Except we do go by secret identities. It’s how we distinguish each character. You’ll never see Miles Morales thrown into a Peter Parker debate but he will be there when in a Spider-Man debate. Just stfu Steve, whoever the fuck you are.
Yall keep popping in going “she wasnt Selina” but no— i mean NO superhero list ever just goes “oh we just doing secret identity confirmations only”. It is always by mantle. Always. And Halle Barry played a character holding a mantle.