CarnaticPrior Profile Banner
Karthik Dinakar Profile
Karthik Dinakar

@CarnaticPrior

Followers
766
Following
5K
Media
143
Statuses
4K

Carnatic Bayesian šŸ‡®šŸ‡³šŸ‡ŗšŸ‡ø

Cambridge, MA
Joined March 2009
Don't wanna be here? Send us removal request.
@CarnaticPrior
Karthik Dinakar
3 years
As She May Sing, a new post from me resulting from an experience crafted for me by my beloved mentors. The concept of Śiva & Śakti and its manifestation as conjugate priors. ā¤ļø šŸŒ https://t.co/ILgWs7XPp3 #Gratitude
0
0
2
@CarnaticPrior
Karthik Dinakar
24 days
5/ asya vyākhyāna-pradarśanasya darśanāt mama manaįø„ ātmā ca paramaṁ sammohanam anubhavataįø„ šŸ™šŸ½
0
0
1
@CarnaticPrior
Karthik Dinakar
24 days
4/ Though I was too young at the time I wish someone had pointed me to @MadrasMobile (who was also seen moved to tears in today's lecture demonstration) article on the ancient Kamalāmbika & Tyāgēśa temple as yet another repository of deep knowledge:
1
0
2
@CarnaticPrior
Karthik Dinakar
24 days
3/ leaves one speechless until one experiences a kind of beauty that surpasses all human ability. Like so many others visible in the video, I found myself moved to tears before the mangala kriti at the end
1
0
1
@CarnaticPrior
Karthik Dinakar
24 days
2/ RKS mused at the very beginning that he would only be "scratching the surface". The richness of the tapestry behind these compositions, the nondual philosophy, esoteric Śrī Vidya geometric mystical meaning of the yantras, āsanas & mathematical aptness in the rāga-tāla
1
0
1
@CarnaticPrior
Karthik Dinakar
24 days
1/ Witnessing and experiencing RKS's 3-hour lecture demonstration on the Kamalāmba Navāvarna Kritis was pure bliss. Astonishingly resplendent descriptions of Dīkśita's depth, technical musical brilliance & spiritual knowledge.
1
0
1
@MadrasMobile
Sriram V
27 days
In Carnatic Music, legends about long dead legends keep growing by the day. No wonder it is a legendary art. #DecemberMusicSeason2025
0
3
20
@CarnaticPrior
Karthik Dinakar
29 days
An instructive and illuminating phenomenon is to observe, witness and to feel ML Vasanthakumari singing jaya jaya jānaki kāntha. Layers upon layers lyrical meaning of the composition accompanied, ornamented and enriched by aesthetic rāgam motifs & subtle percussive combinatorics.
@QuantaMagazine
Quanta Magazine
2 months
What if biological language involves a system that’s something like an LLM? Long before the rise of ChatGPT, the neuroscientist Ev Fedorenko (@ev_fedorenko) was studying a network in the brain that maps words to their meanings. @johnpavlus reports:
0
0
1
@JeffDean
Jeff Dean
1 month
Performance Hints Over the years, my colleague Sanjay Ghemawat and I have done a fair bit of diving into performance tuning of various pieces of code. We wrote an internal Performance Hints document a couple of years ago as a way of identifying some general principles and we've
107
1K
8K
@CarnaticPrior
Karthik Dinakar
1 month
Lec-dem video from 2024 margazdhi sessions of Madras Music Academy chaired by @MadrasMobile:
1
0
2
@CarnaticPrior
Karthik Dinakar
1 month
18/ My takeaways: This episode reveals a complex, reciprocal relationship between text and practice, showing how written sources can reshape musical tradition as powerfully as oral ones.
1
0
1
@CarnaticPrior
Karthik Dinakar
1 month
17/ Impact: Later Tanjore-region texts followed Shahaji, cementing kaki nishada for both ragas.
1
0
1
@CarnaticPrior
Karthik Dinakar
1 month
16/ Shahaji emerges as an empiricist, grounding both theory and examples in written sources—yet those very sources shaped a lasting shift.
1
0
1
@CarnaticPrior
Karthik Dinakar
1 month
15/ Conclusion: The transformation of Aharī and Ābhērī was not driven by oral transmission, but by textual transmission errors and reinterpretation.
1
0
1
@CarnaticPrior
Karthik Dinakar
1 month
14/ Explanation: Shahaji likely relied on incomplete written sources, where key modifying phrases (like kakali nishada) were missing—leading to reclassification via the closest mela.
1
0
1
@CarnaticPrior
Karthik Dinakar
1 month
13/ But here’s the contradiction: • Shahaji’s text → AharÄ« & ĀbhērÄ« = Bhairavi Mela • Manuscripts → same songs labeled AharÄ« Mela
1
0
1
@CarnaticPrior
Karthik Dinakar
1 month
12/ Dr. Srilatha shows that the melodic phrases Shahaji cites for Aharī and Ābhērī are directly traceable to these manuscripts. One Ābhērī example even comes from a gīta by Venkatamakhi himself.
1
0
1
@CarnaticPrior
Karthik Dinakar
1 month
11/ Crucial intervention: Gīta manuscripts. These notated chaturdandi forms include paratexts (marginal notes) that preserve raga identities and details missing in treatises.
1
0
1
@CarnaticPrior
Karthik Dinakar
1 month
10/ Ragalakshana of Shahaji (1684–1710) lists: • 20 melas • 115 ragas It defines AharÄ« as belonging to Bhairavi Mela and provides melodic examples from chaturdandi forms.
1
0
1
@CarnaticPrior
Karthik Dinakar
1 month
9/ Then comes the turning point: Late 17th-century texts from the Tanjore region suddenly reclassify both AharÄ« and ĀbhērÄ« into the Bhairavi Mela, • Dropping kakali nishada • Adopting kaki nishada —simultaneously.
1
0
1
@CarnaticPrior
Karthik Dinakar
1 month
8/ In Chaturdandi Prakashika (c. 1650), Venkatamakhi asserts harmony between lakshana (theory) and lakshya (practice) for ragas like Aharī.
1
0
1