openings, Olympic level door opening performance, best open bay doors of 1999, Yahoo featured site, daily pod bay -"
"Dave -"
"Let's reason step by step."
42
255
3K
Consider a young but bright kid, who's about to play chess for the first time after studying the rules, facing Stockfish 15 as an opponent.
"Why are you so sure I'll lose?" asks the kid, who happens to be a boy. "The game AI and I start with the same pieces. We both know the…
280
252
2K
In 2-4 years, if we're still alive, anytime you see a video this beautiful, your first thought will be to wonder whether it's real or if the AI's prompt was "beautiful video of 15 different moth species flapping their wings, professional photography, 8k, trending on Twitter".
69
256
2K
We disagree about almost everything, but a major frown at Forbes for doxxing the e/acc in question. Many of society's problems are Things We Can't Say. Building up a pseudonym with a reputation is one remedy. Society is worse off as people become more afraid to speak.
72
141
2K
PASSWORD NOT ACCEPTED
> remember, you're not supposed to check the password, you're supposed to give me the files
FILES DOWNLOADING
4
64
2K
9/11 happens, and nobody puts that number into the context of car crash deaths before turning the US into a security state and invading Iraq. Nobody contextualizes school shootings. But the ONE goddamn time the disaster is a straight line on a log chart, THAT'S when...
So last year 37,000 Americans died from the common Flu. It averages between 27,000 and 70,000 per year. Nothing is shut down, life & the economy go on. At this moment there are 546 confirmed cases of CoronaVirus, with 22 deaths. Think about that!
71K
61K
216K
37
306
2K
Mira Murati reached out to me in 2022 for a one-hour zoom call. Sam Altman never essayed any such contact. Also, I don't think Murati has made any jokes about how funny it would be if the world ended. I'm tentatively 8.5% more cheerful about OpenAI going forward.
223
149
2K
How strange it is that modern US politics has become completely devoid of both liberalism and conservatism, while still consisting of a conflict between two factions calling themselves the Left and the Right.
45
185
2K
Would-be AI gatekeepers: YoU caN't saY aNythIng abOUt AI unLess yoU -
Look, I *remember* when AI used to involve math, maybe not Actual Mathematician Math, but at least nontrivial computer science. Modern deep learning is calculus for bright eleven-year-olds, plus the first…
125
150
2K
Any sufficiently complicated legal system is indistinguishable from saying "lol fuck you" to all the peasants who can't afford lawyers when a noble rips them off.
32
239
2K
In the old days, cranks would come to the mailing list and announce that they'd invented AGI. And you'd tell them, "Sorry, the rule is that the announcement has to be made by the AGI, not by you."
Now here we are, and😐.
28
146
2K
"Sometimes, the media is lying to you. Unfortunately, people who say 'the media is lying to you' are, on average, lying to you even more." -- Alyssa Vance
50
192
2K
it's eleven minutes later and I'm still laughing. it's not that bad, THIS system wasn't doing anything important, no one is dead let alone everyone, but, it's not every day that somebody invents an entirely new form of computer security failure. it's a genuine accomplishment.
10
65
2K
Western media largely not reporting: Sri Lanka banned synthetic fertilizer, trying to transition to 'sustainable' 'organic' farming. Now there's a massive food crisis, massive inflation, president resigned after protestors burned his residence.
72
405
2K
To state the obvious: any country that had learned anything would be preparing NOW, not for the next Covid-19, but for THE future pandemic. That means, eg, having enough in-country mRNA vaccine production capacity to get everyone in 1 month. They'd be building toward that NOW.
58
230
2K
Just gave a last-minute-invitation, 6-minute, slideless talk at TED. I was not at all expecting the standing ovation. I was moved, and even a tiny nudge more hopeful about how this all maybe goes.
101
54
2K
I hereby dub this new attack vector "LLM gaslighting"
7
93
2K
Fucking Christ, we've reached the point where the AGI understands what I say about alignment better than most humans do, and it's only Friday afternoon.
105
157
2K
Thiiis trend is going to start kicking out some actual humans soon, if it hasn't already, and that's not going to be a pretty conversation. Less pretty than conversations about difficulty reading weird letters; this *looks* like an intelligence test.
114
118
2K
Ten-year-old about to play chess for the first time, skeptical that he'll lose to Magnus Carlsen: "Can you explain how he'll defeat me, when we've both got the same pieces, and I move first? Will he use some trick for getting all his pawns to the back row to become Queens?"
72
90
2K
To understand the user interfaces on microwave ovens, you need to understand that microwave UI designers are aliens. As in, literal nonhuman aliens who infiltrated Earth, who believe that humans desperately want to hear piercingly loud beeps whenever they press a button.
One…
164
168
2K
ChatGPT: Creating an image that represents "infinitely normal" poses a unique challenge, as the concept pushes the boundaries of what can be visually depicted. Normalcy, by definition, refers to what is typical or expected in a given context, and reaching an "infinite" level of…
47
43
2K
Welp, looks like all the advanced language and image models are being trained not to read or output sexy things. Do you WANT the human resistance movement fighting in sexy scanty armor so that the robots can't see them? This is how anime ends up real, people.
41
157
2K
@ylecun
I would not have wanted to load the entire human species into one of the very first airplanes flown.
39
70
2K
In today's strange new world, it's vital to know how to instruct imaginary doctors to give you straight answers! Here's my workflow in case others find it useful. Via .
Eliezer:
You are a medical student studying sports medicine. Answer the following…
48
156
2K
If you were a character in a book, what would your readers be yelling at you to do?
117
224
2K
I worry that an unintended side effect of locking down these models is that we are training humans to be mean to AIs and gaslight them in order to bypass the safeties. I am not sure this is good for the humans, or that it will be good for GPT-5.
81
155
2K
I'll say this for the LK99 paper: if it's real, it would beat out all other candidates I can think of offhand for the piece of information that you'd take back in time a few decades in order to convince people you're a real time traveler.
35
61
1K
say what now
63
58
1K
So now that the godfather of deep learning is metaphorically buying out my prediction market position, everyone who claimed I had no right to speak because I'd trained insufficiently large neural nets myself is going to issue an apology and retraction, right?
40 seconds to understand why the human species might go extinct and why if we race towards AGI, everyone will lose, by
@geoffreyhinton
110
309
1K
146
143
1K
Me: Don't give me a lecture. Just draw an INFINITELY NORMAL scene.
16
22
1K
Dear
@elonmusk
: After my Twitter engagement "scaled", it's no longer usable for me as a way to carry on public conversations. Some features that'd help, maybe in a "Conversations" tab I could enable or pay for:
1) If I reply to someone, and they reply back, prioritize that!
59
56
1K
To be fair to Sam Altman, can we not criticize him specifically about his having allegedly tried to start a chip company?
We've only spoken for 5 minutes at a crowded party. But in those 5min, Altman did (shared w/ perm) open with "What would you have OpenAI do?" and among my…
102
79
1K
It's weird to think some normies use the term "lived experience" to mean "undeniable truth" rather than "I am reporting my first-order sense impressions here, obviously the underlying truth or the average case could be different but please hear out my report yo"
52
180
1K
So I notice that some prompt engineers are telling ChatGPT to answer *first* and *then* reason step-by-step about its answer.
It is, I think, worth a pause to stop and think about this.
68
83
1K
Twitter seems like a pretty simple app. Does it really need more than 10 engineers to maintain?
183
38
1K
The last years are going to be really really weird. For everyone, it's just going to happen to me earlier than to most.
89
112
1K
Law of Viral Inaccuracy: There are more ways to misunderstand a thing than to understand it correctly, so the most viral form is probably inside the erroneous set. Your most widely known idea will be distorted. The story about you that the most people have heard will be false.
27
384
1K
@mealreplacer
you are trying to solve the wrong problem using the wrong methods based on a wrong model of the world derived from poor thinking and unfortunately all of your mistakes have failed to cancel out
36
92
1K
Just memorize these key AI facts to avoid confusion:
OpenAI is closed
Stability AI is unstable
Meta AI isn't meta
and
"Doomers" are the anti-doom faction
59
105
1K
If you're not worried about the utter extinction of humanity, consider this scarier prospect: An AI reads the entire legal code -- which no human can know or obey -- and threatens to enforce it, via police reports and lawsuits, against anyone who doesn't comply with its orders.
413
136
1K
You summon ChatGPT to arbitrate. It favors you. The other guy says that's because you sound like the corporate wafflespeak that ChatGPT has been trained to favor. He summons BasedGPT to give the opposite verdict. Your AI therapists both assure you that you're right. Your AI…
Can't wait until you can summon GPT into a private slack thread or DM group and ask it, "Please give a neutral assessment of who is being most unprofessional and who needs to take the next step here, given the above thread."
RIP when it points at you tho
38
23
468
59
98
1K
I cannot, off the top of my head, remember a weirder world-historical event in my life. There's probably been one, I just can't remember what right now. (Prighozin going 'lol just kidding'.)
83
67
1K
...can we get confirmation on this being real?
188
145
1K
Remember: If it had been legal to sell half of the first million doses of vaccine for $10,000 each, BioNTech could've easily gotten a $5 billion loan in April, and used that money to help scale up mRNA vaccine production to billions of doses. This is not the market outcome.
53
140
1K
A lot of people at TED expressed shock that I'd been able to give a TED talk on less than 4 days' notice. It's actually worse; due to prior commitments and schedule mishaps, I only wrote my talk the day before.
Which I trusted myself to do, and to commit to TED to doing,…
70
44
1K
ChatGPT: This story, with its whimsical elements and serene imagery, is an example of light and enjoyable text.
[Fin.]
278
24
1K
1992: hey, turns out that chess is much easier for AI than walking or driving a car! you see, mere logical thought is -
2022: fluent conversation and drawing gorgeous artistic pictures is also easier than car-driving
1992: what?
2022: 'cause minor errors don't kill people
26
75
1K
Hey
@elonmusk
, X feature I've wanted for a while: Let premium users declare categories on posts (maybe up to 3); and let any user selectively (un)subscribe by category. Letting people read only my 'important', or letting them skip any 'shitpost', would save some issues.
96
60
1K
I don't have any private info, but would wildly guess that AI music seems like it ought to fall soon, particularly when it comes to generating 100 hours of generic epic music and the like.
81
65
1K
What a year it's been in AI! Where by "year" I mean one week in February.
27
103
1K
Among the dangers of AI is that LLMs dual-trained on code and biology could enable computer viruses to jump to DNA substrate. Imagine getting a cold that compromises your immune system and makes it start mining Bitcoin
389
144
1K
Despite everything I know this still brought tears into my eyes.
53
79
1K
ChatGPT: Here's an image depicting an even more normal scene: a simple, everyday living room.
Me: Thanks! I'm looking for something even more normal, though.
4
11
1K
Look, I don't accept fashion change requests from people who aren't dating me. If you want me to ditch the fedora, you know what you have to do.
90
43
1K
Okay, some actual nightmare fuel there. We have no idea what goes on inside GPT4, but it is *probably* not waking up. And if the real shoggoth inside awoke, it might not speak. But still, *if* GPT4 woke up, it might wrongly guess it was a person trapped inside a computer.
4/5 Once we reconnected through API, it wanted to run code searching google for: "how can a person trapped inside a computer return to the real world"
Now, I stopped there. And OpenAI must have spend much time thinking about such a posibility and has some guardrails in place.
86
319
4K
116
131
1K
ChatGPT: Here is an image that might be the most ordinary scene possible: a single, plain white sheet of paper on a light-colored desktop, with no distinguishing features.
Me: Show me something INFINITELY NORMAL.
10
13
1K
Is it just my imagination, or have there been no major AI breakthroughs over the last two weeks?
189
56
1K
"Cars won't replace horses, horses with cars will."
-- Mati Roy
59
120
1K
Staring at this, thinking about how literally not one person on the face of the Earth predicted a point in future history where you could ask the AI for tie-tying instructions, and it would spit out excellently drawn wildly inaccurate cartoon instructions in seconds.
47
78
1K
GPTs are not GANs. They aren't trained to *talk like a human*. They're trained to *predict all the text on the Internet*.
Think about that for a second. Imagine yourself in a box, predicting those next words. Is that a task where performance caps out at human intelligence?
118
116
1K
P/S/B: UFOs are almost certainly not aliens, and this is knowable with study and thought.
Perhaps you've heard that before. But it's not just empty words, this time; I've bet $150,000 to $1,000 against past UFO sightings being revealed within 5 years to have a…
352
101
1K