they claim to want a more “book accurate” rhaenyra then fancast a thin actress. you don’t want book rhaenyra you want a cishet rhaenyra with certain features that emma doesn’t have. it’s not about book accuracy it’s 100% just projecting and hating emma
and emma is the best targaryen casting there’s ever been like they embody the unique beauty the valyrians are said to have but they’re not cis and have poisoning opinions on rhaenyra’s character so they’re replaced in au gifsets with a more “fitting” actress