@Ahmed1Hilal
हिलाल अहमद Hilal Ahmed
5 years
As a committed student of DAV I opted Sanskrit instead of English after 10th class. My teacher -a trained Sanskrit Brahmin categorically told us that Sanskrit shouldn't be seen through the prism of any religion. The result was obvious: I got distinction in Sanskrit in 12th class!
@omthanvi
Om Thanvi | ओम थानवी
5 years
संस्कृत को मुसलमान विद्वान नहीं पढ़ा सकता? उस देश-प्रदेश में, जहाँ फ़िराक़ गोरखपुरी जैसे हिंदू विद्वान ने कृत्रिम हिंदी की निंदा की, अंगरेज़ी के प्रोफ़ेसर रहे और जिन्होंने उर्दू में महानतम शायरी की। ... भाषा को धर्म से बांधने वाले से बड़ा सांप्रदायिक कोई न होगा।
29
180
662
31
119
572

Replies

@kodle1983
शैलेंद्र कोड़ले
5 years
@Ahmed1Hilal Sir did you read in Indore ?
1
0
0
@Ahmed1Hilal
हिलाल अहमद Hilal Ahmed
5 years
0
0
0
@singhak
Ashok 🇮🇳
5 years
@Ahmed1Hilal @rahulpandita Bizarre such arguments, is it too much to listen to students ? Point is about Muslim/Monotheist teaching Hindu/ Polytheist Dharma/Religion/Rituals? You don’t see any contradiction, get over your prejudiced and curb this idea that one should not question because he is Muslim..
1
0
0
@chitrankanv
🚩🚩🚩
5 years
@Ahmed1Hilal @stellar_anmol Sirji Sanskrit ek bhasha hai...wo aaao jaan v sakty ho aur parha v sakte ho...par yaaha baat sanskrit parhane ki nei...Ved ka gyaan denaa issue hai...
0
0
0
@jon_snow_T
Gold Flake🚬🚬
5 years
@Ahmed1Hilal Same I got the distinction in Sanskrit in my 12th standard.
0
0
2
@NilanjanS
नीलांजन | Nilanjan
5 years
@Ahmed1Hilal @rahulpandita Janab, its is not as simple as you guys pretend to present; comparing apple with orange is no comparison. And neither is about sanskritam nor the teacher. Get facts right please - this read my help you, still there are more than this -
0
0
0
@skrthakur94
Sandeep Thakur
5 years
0
0
1
@Khanda32981538
Khanda
5 years
@Ahmed1Hilal @rahulpandita Think u got the facts wrong.....BHUbstudents are not concerned regarding who teaches Sanskrit..... the course they referring to is a religious course in Sanskrit. Would you learn theKoran from Hindu.
1
0
0
@mishvipin
Vipin Mishra
5 years
@Ahmed1Hilal I agree with you, this is useless debate whoever is capable of teaching that subject should be allowed.
0
0
2
@NITESH1981KUMAR
NITESH KUMAR
5 years
@Ahmed1Hilal Languages have nothing to do with religions. Many of the modern sanskrit scholars have been Europeans.
0
0
1
@primeargument
primeargument
5 years
@Ahmed1Hilal @rahulpandita Correct but would you say it qualifies you to teach religion itself. Should someone who knows English automatically qualify to teach Christianity in a protestant seminary? @omthanvi
0
0
0
@ajayrastogi7
Ajay Rastogi
5 years
@Ahmed1Hilal @rahulpandita हिलाल साहेब, सादर प्रणाम! आप इस बहस के अंदर जाकर देखेंगे तो पाएँगे कि यह संस्कृत बनाम मुस्लिम नहीं है।बहस है की क्या एक मुस्लिम शिक्षक को ऐसा पद स्वीकार करना चाहिए जिसमें उन्हें हिंदू पूजा पद्यती पर व्याख्या और हिंदू देवी-देवताओं के सामने नमन करना होगा।उनके लिए कितना कठिन होगा!
1
0
0
@ajayrastogi7
Ajay Rastogi
5 years
@Ahmed1Hilal @rahulpandita आपने स्वयं देखा होगा इस देश में कितने राजनितज्ञ ऐसे हैं जिन्हें वन्देमातरम् बोलने और स्कूलों में सूर्य नमस्कार पर इस्लाम ख़तरे में दिखता है, उनके लिए तो यह और भी नागवार होगा। बेहतर रास्ता यह होगा की डॉक्टर फ़िरोज़ BHU के SVDV से आर्ट फ़ैकल्टी में चले जाएँ। सब खुश.
0
0
0
@Somvanshi76
Indian Rajput
5 years
0
0
0
@Ankur_tiwari2
Ankur Tiwari
5 years
@Ahmed1Hilal @_YogendraYadav One hopes this conversation will also lead to opening doors in minority institutions such as AMU for example.
0
0
0
@fondoflinux
Shankara
5 years
@Ahmed1Hilal @_YogendraYadav Yes, your teacher is right. But Sanskrit us different from dharmic studies.
0
0
0
@amit302
Amit
5 years
@Ahmed1Hilal @_YogendraYadav I remember a conversation in a bank branch where à muslim officer telling his colleague that his son opted for sanskrit instead of Urdu. And he was proud that his son could beat his classmates in both Urdu and sanskrit. I was really impressed, the reason I Remember aft 30yrs.
0
0
1
@shantibh
SB
5 years
@Ahmed1Hilal @_YogendraYadav विषय के मामले में आपकी बात सही है पर क्या हिन्दू धर्म की शिक्षा कोई मुसलमान दे सकता है?
0
0
0
@TheBhaskar
bhaskar
5 years
@Ahmed1Hilal @_YogendraYadav संस्कृत पढ़ाने पे विरोध नहीं है बुतपरस्ती पढ़ाने पर ऑब्जेक्शन है मियां
0
0
0
@india_ankit
ANKIT SHUKLA
5 years
0
0
0