@AlexandraErin
Alexandra Erin | patreon.com/AlexandraErin
2 years
Remember when acclaimed novelist John Boyne Googled "red dye ingredients" for a historical novel, copied down the top answer preview, and put Octorok eyes, Lizalfos tails, and Hylian shrooms (not mushrooms, but shrooms) in what was ostensibly real-world 12th century Eurasia?
60
1K
12K

Replies

@AlexandraErin
Alexandra Erin | patreon.com/AlexandraErin
2 years
Did not stop to check out the meaning of any unfamiliar words. Did not try to correlate any of these ingredients with their availability to a particular time and place (which would have revealed that there was none). Just plunked them into a novel, which was edited and printed.
1
48
3K
@AlexandraErin
Alexandra Erin | patreon.com/AlexandraErin
2 years
Think about this in the context of overwhelming impostor syndrome and anxiety about "getting it wrong" for basically anything I might attempt to undertake.
5
84
3K
@AlexandraErin
Alexandra Erin | patreon.com/AlexandraErin
2 years
Even at the peak of Breath of the Wild's hype, I don't expect everyone in the world to recognize Zelda lore terms. But I also don't expect a writer "researching" for a novel to let so many completely unknown terms pile up in a single passage.
15
40
3K
@jimoutofbennies
Jim (Gamma Male)
2 years
@AlexandraErin OMG I put more effort into my TTRPG notes for the benefit of five people.
1
4
328
@KRGoose
a large goose
2 years
@AlexandraErin I just told a non-online person about this last week. That was so fucking funny.
0
1
46
@zander_cannon
Zander Cannon | SDCC FF-03
2 years
@AlexandraErin Less galling, but still quite funny: in 2005, comedian Chris Elliott included the fictional character Boilerplate (created by @bigredhair and @Boilerplate1893 ) in his novel as if it were real (or at least a contemporaneous hoax)
3
4
55
@Karkadinn
Stephen Mackey
2 years
@AlexandraErin ...I take it the editor was interested in neither history nor video games....
1
1
46
@ellle_em
Elle Has Cats (and ADHD)
2 years
@AlexandraErin I think about this every time I struggle to write a single sentence because the words don't sound exactly 100% right and I end up staring at a blank document for three hours
1
8
747
@MockWooloo
Wooloo | @mockwooloo.bsky.social
2 years
@AlexandraErin There was also a time Whitley Strieber mistook a 1979 short story by Dave Langford for an authentic account of a 19th-century UFO encounter and used it in one of his books without permission.
1
4
123
@mxjaynestrange
Jayne Strange
2 years
@AlexandraErin I get imposter syndrome from going to the grocery store, how is this guy even alive?
2
7
504
@e_brooks
Erica Brooks
2 years
@AlexandraErin God that was glorious. That was a fun day on the internet.
0
1
24
@GradeBMaple
Songbreeze Swifteye (Rose) ๐Ÿ’—๐Ÿ’œ๐Ÿ’™ ๐ŸŒบ๐Ÿ‡๐Ÿฌ
2 years
@AlexandraErin But did any of his characters have Alexandria's Genesis
1
0
7
@dragon0131
Dragon0131
2 years
@AlexandraErin I will admit, I donโ€™t know much about Zelda. But I do know Hylian has something to do with Zelda & I would have to double check the rest to make sure they exist.
0
3
82
@foolerrant
Foolish Mortal - my skeleton brain still lives๐Ÿ€
2 years
@AlexandraErin I needed to be reminded of this today as I desperately make sure the car I'm writing it ON MODEL.
0
1
23
@FanboySingleton
Skyshroud Jay ๐Ÿ”œ MC Amsterdam
2 years
@AlexandraErin Wasn't this the guy who wrote a Holocaust book, trying to say the Germans weren't all bad, while doing absolutely no research about the Holocaust
2
3
309
@daniela_kraml
Hirschi๐ŸฆŒ
2 years
@AlexandraErin That was John Boyne? Figures.
0
1
8
@KittensNeeds
For love of cats
2 years
@AlexandraErin It wouldโ€™ve taken 3 brain cells to realize you can dye stuff red with red rose petals wouldโ€™ve been, yah know, much more believable
2
1
18
@JellyKind
JellyKind
2 years
@AlexandraErin Extremely dubious recipe.
1
1
6
@OldAutisticAFAB
Huytongirl โ™ฟ ๐Ÿณ๏ธโ€โšง๏ธ
2 years
@AlexandraErin It was a hugely successful novel some years ago, forget which, set in London, with a sentence something like, "it was five oclock on New year's Eve and everybody was dying for it to go dark." I mean how long does it take you to find out what time is sunset in mid December!๐Ÿคฃ
1
2
76
@UltimateXiphias
DreamAnimal
2 years
@AlexandraErin He's replacing actual Jewish authors as the school standard for teaching the Holocaust, we're so fucked
0
3
108