Bungie: We don’t see the Halo expanded universe as canon.
Also Bungie: We’re going to use really specific things from the expanded universe like Spartan-IIIs for Reach and make contextualizing this game a nightmare for fans later on.
Can’t imagine why I like 343’s approach.
@VincentGat
It’s the same coin in a way with 343. Bungie rushes forward without thinking and 343 is sometimes too cautious about their direct and second guesses. Let’s get some middle ground.
@DecepticonCobra
It works if you see at FOR as being influences by ONI propaganda.
What’s more heroic? A bunch of Spartans giving their lives to try and save the planet? Or Kat getting sniped because she wasn’t wearing her helmet?
And the S-IIIs were still heavily redacted at the time of FOR.
@DecepticonCobra
Let’s not forget bridging the gaps between CE and Halo 2 and explaining it with “It’s classified” in Halo 2. Or Chief jumping from the Dreadnaught at the start of Halo 3 with zero explanation why after we saw him on it ready to fight his way to Truth in Halo 2’s ending.
@DecepticonCobra
The one that got to me back in the day was
Bungie: ‘the games are our only canon,’
Me: how did Johnson and chief get to earth in H2?,’
Bungie: ‘here’s a book called first strike...,’
@DecepticonCobra
@haruspis
...okay so did the PoA have the 20+ S-IIs in the PoA when it was docked at the shipyard waiting for Noble Team? Did they pick them up later? Was them being docked at the shipyards come before or after they left to do RED FLAG? Like... whats going on there.
@DecepticonCobra
Once 343 embraced the expanded universe, it made everything more simple. I do enjoy Bungie's way of putting as much lore content into the game as possible through dialogue, reverences, and terminals, but I like that when 343 got on board they're all "yeah that stuff is canon now"