Happy Robert E. Lee Day!
Today is the twenty-ninth and final day of my month long heritage history posts in which I offer a few somewhat arbitrary reflections on important figures from our past. The entire point of this series was to counter-signal the ethos and spirit of the…
This post is predictably now drawing in the haters. So let me clarify something about my celebration of Lee:
He was a better man than anyone alive today, he was a hero, and no emotional display of outrage will convince me otherwise.
Robert E Lee today, Robert E Lee forever.
@contramordor
General Lee may well be the greatest American ever to live. A fantastic choice, C.Jay and a supremely satisfying capstone to your month-long work. Thank you for all you do.
@contramordor
As a fellow West Pointer he should have taken the offer or resigned. He was a traitor to the Union. Full stop. Stop glorifying him. Do I forgive him? Of course. But he doesn’t get to be glorified. Period. This wasn’t a minor “flaw” like some northerner owning slaves.
@contramordor
‘his people and their well-being always meant more to him than any ideological crusade’
Translation: Black People didn’t count.
Racism is not an ‘ordered love’. It is anti-Gospel. Don’t celebrate people who, faced with the question “But who is my neighbor?” disagree with Jesus.
@EffTexas
He defended the well-being and integrity of the property owners, the institutions, and the traditions of the South. This reflects the historically unavoidable reality that politics is about the clash of elites.
@contramordor
My grandfather swore to us all his life we descended from Robert E. Lee. I’ve never been able to prove it, but would certainly take it as a point of pride. He was an honorable man who stood firm in a difficult time. An excellent capstone to this project. I’ve enjoyed reading.
@contramordor
Truly a great American and a member of the Pantheon of All time great generals. Even if I think he was misguided (from the comfort of 21st century suburbia) I respect him as a man