@yogobog
yogo𓆝
3 months
A thread about everything incorrect in Chuuya's bsd wiki page, bc @nbrimbaud had shown me how stupid it is, with evidence
5
143
782

Replies

@yogobog
yogo𓆝
3 months
this is just for funsies don't come after me
1
1
45
@yogobog
yogo𓆝
3 months
this is mild, but in the very second paragraph, he is said to have grey eyes. Now, while it lists the Dead apple light novel as a source, and Chuuya's eye colour is a bit of a debate, we mostly see him with blue (anime) or brown(manga) colours
Tweet media one
Tweet media two
Tweet media three
1
2
146
@yogobog
yogo𓆝
3 months
while talking about Chuuya's inhumanity, it refers to Arahabaki as an actual god, instead of an ability singularity in this particular paragraph. This is a very common misconception and incorrect. The god rumor was spread by Rimbaud as confirmed by Stormbringer
Tweet media one
2
5
157
@yogobog
yogo𓆝
3 months
Now, we have this whole paragraph that is actually so funny
Tweet media one
3
2
108
@yogobog
yogo𓆝
3 months
Let's start with the first sentence. "Ultimate downfall" is an odd way of phrasing their relationship, when they have been referred to as "one soul in two bodies" and an incredibly successful partnership. That is anything but a downfall, in fact it seems their relationship
Tweet media one
1
1
121
@yogobog
yogo𓆝
3 months
mutually aids them. But I digress. Next, I would refrain from "intense hatred" to describe their partnership, especially talking about 22!skk, as the article would suggest. They work together without being forced to, they trust eachother (corruption, prison arc)
1
2
91
@yogobog
yogo𓆝
3 months
and have been shown simply having fun, laughing at each other's jokes, and teasing each other without any real distain.
1
2
88
@yogobog
yogo𓆝
3 months
Again, never got along is not true, they had many moments of fun or peace or understanding, without antagonising each other.
Tweet media one
1
2
89
@yogobog
yogo𓆝
3 months
Now this is just flat out wrong and very mischaraterizing. During Stormbringer, the novel straight up about Chuuya's humanity or inhumanity, Dazai was the first to deny any chance of Chuuya not being a human. He makes sure even in the middle of the worst battle
Tweet media one
1
5
101
@yogobog
yogo𓆝
3 months
in Yokohama for a long time, Chuuya can make a choice about preserving the records of his humanity, while being sure Chuuya is human.
1
2
74
@yogobog
yogo𓆝
3 months
This again is very odd. By the nature of corruption, Chuuya can not disable it and will die after a while. The only method to stop it is Dazai's ability. I personally wouldn't call it "minimal trust" to place your life, (and those you'd otherwise kill) in the
Tweet media one
1
2
84
@yogobog
yogo𓆝
3 months
hand of the man you "hate" but that might just be me. Not even mentioning the prison arc, where they both had to trust each other without any communication during the plan in prison where they had to bring down Dostoyevsky.
1
2
78
@yogobog
yogo𓆝
3 months
Okay, we got through the main article, I'm ignoring the synopsis bc I will have to check it through more in depth, going to relationships now.
1
1
61
@yogobog
yogo𓆝
3 months
RELATIONSHIPS Verlaine. Well, there's technically only one nitpicky wrong detail here, him and Chuuya "met" when him and Rimbaud freed Chuuya at the Suribachi explosion. Aside from that, maybe just as a Verlaine enjoyer, I find this a bit... lacking, to say the least.
Tweet media one
1
1
58
@yogobog
yogo𓆝
3 months
Mori. It's significantly longer than Verlaine's, but I found no wrong info. No notes, moving on. Okay, maybe could've talked about his manipulation of Chuuya, but I digress.
1
1
58
@yogobog
yogo𓆝
3 months
Rimbaud. Still a lot longer than Verlaine, but the info is okay. Again, no notes. He/she Chuuya truthers, I say hell yeah.
Tweet media one
1
3
73
@yogobog
yogo𓆝
3 months
Kouyou. Seems okay again, no particular notes, but here's a fun fact! In the yakuza, mafioso boss's wives are traditionally called "ane-san".
Tweet media one
Tweet media two
2
3
73
@yogobog
yogo𓆝
3 months
The flags. There's no analysis, only quotes, so I can't nitpick anything.
1
1
56
@yogobog
yogo𓆝
3 months
Dazai. Oh lord here we go. I find it a bit odd that this paragraph is a much better (albeit still antagonizing) analysis of the two. It's a bit uncoordinated with the first, god awful take on them. Again the hate comes up, but at least their relationship is said to be deep now.
Tweet media one
Tweet media two
1
1
63
@yogobog
yogo𓆝
3 months
This is very subjective, but imo it's quite obvious that Dazai's departure was not this simple. However, anyone is free to have their own takes on this as there isn't a canon timeline, so I wouldn't call it incorrect, it's just bugs me a bit
Tweet media one
1
1
54
@yogobog
yogo𓆝
3 months
not true! Dazai has been confirmed to partly be caught by the pm because he wanted to put Chuuya between a rock and a hard place, and he could've escaped before, so he did in fact want to interact.
Tweet media one
1
2
55
@yogobog
yogo𓆝
3 months
to give credits, this last few paragraphs are okay, albeit (imo) still water down their trust a bit.
Tweet media one
1
1
47
@yogobog
yogo𓆝
3 months
the others (ada, sheep) are fine or not very important so I won't go over them. HOWEVER having nothing on N and Adam is criminal (there's nothing below the ss)
Tweet media one
2
1
57
@yogobog
yogo𓆝
3 months
aand with that we're done! the moral of the story is that we need to update the wiki and anybody who hasn't read Stormbringer is not qualified to talk about bsd
Tweet media one
1
7
87