NO MORE PLAYING GAMES: Breakthrough analysis reveals repetitive head impacts are a DEFINITIVE CAUSE of
#CTE
.
Sports industry must acknowledge cause-and-effect & get to work protecting their athletes, especially children.
Release, study & a thread:
If Tua takes the field tonight, it's a massive step back for
#concussion
care in the NFL.
If he has a 2nd concussion that destroys his season or career, everyone involved will be sued & should lose their jobs, coaches included. We all saw it, even they must know this isn't right
This is so sad. Note the fencing posture with the first brain injury. He may never be the same.
@danawhite
&
@TBSNetwork
should be ashamed. Pure exploitation. What's next, "Who can survive a stabbing"?
Gronk's cheap shot gave Tre'Davious White a
#concussion
. If he's not suspended, it signals cheap shots are fair game now in NFL. Had it been Tom Brady's knee, player would be banned for life. Just because you can't see his injured brain doesn't mean it's not as serious.
This is a disaster. Pray for Tua. Fire the medical staffs and coaches. I predicted this and I hate that I am right. Two concussions in 5 days can kill someone. This can end careers. How are we so stupid in 2022.
I take no pleasure in being right. Pray for Tua. We saw this coming. Get angry. Get involved with
@ConcussionLF
to make sure the
@NFL
can't do this again.
If Tua takes the field tonight, it's a massive step back for
#concussion
care in the NFL.
If he has a 2nd concussion that destroys his season or career, everyone involved will be sued & should lose their jobs, coaches included. We all saw it, even they must know this isn't right
Mike McDaniel said it's good Tua "doesn't have anything more serious than a
#concussion
."
I don't think this guy gets it. A concussion is a traumatic brain injury & posturing suggests brain stem injury. It's pretty high on the list of serious medical consequences of football.
@Thomas_Ragland
In addition to stumbling when he stood up and falling, he never reached for his back or leg. Instead, he reached for his head and then shook his head side to side to "clear the cobwebs". The NFL and the Dolphins take us for fools.
LISTEN: Donald Parham Jr. is at the hospital with a brain/spine injury. Joe Buck says he'd never speculate on an injury, then speculates DP's arm tremors were bc "it's cold tonight, at least by Los Angeles standards."
Ladies and gents, meet rock bottom for sports broadcasting.
Disgusted that the
@HoustonTexans
allowed Tom Savage to return to the game after 2 plays after showing these horrifying
#concussion
signs (is that a seizure?) after a head impact. I would not let my worst enemy go through the 2017
#NFL
sideline concussion protocol...
Sending positive thoughts to Hangman. This was not a high risk move. Something went wrong.
Ref Paul Turner is trained to recognize a
#concussion
or a possible neck injury & stopped match.
@DocSampson13
was ringside & there in seconds, gives us the best chance for a good outcome.
Worst & best of
#concussions
in the
#NFL
here.
DeVante Parker shows clear "no-go" signs after a head hit. Everyone (spotter, coaches, refs) pretends they didn't see it- EXCEPT teammate Nelson Agholor, who tries to stop the next play. Teammate of the Year!
Sadly, it happened.
Tua Tagovailoa is in the
#concussion
protocol after reporting symptoms today, likely from this play in Q2 ⬇️. Missed by team again, despite poor play & 3 INT's after. 3rd concussion of season-no doctor in their right mind can clear him this year. Season over.
If Tua takes the field tonight, it's a massive step back for
#concussion
care in the NFL.
If he has a 2nd concussion that destroys his season or career, everyone involved will be sued & should lose their jobs, coaches included. We all saw it, even they must know this isn't right
At the right schools, pro wrestlers are taught to protect each other. This is not performance, this is a careless violent assault IMO. I would suggest other wrestlers avoid getting in the ring with this guy.
In light of the Tua disaster last night, I appreciate more than ever
@AEW
@TonyKhan
,
@WWE
@TripleH
, &
@nwa
@Billy
all inviting me to come teach their talent abt
#concussions
& the risks of getting in the ring before you've recovered. Protecting athletes begins with educating them
Breaking: Beloved
#NFL
WR Demaryius Thomas had Stage 2
#CTE
when he died at 33. I arranged his brain donation to the VA-BU-
@ConcussionLF
Brain Bank where
@annmckeemd
@bu_cte
made the diagnosis. He struggled with erratic behavior, memory loss, & paranoia.
The unaffiliated neurotrauma consultant involved in clearing Dolphins QB Tua Tagovailoa during Sunday's game against the Bills has been fired after it was found he made "several mistakes" in his evaluation, according to ESPN and multiple reports.
More:
This "Cam Newton's visor poked him in the eye" is the greatest storyline in the history of sports. And I'm saying that as a former WWE wrestler. Watch the video, you don't collapse after that him because you need ice on your face. It's a
#concussion
.
#NFL
#concussion
protocol is a fraud. QB Jacoby Brissett goes back in after showing the clearest concussions signs of the season. Helmet-to-helmet hit, holds head, then goes limp, then needs help up. You don't need a protocol to hold this player out for the game. Check the tape:
@RobGronkowski
You are right about brain plasticity, and I am glad you are feeling great today, but neurodegenerative diseases (CTE, Alzheimer's, etc.) cannot be "fixed" or cured today. They eventually win. Please come on over to the BU brain bank next week and we can discuss the nuances.
I believe adults can choose to do dangerous jobs if they understand the risks & reasonable efforts are made to protect them.
But head hits with no defense is just sad. It reminds us that people who don't take the risks often exploit those who do.
The way Brock Purdy grabbed his head here, I strongly suspect he felt something.
Because it was the end of the game & they have a bye week, everyone will pretend nothing happened.
It was a terrible idea to play him 6 days after a
#concussion
.
The NFL Players Association has terminated the unaffiliated neurotrauma consultant involved in Tua Tagovailoa's concussion check last Sunday, as
@ProFootballTalk
said.
Both the UNC and the
#Dolphins
team physician were interviewed Friday, per source. Investigation ongoing.
I'm calling bull$hit on the "back tweak theory". Watch the vid. Tua shakes his head multiple times to "clear the cobwebs", which is a specific sign of vision impairment after
#concussion
. He also wobbles getting up before falling. His return is a fail
@NFL
My understanding of the Tua Tagovailoa situation: He tweaked his back in the 1st quarter on a sneak and didn’t miss time. After the Matt Milano hit, his back locked up — leading to him wobbling. Into the locker room for a full concussion check. Fully cleared. Now on the field.
What the Dolphins did to Tua last night reminds me of how they mishandled QB Matt Moore in the 2017 Playoffs.
He was hit in the head, couldn’t stand up for 2 minutes, and missed one play.
Watch:
Parents, if your son takes a hit like this and can’t stand up, and the team leaves him in, just walk on the court and pull him off yourself. He only gets one brain.
"This backup thing, I could do this for a long time and be happy with it... I'm pretty content making a good living, not getting pounded." -Danny Kanell
Is that what you meant by “built for the NFL?” Collect checks and let guys like Carson Wentz take the hits?
Shameful.
Respectfully disagree. Not saying he’s soft but some dudes aren’t built for the NFL. Until Wentz actually plays a full season it’s a more than fair question.
You are so clever to mock a 24 year-old kid who suffered a brain injury in front of 300 million witnesses, but was left to play on without being evaluated.
Maybe you could use your platform to help educate uninformed fans on
#concussion
rather than piling on.
Of course you eject Damontae Kazee for this hit.
Michael Pittman Jr. doesn't deserve a brain injury - or spine - for trying to make a great catch. (He got a
#concussion
)
It's a new day in sports. These are human beings first.
We can adjust how we play.
Dear
@NFL
,
You must do better. This is bigger than protocols. A concussion can change a life. For me, it’s personal. We can’t let any other children grow up without their fathers.
Vikings appear to pull out the smelling salts here, which are famous for being used to revive someone after a
#concussion
. While also used "recreationally" it's a terrible look for the NFL after Tua.
Thanks
@alanschwarz
, who we all owe a lot to, for the video.
Shame on you
@stephenasmith
. This kind of 2005 talk sends a terrible message to young athletes. You know better.
It doesn't have to look catastrophic to cause
#concussion
. And asking 6'10" guys who are dizzy and can't see straight to walk to the locker room is bad medical care.
It’s wild that this is the conversation on a national talk show in 2023 the day after a player looks like they may have been knocked out of a playoff game due to a concussion.
If Dawkins wasn't immediately pulled for a full
#concussion
evaluation this is as bad as it gets.
He points to his head within seconds of a helmet-to-helmet (self-report) and can't even kneel without falling. Was he really allowed to continue playing?
Wrestlers: if someone has fallen in a way that may have caused a neck/spine injury - especially when they might have a
#concussion
- do not touch them!
With the concussion, they can't tell you they have a broken neck. You could paralyze or kill them. Crowd will support stopping.
If you or someone you are about is struggling with concussion symptoms, possible CTE, or other potential consequences head impacts, reach out to the
@ConcussionLF
HelpLine here:
Fort Lauderdale airport shut down hours ago due to relentless rain but we can't get our due to flooded roads. Now the water is coming in and the rain isn't stopping. Not good.
Dolphins QB Tua Tagovailoa is out with a
#concussion
.
Backup QB Teddy Bridgewater is now out & in the concussion protocol.
So Mike McDaniel runs a reverse with his only healthy QB as a lead blocker? Sorry, this guy still doesn't get it.🤔
IT HAPPENED AGAIN
@NFL
!
Cam Brate went back in 4 plays after showing
#concussion
signs from this huge hit to the head. He stayed down too long & couldn't run off the field fast enough to avoid a penalty.
@TonyDungy
says it was obvious he had a concussion. How did he go back in?
Broken system. I was on the sideline very close to Brate-obvious he had his bell rung. There’s a league appointed spotter in the press box who should stop play & alert the referee. Brate shouldn’t have been allowed to return until after an evaluation. Why didn’t that happen???
This is a very unfortunate way to get into the
#concussion
protocol. Unacceptable. These kind of punches kill people regularly, usually from the head hitting the ground after being knocked out. Bad idea, always.
This deserves another look. Ajayi gives a “Chung is sleeping” signal, aka is knocked out. In all my years I’ve never heard of an NFL player lying about that for gamesmanship. Yet Chung is back after a quick “blue tent” evaluation. I don’t buy it. It’s a bad
#concussion
protocol.
.
@RobGronkowski
I appreciate and respect that you have the guts to talk honestly about
#concussions
and
#CTE
. But right now
#CTE
cannot be fixed- I invite your help in changing that.
.
@RobGronkowski
told CBSN's
@reenaninan
that he'd let his son play football ––only after educating him about what he went through in the game.
He said he had about "nine surgeries, probably had 20 concussions" playing football.
Stable is great news.
But it has to be said tonight:
Donald Parham Jr. has a brain injury, but
#NFL
teams say "head injury" as part of a coordinated campaign to not make it sound scary so we keep watching and signing our kids up.
Injury Update: Tight End Donald Parham Jr. is currently undergoing tests, imaging and evaluation for a head injury at UCLA Harbor Medical Center and is in stable condition.
Context:
@ConcussionLF
has only
#concussion
education program for sports media. Taught at 20 universities. We've offered to train football broadcasters for free. Turned down bc
#NFL
provides their own training on concussions. Lesson 1: Don't say the c word
Double
#concussion
in the USC-Tulane game w/18 seconds remaining. Reviewed, no targeting.
Long discussion of the rule, zero mention of the two brain injuries or their implications. "Shaken up" "wobbly" nonsense words used. Colleges, NCAA in control of the narrative.
#CTE
So Josh Rosen (I was his 8th grade coach) can't play in a bowl game (probably his last CFB game) almost a month after a concussion which no one could even tell happened, but he might be the 1st pick in the NFL draft?! How is that possible? Either he's a wuss or has a BIG problem!
Looks like DeVante Parker wanted to receive medical care for his brain injury as if he were an actual human being - rather than an asset for the NFL to exploit & forget about once his health is used up.
Worst & best of
#concussions
in the
#NFL
here.
DeVante Parker shows clear "no-go" signs after a head hit. Everyone (spotter, coaches, refs) pretends they didn't see it- EXCEPT teammate Nelson Agholor, who tries to stop the next play. Teammate of the Year!
I've been at this for 20 years. This is the most difficult article I've ever had to read or share.
I want you to know how great my Harvard captain Chris Eitzmann was.
I want you to know how far he fell before he died last year & was diagnosed with
#CTE
.
I want you do know how…
Paul Turner handle
@RefTurnerAEW
. He was not scared to potentially end a main event match by calling in the doc. Let him how much you appreciate him keeping talent safe.
This is fantastic. Well done
@BillPascrell
! The public deserves real answers, not what movie Tua shouldn't have watched on the plane flight he probably shouldn't have taken home.
Today I’ve written to NFL commish Roger Goodell and Dolphins owner Stephen Ross demanding answers about the concussion to
@Tua
days after he had another injury. As head of Congress’s Brain Injury Task Force I want to know how the hell he was on the field last night.
Rare to have both players suffer a
#concussion
on the same hit, but it appears Derwin James & Ashton Dulin both suffered traumatic brain injuries here. James ejected.
No word yet on how the brain injuries will impact their families in 20 years.
Tough to wake up in a world where:
1. This hit could be easily legislated out of the game
2. Every NHL player studied post-mortem has had
#CTE
3. The NHL refuses to fund research into how to fix these broken brains
If you've made the mistake of signing up your young child for youth tackle football, there is no shame in pulling them out today & moving to flag.
I know this sounds radical, but I'll say it- allowing your child to get hit in the head over and over again is not a good idea. 👇
#FIFA
#WorldCup2018
@ConcussionLF
#concussion
alert:
France's Blaise Matuidi was involved in a collision & taken to the sideline. Docs evaluated him for a whole 2 minutes before clearing him to return.
He lasted less than 2 minutes before collapsing.
I'm very tired of this.
Prayers for JuJu Smith-Schuster after this
#concussion
. Straight arms is the "fencing response". Means he was unconscious & deep parts of his brain are injured. He cannot return per protocol & for his sake I hope they give him multiple weeks to recover.
The standard football kickoff will be gone in 5 years at all levels. It's simply too dangerous.
This
@xfl2020
innovation has my attention. I expect we will find it's just as exciting and significantly safer. Well done. 👇
Prayers for Dylan Larkin.
NHL & Gary Bettman don't believe - or at least claim to not believe for legal reasons - that repeated traumatic brain injuries can cause
#CTE
.
This is the result. Free head shots.
The NHL gets richer.
Only players pay the price.
I've spoken to multiple brain injury experts and no one is confident in the diagnosis for Donald Parham Jr.'s shaking arms here based on this video. But it's not good. The team at
@ConcussionLF
is hoping for the best possible outcome.
Wyatt Bramwell died by suicide at 18.
He played tackle football from age 8 to 18.
He died with stage 2
#CTE
.
That is the same stage Junior Seau had.
Wyatt's the first teenager to have stage 2 CTE. He won't be the last. Please choose flag under 14.
Plays like Malcolm Jenkins unloading on Brandin Cooks helmet-to-helmet from behind cannot continue if the NFL doesn't want more fans to walk away. No penalty? This rule has to change in the offseason if we still respect human life.
Wow. I don't really understand the rules anymore, but it looks to me like he led with the crown of the helmet and hit Baker Mayfield right in the brain bucket.
The
#NFL
picked up this flag in the
#Browns
game after stating Baker had not yet begun his slide and therefore was “allowed to be hit in the head”🤔... Yet here is clear helmet to helmet head hunting. What a sham of a league.
Iran's goalkeeper went down after clashing heads w/teammate. Cleared, only to lay down minutes later & beg for a sub.
#WorldCup
is off to a disastrous start on
#concussion
management.
Sets an example that puts 10's of millions of global youth players at risk.
Shameful.
Here is the hit that put Josh Johnson in the
#concussion
protocol. The back of his head hit the ground, just like Tua's first 2. Worth noting that helmets are getting heavier to be "safer" - QB's falling on their back may be revealing a flaw in the design.
#NHL
continues to fly under the radar with shocking
#concussion
care.
Here's Jean-Gabriel Pageau after a big hit from Ovechkin. This is classic ataxia & in the new
#NFL
protocol is automatic removal. Pageau was "evaluated" & returned to the game. Time to update the protocol Gary
BREAKING: Largest study ever on pro soccer players (>7,000 in Scotland) led by
@WillStewNeuro
finds players were:
3.5x more likely to die of any neurodegenerative disease
5x more likely to die of Alzheimer's
4x more likely to die of ALS/MND
This is big
Tough brain injury symptoms displayed by Elijah Moore last night. The
#concussion
caused circuits of his brain to fire involuntarily. Very unsettling, even for a neuroscientist. Let's hope for a good recovery.
HORRIBLE: Michigan State's Alante Brown was allowed to return after showing a clear sign of
#concussion
here.
Failure to protect yourself when you spike your head on the ground usually means you are unconscious.
College football needs independent doctors on the sideline.
Ex-Titans TE Frank Wycheck, 52, dies after fall at home.
I am heartbroken. Frank retired from
#concussions
at 32 & was courageously outspoken.
He was in the first group of athletes to publicly pledge to donate their brain in 2008. We owe him a great debt.
The US is still years ahead of the world on
#concussions
.
Here we're mad Tua stayed in an
#NFL
game... even though he showed no outward signs.
In the UK, no one appears to care that Chelsea's Denis Zakaria looked to be knocked out... but returned 2 minutes later. Full video👇
How the hell was Keylon Stokes allowed to return to the game?
You can't diagnose a
#concussion
from video. But it's also true that a doctor CANNOT definitively rule out a concussion on the sideline after this horror show. If only anyone enforced protocols in $college football$.
Joe Burrow
@JoeyB
revealed he's played through multiple
#concussions
. A thread:
1. It's irresponsible for pros to talk about playing through concussions w/out acknowledging how dangerous it is. Youth & high school athletes are listening.
"If Joe ignores concussions, I will too."
A massive flaw still in the
#NFL
protocol is that if you don't stand up, you can't show ataxia or gross motor instability.
Watch how long Braxton Berrios stays down on a knee after this huge hit. He couldn't celebrate his own touchdown. Brain injury or wind? We'll never know.
Here is what could have happened to Tua:
HS RB Jayden Veesenmeyer is currently in a coma after a brain bleed. I'm told he took 2 weeks off due to a
#concussion
, but it appears it wasn't enough. "When in doubt, sit them out." Pray for him. via
@RyanMahanSJR
How is the
#NHL
worse on
#concussions
than the
#NFL
?
Gary Bettman: "Let's allow cheap shots to defenseless players (banned in NFL), add ice for a nice skull bounce, the deny it causes
#CTE
& provide no support for retired players!"
This is a great conversation on the role of the head coach as a 2nd line of defense for protecting players.
Doctors can make mistakes and coaches should feel free to overrule them - but ONLY when erring on the side of caution.
The Sunday Countdown crew weighs in on the Tua Tagovailoa situation:
“I treated every one of my players like they were my son … No way in hell I put my son back in that game.” – Rex Ryan
This Chicago kid's heart is breaking: '85 Chicago Bear legend Steve 'Mongo' McMichael has
#ALS
.
#NFL
players have a 4x risk of developing ALS & it appears due to trauma/
#CTE
. I'm begging more scientists to take the link seriously and invest in research.
You don't hear this often & it is concerning. Post-traumatic amnesia means Hurst was or is having trouble forming new memories & possibly remembering old ones. I hope he takes his time and recovers fully.
@haydenrhurst
has been diagnosed with Post Traumatic Amnesia by an independent neurologist as a result of the hit he took in Chicago November 9. Slow recovery, don’t know when he’ll be back. Prayers appreciated!
The continued confident ignorance of Coach Mike McDaniel on
#concussions
is astonishing.
Tua's in real danger playing for this guy again.
Concussion tests are 100% accurate?
He did media interviews so he's fine?
He can't seriously believe these things.
A
#WorldCup2018
#concussion
disaster already???
Morocco player is knocked out & the medic SLAPS HIM IN THE FACE to try to revive him & keep him playing!!!
Looks like we have work to do.
#FixFIFA
Why does Tua's care matter to me so much?
The
@NFL
still denies that they missed Tua's Sunday
#concussion
⬇️.
PARENTS, you need to know that if you follow NFL's example & dismiss on field signs, your child can die.
Below are athletes who have died from second-impact syndrome.❤️❤️
Our interview with NFL CMO Dr. Allen Sills on why Tua Tagovailoa was allowed to fly home, what happened last Sunday and on the subsequent concussion checks during the week, and on whether the concussion protocol could be changed as a result.
To my knowledge zero
#NFL
players have had 3 diagnosed concussions in a season.
Miami still denies the 1st, but this is unprecedented. All eyes will be on the team & the NFL.
That said, spoke to a former NFL player who was knocked out 3x in one game before they tracked them.
Everyone is focused on the fumble, but if you watched Godwin's head slam the ground in slo-mo, & the fact he didn't chase his own fumble in this video, the eye in the sky has to call down to have him evaluated for a
#concussion
. Agree?
Watch Dolphins LT
#75
Greg Little take a knee to the head, stay down, get up looking woozy, do the "shake off the cobwebs" TWiCE, yet finish the drive.
The FOX cameraman & producer hold on him way too long to try to help the
#concussion
spotter. How do you not evaluate him
@NFL
?
Fingers crossed Tua Tagovailoa doesn't become the first
#NFL
player in modern history - and possibly ever - to have 3 diagnosed
#concussions
in a season
(yes, I know the Dolphins are still covering up the 1st concussion, & that's the problem)
Dolphins’ QB Tua Tagovailoa was cleared from concussion protocol today, per sources. He will be inactive on Sunday vs. the Vikings, but he is expected to return for Week 7 vs. the Steelers.
More:
Wait for a response? Come on Kevin, the protocol is breached weekly. No one is punished. We pretend it didn't happen. The docs are supposed protect these men from severe brain injury & death. If they aren't required to watch the video before clearing them, NFL just doesn't care.
We should await response from the Texans before judging their medical staff for returning QB Tom Savage to today's game after a brutal hit that left him, at the very least, stunned for several seconds on the ground. But to be clear, the NFL supplies...
I cannot believe the
@NFL
blew their new
#concussion
protocol in the 2nd week with Cam Newton. Heads need to roll, and I’m not talking about the helpless
#concussed
players who are receiving negligent medical care