
Charlie Theel
@CharlieTheel
Followers
2K
Following
16K
Media
575
Statuses
7K
Board game critic. Bylines: @ArsTechnica @Polygon @ign @joindicebreaker @TabletopMag @geekandsundry @pcgamer @wargamercom. Co-hosted @DingandDent.
Joined August 2014
I had no interest in Lord of the Rings Pandemic. But what I discovered was an epic that bears little semblance to its predecessor. In my review, I discuss IP, narrative framework, and aspect ratios. You can find it here:
playerelimination.com
Somewhere, Matt Leacock is walking around, chained to a big goose as gold as the sun. For the love of God, someone let this man design something other than Pandemic. Not today. “It’s a …
0
3
6
It's not every day a 60-year-old avant-garde film is adapted to a mass market board game by Phil Walker-Harding. In my review, I discuss 2001, player elimination, and the legacy of Prospero Hall.
playerelimination.com
Prospero Hall is back. I’m sorry, that’s a lie. 2001: A Space Odyssey the Board Game is not a Prospero Hall title. It’s a Phil Walker-Harding design courtesy of Maestro Media. Thi…
0
1
8
The Old King's Crown is a wild game of bidding, tableau building, and area control. It's also gorgeous to gander at. My review:
playerelimination.com
The Old King’s Crown is beautiful. It’s a lavishly illustrated craft with peerless style. This charisma reverberates in the game’s excellent writing, with passages leaping from th…
0
0
4
Over at IGN I've written a list of the top games that impressed me at Gen Con. A lot of choice titles here:
ign.com
We went to Gen Con 2025 and found all the best board games at the show.
1
0
7
Leviathan Wilds is back with a fresh print run and expansion. I take a look at the new content and also re-assess the base game, which I first reviewed just over a year ago. Leviathan Wilds: Deepvale -
playerelimination.com
Deepvale is the hotly anticipated expansion to one of my favorite titles of 2024. Justin Keppainen’s Leviathan Wilds is an impressive indie cut that captures much of the excitement in boulder…
0
0
3
Vantage is Stonemaier Games' evolution of the tabletop open world adventure. This sharp construction solves some of the pitfalls of its peers, and in doing so, manages to present itself as one of the best games of 2025. My review:
ign.com
Vantage, from the makers of Wingspan and Scythe, is a sandbox adventure board game of immense proportion.
0
1
4
RT @halfwayhoping: @CharlieTheel composed this thoughtful review of Chicago '68. Link in the comments ✊. #boardgames @FoundationDietz @joe_….
0
1
0
Chicago '68 is a blistering look at protest and violence. It's an emotional historical game that never flinches. My review:
playerelimination.com
First time designer Yoni Goldstein offers a brick to the temple with his debut title, Chicago ’68. This historical game is set during the tumultuous events surrounding the Democratic National…
0
0
6
Ichor is the second game in Bitewing's Mythos line. Like its sibling Iliad, it's a dynamic and thoughtful design from Reiner Knizia. Unfortunately, I didn't find it quite as legendary. My review:
playerelimination.com
Beyond Sextus Empiricus (a noteworthy Greek skeptic, not an Imperator from the Citadel), absolutely no one should be doubting that Bitewing Games has cornered the Reiner Knizia market. Their reign …
0
0
3
Apex Legends is brought to the tabletop as a skirmish game full of interesting characters, exciting modes, and nuanced gunplay. My review at IGN:
ign.com
Apex Legends: The Board game is an enormous effort that can be both overwhelming and thrilling.
0
0
1
Off the Page Games' third title seeks to adapt a comic about Lewis and Clark slaying beasts and extinguishing evil. The core identity of the game is that of a puzzle. A new framework for exploration. Something entirely novel. My review:.
playerelimination.com
I’m not familiar with the comic Manifest Destiny. I don’t need to be. The concept of Lewis and Clark embarking Westward with the ulterior motive of slaying monsters is totally righteous…
0
0
4
Why bet on horses when you can bet on D-list mascots? Hot Streak is a revelation. Rarely is a game equal parts absurd and committed. My review:
playerelimination.com
The smell was unbearable. It was a mixture of sweat and piss; the suit forever marked with the fluids of previous captives. His eyes burned but all he could do was feebly rub his forearm around the…
0
0
1
Reiner Knizia is still cranking out epics like the 90s never ended. Here, he takes on the climactic showdown between Hector and Achilles. Both warriors seek blood and honor, but they also seek the ear of the gods.
playerelimination.com
“Now my doom is upon me. Let me not then die ingloriously without a struggle, but in the working of some great deed to be told among men hereafter.” Reiner Knizia’s latest –…
0
2
5
On Monday I published a review about an influential game with historical significance. Today, I'm looking at a silly little game about ducks. Quack, quack.
playerelimination.com
My kid is all in on ducks. I don’t know why. I’m not sure she knows why. But a year or so ago, at the age of 10, she decided she was all about fowl. I will tell you, it’s difficul…
0
0
2
Cyclades helped usher in the era of Euro/Ameritrash hybrid design and has left an indelible mark on the hobby. It also happens to be one of my favorite games. Does the Legendary Edition measure up to this legacy? My thoughts:
playerelimination.com
Cyclades’ release in 2009 was a watershed moment. Alongside Chaos in the Old World, it was responsible for the conception of the hybrid design, blending together elements of Ameritrash and cl…
0
1
4
Here we go, my annual top 50 games list. Come take a gander at the good stuff:
boardgamegeek.com
Previously titled, "After X Years of Reviewing, Charlie Theel's Top 50 Games". I always thought that sounded a little pretentious, pointing to some level of authority due to my history as a reviewer....
1
2
7